Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Thank you for the pictures and comparison, my brother ordered a copy of the black ops from Jackie Nie and his is by far leaps and bounds a better copy than the all white vapor pro that I've received
 
Thanks for the comparison and the detailed pictures Mr.Scott.

Now that I can see clearly the minute differences between the real one and the fake one, down to the packaging, I am more than happy that I bought 2 fakes ones instead of a real one.
 
Finally got my white one from Cindy. While it looks really good the fit leaves a lot to be desired. It's pretty loose even after sanding down the ends and adding extra felt in the corners. I emailed her so I'll see if she offers any kind of resolution. It looks really nice though. The paint is applied evenly and the two pieces match in color.
 
I ordered the spectra link as there were many color choices that I had to select the sliver and he asked me what color combo I wanted and I told him silver/silver. Based on your pictures, it's hard for me to tell the difference between your Chroma.

I believe you got the Spectra too...


Thanks ... The copy came from the same seller as yours did and it appears to have the same silver finish. Do you remember if you ordered a Spectra or a Chroma?
 
Last edited:
can some one please suggest me a seller? i never bought on aliexpress , and looking at the site its pretty confirming...

any suuggestion would be good. i am looking to buy two cases .. one black and one white.
 
confirming? there are many sellers and links that you can choose from. I highly recommend you spending time and reading previous thread. One person is going to recommend seller A while another person recommend seller B. You need to make your own decision in which seller you want to buy from.

It's not very hard to read and click on the link provided by members. Again, if you have read previous thread, many members, including myself instructed NOT to buy the white one due to quality issue. You should do your homework and read the thread.

can some one please suggest me a seller? i never bought on aliexpress , and looking at the site its pretty confirming...

any suuggestion would be good. i am looking to buy two cases .. one black and one white.
 
can some one please suggest me a seller? i never bought on aliexpress , and looking at the site its pretty confirming...

any suuggestion would be good. i am looking to buy two cases .. one black and one white.

I would suggest to not buy a white one, lots of fitment issues with the white ones

just my $0.02
 
I ordered the spectra link as there were many color choices that I had to select the sliver and he asked me what color combo I wanted and I told him silver/silver. Based on your pictures, it's hard for me to tell the difference between your Chroma.

I believe you got the Spectra too...

Thanks for your reply.

I think you're right and I received this sellers version of Spectra Silver, which is more of a flat satin finish than I expected from his pictures.

Here are the two Silvers as show on the Element Case web site. The seller that I purchased from uses these same pictures on his site.
If you look in the area of the volume buttons you will see that the true Spectra finish should be closer to the silver finish on the iPhone 4/4S band.

attachment.php
 

Attachments

  • SXX0-4.jpg
    SXX0-4.jpg
    55 KB · Views: 4,251
Based on the picture, it looks like the Spectra has more of a brush sliver. The more I look at it, the more I think mine is more of a Chroma line. It's hard to tell which one I got...

Thanks for your reply.

I think you're right and I received this sellers version of Spectra Silver, which is more of a flat satin finish than I expected from his pictures.

Here are the two Silvers as show on the Element Case web site. The seller that I purchased from uses these same pictures on his site.
If you look in the area of the volume buttons you will see that the true Spectra finish should be closer to the silver finish on the iPhone 4/4S band.

Image
 
I don't feel bad for anyone who pays a pretty penny for a "real" one but gets a "fake" one. There's real and fake everything out there...if you do your research and know what to look for then you won't get screwed.

OR...if you cannot tell the difference and have to ASK if it's real or fake then WHO CARES?! It's not a matter of different materials like real diamonds vs fake diamonds. It's aluminum vs aluminum. If you have to ask then it shouldn't matter in your head if it's "real" or not. Right? Does calling it "real" all of a sudden change anything? Nope... It's still an aluminum iPhone case. Real or not.

I paid $60 if you are talking about me. But thanks for your contribution.
 
any idea why the price for the vapor black ops is no longer $24.74??

The past transactions were all at 24.74 for just 1 order. But i tried adding to cart today and it was 27.89.
 
different sellers make their own prices...the fluctuation is based on seller.

any idea why the price for the vapor black ops is no longer $24.74??

The past transactions were all at 24.74 for just 1 order. But i tried adding to cart today and it was 27.89.
 
different sellers make their own prices...the fluctuation is based on seller.

