Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

ironsienna

macrumors regular
Original poster
Oct 28, 2010
215
0
I really like the stripy background on the folders or on the various apps like pages and ibooks. It is subtle and it has a kinda warm feeling.

But now that they tried to use it as the main background of the notification system, I think it looks completely tacky.

notification-center-ios5-333x500.png
20110612-122101.jpg



They have overlaid with photoshop a white gradient on top to make it look less homogenous but at the same time, this difference of light (bright on top and dark on bottom) along with the little lines and the increased contrast makes it look utterly dirty.

And the fact that the notifications are displayed with tiny white text and without their own background in front of this messy thing makes the whole design concept completely un-Apple and amateurish.

And ok, lets say that they are using this specific background because they try to provide a more organic feeling to the overall UI. Why all these semi transparent bits (especially at the title of each app) and the COMPLETELY transparent background in each notification..! I really question the skills of the graphics designer that took the decision to display text with thin fonts in front of a high contrast and varied in light background. Where did the taste of the Apple GUI designers go? What are they thinking?

In the end it looks like a cheap immitation of the great design from Teehanlax

iphone_home.jpg

I am sorry for the tone of the post, but till now the taste of Apple GUI designers, reflected on their GUIs was a guideline for my designs. I personally spent more than a month trying to find the most appropriate size and contrast for the elements of the list of my app, constantly redesigning it so that it looks nice even with the brushed metal as background (I am not mentioning the name of the app cause I don't want some people here to think I am trying to promote it). And yet again, I am still not fully satisfied with it and I need to further improve it.

screenshot20110613at150.png


I really can say if someone really spent a lot of time on a GUI or if they just did a quick and dirty job (I have a Masters in HCI). And notifications are the most important new feature of iOS5. They should provide a landmark design for it. I remember Steve Jobs trademarked the exact shade of grey of the Apple II computer back in the days. Where did that passion go? I would appreciate any other opinions on it, which style do you prefer more? Which one do you think looks cleaner and more professional?
 
Last edited:
I, too, am not a fan of the excessive use of the fabric texture. The texture is currently used for expanded folders and the multitasking "drawer", which are presented as a layer behind the home screen. I think it's better to choose a different texture for Notification Center which acts more like an overlay on top of the home screen.
 
Last edited:
I agree. For a company that makes the most beautiful hardware on the planet, sometimes their UI design is a little strange. That Teehanlax design is beautiful!
 
I agree. For a company that makes the most beautiful hardware on the planet, sometimes their UI design is a little strange. That Teehanlax design is beautiful!

I totally agree with that, however they might change it before they ship iOS 5. I have no idea.
 
I personally love it. I think it looks great, especially on the retina display. I don't find them "messy" or "utterly dirty" or "un-Apple and amateurish" or "a cheap imitation".
 
Wirelessly posted (Mozilla/5.0 (iPhone; U; CPU iPhone OS 4_3_3 like Mac OS X; en-us) AppleWebKit/533.17.9 (KHTML, like Gecko) Version/5.0.2 Mobile/8J2 Safari/6533.18.5)

I'm not fussed and have seen worst.
 
I don't hate it, but I'm not in love with it. If it looked like the version made by Teehanlax, that would be awesome.
 
This kind of decoration (and also ornamentation) is rife, not just in iOS but in business presentations etc. However, I do wish people would consider those of us who are visually impaired or dyslexic. Putting a texture behind text reduces the contrast and makes the job of visually decoding the information harder. It makes no sense....
 
I don't necessarily think it looks bad, but I also don't think it fits with the rest of the UI...

and those 3 lines on the bottom, those do look bad
 
I don't necessarily think it looks bad, but I also don't think it fits with the rest of the UI...

and those 3 lines on the bottom, those do look bad

I think the three lines would be more appropriate if the NC didn't snap to the bottom or top of screen.
 
This is only the first beta... I seem to remember them changing the folder background and task switcher background last year with the final release.
 
Nope, I've been fine with it and I use it every day. I suspect there will be minor changes before release, though. This is such a banner feature that it will receive a lot of love before release.
 
I don't have the beta loaded onto my phone so I'm not looking at it day in and day out. Given that little tidbit, I'm not really having any issues with the UI at all. It appears to me that apple is trying to provide a neutral look towards it. Maybe it will change in subsequent betas maybe it won't. Only time will tell.
 
I don't have the beta loaded onto my phone so I'm not looking at it day in and day out. Given that little tidbit, I'm not really having any issues with the UI at all. It appears to me that apple is trying to provide a neutral look towards it. Maybe it will change in subsequent betas maybe it won't. Only time will tell.

I'm fine with the UI too, for the most part.
 
I couldn't say. I haven't seen it.

And no, seeing a screenshot doesn't count. The time I've spent downloading iPhone wallpapers has taught me one thing: Things always look different on the iPhone's screen than they did on my computer's screen. Besides the pixel density there's also contrast and brightness differences that make things look differently once I've sent them to my phone.

Yeah, there are some colorful, high-contrast things that look the same on any screen. Angry Birds, for example. But those light hash-marks mixed with a gradient are prime candidates for being very susceptible to slight differences in the screen you're viewing it on.

So basically I'll have no opinion 'till iOS 5 officially comes out.
 
I actually love it. Refreshing move move away from the bog standard black/white panes. It's easy on the eyes and legible whilst looking organic.
 
Beta 1....

I think the fabric texture graphics are trying to show off how nice the retina screen is.

Agreed.. On an iPhone 4 with high res screen it looks beautiful I think. When I look at it on my iPad it definitely doesn't look as nice, and some solid background would help text legibility.
 
I, too, am not a fan of the excessive use of the fabric texture. The texture is currently used for expanded folders and the multitasking "drawer", which are presented as a layer behind the home screen. I think it's better to choose a different texture for Notification Center which acts more like an overlay on top of the home screen.

Or, god forbid, let us choose a custom background for it.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.