The headphones are not crappy, in fact for certain music I prefer the treble boost they have.
A lot of obnoxious people saying they are just plain crappy are just trying be cool.
These people probably listen to only one genre of music or something.
There are also even people out there who laugh at people for paying for Beats by Dre as well.
First you have to mention what you listen to. For pop music the Apple headphones are delicious.
They are very crisp around 2-10K. The upsides are that melody and vocals will sound like they are deep inside your head. The downsides is they can't handle much bass and they might be too boosted for certain genres.
But of course the simpleton just uses the word crappy.
There are upsides and downsides to Beats by Dre headphones. The upsides is that it creates a very overdone, yet funky bass feeling combined with the suction cupping of the cans can be a cool listening experience. They are not that accurate like monitor cans or even balanced like other brands. But they are certainly not crappy either and are fun to listen to.
If I was listening to pop, the Apples are great. If I was listening to gangsta rap, the Beats are great. I personally have many different headphones, speakers, and monitors, including headphone monitors.
All of them have different sounds and advantages and disadvantages for listening.
The Apple headphones are pretty crack and can make music addictive. Just like how things are overly compressed on the radio but they still sound great. This is also why you see a lot of people with the white iconic headphones. Obviously the masses think they sound pretty damn great for now.
Most of the comments are from audiophiles who think its cool to be snobby. If you're so smart, you would give an accurate rendering of pros and cons instead of resorting to saying they are crappy when they do have some merit.
Go buy some 3$ headphones from a flea market. Now thats crap. Apple headphones are far from crap.