Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
People seem to be confusing the design system with "transparency" — that's not it. Liquid Glass isn't about transparency, it's about the light affecting elements like they were made of glass — and glass can be transparent, opaque, and all stops in between. It's about the elements in space and how they interact with reflections, and refractions over perceived light, but transparency isn't the cornerstone of it. It's an oversimplification... like saying Material Design is only about replicating stacks of digital paper.
But Liquid Glass does have transparency (really translucency) as one of its main design features, in addition to emulating light reflecting off of glassy UI elements. The main complaint many people have with Liquid Glass isn't with its reflection simulations, but with this transparency effect, since even in its more toned-down versions, it allows too much of what's behind a UI element to bleed through and make what you're supposed to be focusing on, in the UI element, require needless extra effort to distinguish from the stuff that's bleeding through.
 
I still don’t understand the concerns about legibility. I’ve seen some cherry-picked screenshots showing a very light background, Liquid Glass notifications, and white text. Yes, that is a poor accessibility scenario, and the system should automatically provide darker text for contrast. However, I think people confuse legibility (“the quality of being clear enough to read”) with decreased contrast (“the state of being strikingly different from something else in juxtaposition or close association”) due to greater transparency of Liquid Glass. The system generally handles text color well with varying backgrounds. I bet you can read the text. You just don’t like the “distraction”.

It’s not like you’re looking at your phone from feet away; If you struggle to read the text on a phone in your hand, increase the text size in Display settings. iOS has also had Reduce Transparency and Increase Contrast accessibility settings for ages. If the new design is too overwhelming for you, use these features.

The issue is not legibility. It’s people forcing their opinion to have a flat, stagnant UI on others, when they already have a way to opt out.

Even beta 1 was “legible”. Ignore the frutiger aero theming:
[edit: removed Insta link with invalid permissions]
 
Last edited:
I sense there may be some internal struggle going on at Apple between those writing the HIG, who care about things like UX, consistency, readability and accessibility, and the pixel-pushers who like to demonstrate the capabilities of the platform and show off flashy visual effects.
That's been true, to varying degrees, since the first releases of OS X. With OS 9, 8, 7, etc., Apple stuck with some pretty good, consistent HIG (Human Interface Guidelines, for those who don't know), but when OS X was released, they said developers now had more flexibility in where some buttons were placed, some aspects of the appearance of UI elements, menu arrangement, etc. They said it was time to experiment. This was a nice idea in theory, but the actual effect was that some (many?) developers produced apps with non-intuitive, inconsistent interfaces that were sometimes unpleasant to use. Apple eventually straightened things out fairly well, but now the themers have gotten control again. Not that this is bad, but it needs to be done right to not be bad.
 
To answer the hyberbole. It looks like very few actually used beta 3 so far.

Apple simply adjusted readability in light mode vs dark mode . Glass is still there, PROMINENTLY. 90% of users in first 3 pages didnt even use the beta before replying...apparently neither did the author of the article :)

 
  • Like
Reactions: stiligFox
I feel sorry for the staff who now have to redo tones of design documentation and videos now.
 
These are cool and all but can we get multiple private spaces? Sometimes called multiple users? Thank you
 
To answer the hyberbole. It looks like very few actually used beta 3 so far.

Apple simply adjusted readability in light mode vs dark mode . Glass is still there, PROMINENTLY. 90% of users in first 3 pages didnt even use the beta before replying...apparently neither did the author of the article :)

View attachment 2526800
Oh, that looks fine to me!

I did wonder if it would look better in motion. Screen shots really have a hard time really showing off the effect, in any of the betas so far
 
You likely are in dark mode. Dark mode is still the beta 2 version of glassy. If you take it off of dark mode, light mode is mostly frosted plastic with barely a touch of glass. 16 Pro Max.
At least that is what I am seeing on my device. 🤷‍♂️
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: scrtagntman
Every single post in this thread could have been written two months ago. All sane people were expecting the original concept to be toned down before public release. I can’t think of a single serious Apple pundit that did not point this out on the first day.

Most users won’t know how it looked like on reveal, or during beta stage. Most users will only see the final, refined version. Prepare for the public outcry in mainstream media, followed by all the geeks saying “you should have seen the beta!!!”, like anyone actually cares.
 
  • Love
Reactions: Tres
I wish they'd just give up on the redesign and continue with minor tweaks to the current iOS 18 interface.

Seriously, who asked for this? iOS looks fine as it is today.
Well, lots of Macrumors users have been asking for it for years, commenting how the current design looks “stale”. Can’t win ‘em all I guess.
 
And the worst part about this mess is that if you want a new phone, you’re gonna get stuck with this ugly redesign since you can’t install an old iOS on a brand new device. If they don’t make some serious changes, this will be the first year. I don’t get a new phone.
I’ve already decide to get an android this year. Apple lost me after the last year of ****** OS releases. I feel they are about as incompetent as you can get now.
 
  • Angry
Reactions: Tech for Kings
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.