Why would CR hate anyone? They call it how it is because they are not paid off by Apple (or other companies) like most internet reviewers.
Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Consumer Reports: Google Home Max and Sonos One Sound Better Than HomePod
- Thread starter MacRumors
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
Why would CR hate anyone? They call it how it is because they are not paid off by Apple (or other companies) like most internet reviewers.
CR has a financial motive as well. Just not the model you're referring to. A model that depends of click bait and selling some sort of financial packages. I'm also a paying member of CR, so I'm not biased. I have a financial interest in CRs work. But I have also seen them play their consumers and the media specifically. They are not saints and have a financial interest at stake too. They ARE selling a product.
CR isn't worth even a glance anymore. They haven't been relevant in at least 5 years. I wish news outlets would stop giving them undeserved publicity. There are far better consumer reviews to be found in every corner of the internet nowadays.
Of all the negative reviews of the sound (and they're not negative reviews of the sound overall, more like criticisms), 1 remarked that there are zones where the sound is not quite right, 1 said that the midrange or upper tones were not "balanced." the other said that the placement of the HomePod can affect quality.
But all these reviews have been generally positive about the sound quality.
But all these reviews have been generally positive about the sound quality.
Since you brought this up, can you tell me which reviewers were flown out to Apple, and most importantly, which HomePod reviews were written based entirely on the reviewers’ impressions formed in Cupertino?
Did they test in a sound absorbing room so the speaker couldn't calibrate? For this speaker, they should test in various room environments.
There was a time, back in the 80's I believe, where you could trust CR. You have to be a complete dolt to pay attention to CR anymore.
The way I see it, is you will have those who are partial to Apple because you are frequenting an Apple related website. I think having options is good with Sonos and the Google home Max, it creates competition and diversity. And I think in order for the HomePod to thrive, it’s nice for consumers to choose what works best for their home. Everybody has their own preference, but the HomePod really is a great sounding device regardless of how someone chooses to judge it.
This is totally funny. Just a few months ago CR issued a report that was negative to the Microsoft Surface line in comparison to Macbooks, and 99% of the posts were praising CR. Now when they say something against Apple 99% of the posts bash CR.
So much objectivity!
Personally, I have been consistent in my criticism of CR as being of little value after I subscribed with them for a period of time during which I was shopping for things they are traditionally good at reviewing - cars, appliances, mattresses, etc.. and found they were of little value.
So much objectivity!
Personally, I have been consistent in my criticism of CR as being of little value after I subscribed with them for a period of time during which I was shopping for things they are traditionally good at reviewing - cars, appliances, mattresses, etc.. and found they were of little value.
Consumer Reports reminds me of Snopes.... All fake news.
For real news: https://www.reddit.com/r/audiophile/comments/7wwtqy/apple_homepod_the_audiophile_perspective/
For real news: https://www.reddit.com/r/audiophile/comments/7wwtqy/apple_homepod_the_audiophile_perspective/
Last edited:
I have heard the Google Max but unfortunately it was in a retail store which was not an ideal setting. I have yet to hear the Sonos or HomePod so I will keep my opinion comparing them all to myself at this time. However, for whatever reason it does appear that Consumer Reports has an issue with Apple. But whatever.
I think what you meant to say is, "Nice to hear from someone who actually confirms my confirmation bias."
Nothing against @jamesdc , but you have no idea if he's really who he says he is. Even if he is 100% everything he says he is (and I have no reason to doubt he is), that does not mean his opinion of what sounds good is any more valid than your opinion or mine. James could have horrible taste in sound. He could be a mumble rap producer. Or a country music artist. You've simply gravitated to something that reinforces your already held beliefs. We all (me included) do it from time to time. It's not a rarity on here.
I'll go with this. Summary: Love the sound, hate Siri. Pretty much the consensus.
https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/201...mepod-say-it-sounds-better-than-1000-speaker/
-=HomePod Owner=-
https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/201...mepod-say-it-sounds-better-than-1000-speaker/
-=HomePod Owner=-
I see you are a reasonable bunch
Less than stellar review comes out and the response is attack! “fake news, biased Apple haters, rag mag”.
Well done.
Less than stellar review comes out and the response is attack! “fake news, biased Apple haters, rag mag”.
Well done.
I think that listening to classical music through Apple Music which, uses compressed quality, is not exactly a great idea in the first place. That’s like saying, “hey, let’s listen to the new Stones album on my stereo speaker iPhone”. It’s just wrong. People who actually love music will understand.
That very well could be. I hope that is the case.
Thought, if that is the case, then Apple fans still are justified in their anger at Apple for releasing a product which is half-baked and unfinished.
I had to look up Allen St. John to see who he was.
And it turns out he’s an editor on Bike magazine. He also writes about sports and pop culture. That’s who I want testing audio equipment, a sports guy.
And it turns out he’s an editor on Bike magazine. He also writes about sports and pop culture. That’s who I want testing audio equipment, a sports guy.
Read the classical thread. There are people streaming lossless over AirPlay. As for you comparison, ridiculous.
Then you're only read fan-boy reviews. I have seen plenty of mixed reviews.
Personally, I think people should go to specialized reviewers instead of the one size fits all CR.
More like:
Unlike most other reviewers, CR isn't afraid that Apple won't let them get an early product look next time if they don't praise it.
