Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

MacRumors

macrumors bot
Original poster


As Epic Games prepares for its upcoming bench trial with Apple, the company has today published depositions that it conducted with several executives, including current iTunes chief Eddy Cue and former software engineering chief Scott Forstall.

fortnite-apple-logo-2.jpg
 
Last edited:
a mention by Steve Jobs that at its inception, the App Store wasn't designed to make money for Apple.

And there we have it. Jobs won't ever have a chance to be clearer, but it sure sounds like Jobs never intended for the App Store (or "Services") to be how Apple made money. Apple makes money by selling hardware which comes with great software included. They operate a store and an API that is supposed to make it easy for developers to make apps and for customers to receive apps, and they don't want it to be a money losing operation so obviously some small fees need to be collected, but at the end of the day, everything about the store should be in service of selling hardware.

And when the store gets in the way, alternative options should exist.

Apple never limited us to only putting music and videos from iTunes on the iPod - we could get them from anywhere, and Apple couldn't care less whether we pirated them or not. Their argument was that we could find the stuff on the iTunes store easier than via piracy, and so naturally it'd make sense for us to use it, but they didn't actually care. Jobs went as far as arguing against DRM and making everything about iTunes DRM free, so that everything would "just work". That was totally against the idea of them caring about making money via the store - only one person needed to buy it from iTunes, DRM free, and then they could distribute it however they wanted enabling piracy.

Apple gave developers an easy way to make money via iAds. Developers were free to use it, or not, and overwhelmingly they didn't.

In-App Purchases is the first time where Apple got super different about it - suddenly it wasn't about giving developers and users more and better choices. Suddenly Apple wanted to force everyone into giving them money.

Yeah, maybe the App Store was different, too, but I think that was intended to be short term, while Apple worked on their security model - if Jobs hadn't died, we would have seen Apple bring Gate Keeper from the Mac over to iOS 8 years ago.
 
Maybe if iMessage had been released on Android, I could finally get off this GD group thread that has Android users in it.
If Apple opened up iMessage to Android users it’s highly likely I wouldn’t have to use Facebook Messenger, WhatsApp or Signal either!

I truly believe that the creation of a scaled down version of Messages for Android would lead to more adoption of it as a “standard” messaging platform and actually drive iPhone sales rather than hurt them. But then again, I don’t have a masters degree in Sales and Marketing from Berkeley… just a modicum of common sense.
 
And there we have it. Jobs won't ever have a chance to be clearer, but it sure sounds like Jobs never intended for the App Store (or "Services") to be how Apple made money. Apple makes money by selling hardware which comes with great software included. They operate a store and an API that is supposed to make it easy for developers to make apps and for customers to receive apps, and they don't want it to be a money losing operation so obviously some small fees need to be collected, but at the end of the day, everything about the store should be in service of selling hardware.

And when the store gets in the way, alternative options should exist.

Apple never limited us to only putting music and videos from iTunes on the iPod - we could get them from anywhere, and Apple couldn't care less whether we pirated them or not. Their argument was that we could find the stuff on the iTunes store easier than via piracy, and so naturally it'd make sense for us to use it, but they didn't actually care. Jobs went as far as arguing against DRM and making everything about iTunes DRM free, so that everything would "just work". That was totally against the idea of them caring about making money via the store - only one person needed to buy it from iTunes, DRM free, and then they could distribute it however they wanted enabling piracy.

Apple gave developers an easy way to make money via iAds. Developers were free to use it, or not, and overwhelmingly they didn't.

In-App Purchases is the first time where Apple got super different about it - suddenly it wasn't about giving developers and users more and better choices. Suddenly Apple wanted to force everyone into giving them money.

Yeah, maybe the App Store was different, too, but I think that was intended to be short term, while Apple worked on their security model - if Jobs hadn't died, we would have seen Apple bring Gate Keeper from the Mac over to iOS 8 years ago.
According to the Article Jobs did not want 3rd party apps to run natively at all, so developers would have been running web apps like the first iPhones, so there would have been no ecosystems platform to build and sustain and no mechanism to make money. Also, Remember most App are free so they make nothing on them. If developers make money from their platform Apple should make their percentage.
 
Apple has disrupted traditional tech markets many times over and continues to do so. These companies are trying to sacrifice Apple's innovative and profitable model for their own financial gain. They're hoping if they can create enough smoke, some judge/jury somewhere may think there's a fire.

"I have a hard time believing that we would call it Apple having a monopoly on its own product." -Shannon Bird
 
IMO, if Jobs had won the debate he was having with Forstall, the iPhone would have died a relatively quick death, perhaps lasting ONLY 3 years AFTER FCS.

webOS would have become the dominate mobile OS !

IMO, it is precisely Apple's Dev infrastructure that has enabled the iPhone & the iPad to become so dominate.

And much of it came from NeXT, Inc.
 
Texting someone on an Android phone is the worst experience ever. Blackberry and Apple got it right... Google still hasn't. I've tried Google's app and plenty of 3rd party apps and they're all ugly interfaces. The junk keyboards on Android phones don't help the cause either.

Android emojis (I know plenty of people who use them) were also a joke until recently.

The crappy texting and typing experience in general always pushes me back to iPhone.
 
I'm an App publisher and I make good money from the App Store. One misunderstanding that is pervasive amongst App Store users is that App publishers, like myself, can issue refunds and have control over the payment system.
Every so often I'll get an app support email saying something like "I would like a refund this app was downloaded by accident". (yeah, sure...)
Being able to re-direct them to Apple's support people is worth the 15% alone.
The other great benefits I get are 1) not having to collect local/national sales tax 2) offering payment in local currency and no currency exchange overhead. 3) dealing with credit card companies, paying outrageous "charge back" fees/fines etc
Those 4 things alone are worth 15%.
If you are paying 30% WTF are you crying about? I wish I was in the 30% category.
 
Last edited:
Why? Why can't Apple offer great hardware and services and tools for others to drive the platform without taking a cut from everything?

Why should Apple?

I don’t see what is so controversial about App Store profitability. You mean to tell me that the App Store model would suddenly be okay if it were to break even or even be run at a loss?

Epic is clearly grasping at straws here.
 
In-App Purchases is the first time where Apple got super different about it - suddenly it wasn't about giving developers and users more and better choices. Suddenly Apple wanted to force everyone into giving them money.
Because app devs would always circumvent the AppStore, and it would eventually become a loss leader. Apple is still a for profit company and should be able to run its own models without having regulators breath down their necks. Apple is not a monopoly by any standard, but it has very successful business models.
 
Why? Why can't Apple offer great hardware and services and tools for others to drive the platform without taking a cut from everything?
It costs money to build and OS, tools like Xcode, run the servers that host the app downloads ect. Did you know that a lot of coding ide tools / libraries are often $1500-$4000? Apple is giving Xcode away. They are recouping the cost.
 
Ahhh so close on iMessage, wish they had. Still think Apple could change their minds there (they do, do that sometimes).

Also gotta throw out that I think keeping end 2 end encrypted iMessage only on Apple also kept the Government dogs back some (just like not E2E encrypting iCloud backups, which they were originally going to do) - a good chunk of androidies in the U.S. just use SMS which the Feds really like.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.