Ah, but it is the same seller. The most expensive one to boot.
Other sellers are selling it at $21 but this one had a few good reviews in this thread
 
Got my 4S today, and also picked up the the Black Ops case from Jacky Lin. I actually got the case a couple of weeks ago, and it took about 2 weeks to get to me. The fit is great, wiggles a little bit on the top right corner, but it only does when i really try to do it. Other than that, it's a great case for the price.
2rgki7o.jpg

t69tok.jpg

2ih49y9.jpg
 
ask the seller why he's charging more than before :) For us members to answer your question, we must have power to read the seller's mind :)

if others are selling it cheaper, then you decide who you want to go with :) none of us can help you.

by the way, I paid $28 for mine :)

Ah, but it is the same seller. The most expensive one to boot.
Other sellers are selling it at $21 but this one had a few good reviews in this thread
 
Just received my 3 cases from Jacky Nie. Ordered on Oct 31, so it took about 2 weeks to arrive with the standard free shipping. Got the blue/black, the silver/black, and the blue/silver/black.
They all fit very tightly with no wiggle at all. Actually thought I was going to strip the screws tightening them so that the pieces met together the way they should.
Only 1 came with the correct screwdriver though. The other 2 had s 5 cent flat head one that did not work. Asked Jacky for the 2 correct ones, but it'll probably cost more to ship than what they are worth, so I am not worried about it.

My GPS is way off now. Can't use it at all as a navigation device. I guess I'll keep the screwdriver on my keyring so that in the rare occasion I am out and actually need a gps device, I can remove the case. Seems silly to have to resort to that, but it is what it is. Gave 2 of the cases to my boys, and now when I use "find my iPhone" to track their devices, they are a good 500 to 1000 yards off at least. I kind of knew that before ordering them anyway. For the price, they are fine. My cell phone signal lost 1 bar, but where I live, it isn't really an issue. Are they as good as the original Element vapor case I had last year???? Nope. But I didn't spend $79 on each one either.

I'll post pics when I take them.
 
Got my Black Ops case from Jacky Nie today. I ordered 11/02 and received it 11/14. I opted for the standard free China Post shipping method. I am ridiculously impressed with the quality of this case. Color/finish is flawless, fit is flawless, I CANNOT see how the "real/authentic" Element case could be better. The ONLY issue I found was that the foam pad in the corner closest to the headphone jack was a little too long and protruded out so it could be seen/somewhat obstructed the headphone jack. A quick slit with an exacto knife fixed that problem. For a seamless fit, I suggest placing the 2 frame pieces on the phone, put all 4 screws in an tighten only 1/2 way, align the 2 frame pieces so everything is lined up perfectly, hold tightly together with your hand, then tighten all 4 screws the rest of the way. Just snug it up, don't over tighten! If you're worried about it coming loose, you could always put a tiny drop of BLUE (NOT red) thread locker on the screws' threads. But I wouldn't bother... FWIW I have a Verizon iPhone 4S (Black), NO antenna band wrap, and just an ugly Zagg invisible shield front screen protector.

Here's some pics:
Image
Image
Image
Image
Image

Here's a couple pics of the only "issue" I found and the solution:
Image
Image

Soooo..whats the deal with taking photos with your pistol? Actually that would make a good thread. Lets all take photos with our pistols.
 
Mine came in yesterday. Sorry no pics, I'll try to get some tonight.

iPhone 4S White.


The element case was perfect. I got the black chroma.
http://www.aliexpress.com/snapshot/103349398.html
On one of the pieces the paint towards the end where both pieces meet is a little off, looks like just primer and no end flat coat.

Over all for the price I paid, amazing piece. Not loose at all, didnt have to make any extra adjustments, looks like the real deal- i've actually seen a REAL element case and I dont think I would be able to tell the real from fake.

Not everything was included with the case, I was missing that little bit of felt to clean off the phone but that was it, I dont care about it. Packaging was pretty impressive.

Overall 9 out of 10.


The Deff IV/Cleave however-
http://www.aliexpress.com/snapshot/103349397.html

Was a little loose. It fits the 4S just fine, though there was rattling on the mute button. The case seemed cheap. Never seen a real Cleave but picking this thing up, you could tell its ... fake. Fitment seemed like the phone would just pop out. And didnt offer a lip so I feel as if the phone is sitting on its glass when i put it down instead of the case. I'm asking for a refund or an exchange- maybe for a white vapor pro or something.

I'd give it 6 out of 10.
 
Last edited:
I hope you realize that these sellers are only making $5 per sale transaction right? Since you stated that it fits fine, then why are you going to ask for a refund or exchange? It's going to cost you $10 of your own money to go that path...both side lose money and the shipping company is the only one making money. Put yourself in his situation. Why don't you put it on eBay and I'm sure people are willing to pay for more than your cost. Think about it...

Keep in mind to the policy...you do NOT get a full refund just because you didn't like it or it was not as described. You can negotiate for a partial refund.

A full refund will be given if the order did not arrive. If the order that you received is not as described, you can also negotiate with the supplier for a part refund. AliExpress is always on hand to mediate if you have a dispute.Learn more

The Deff IV/Cleave however-
http://www.aliexpress.com/snapshot/103349397.html

Was a little loose. It fits the 4S just fine, though there was rattling on the mute button. The case seemed cheap. Never seen a real Cleave but picking this thing up, you could tell its ... fake. Fitment seemed like the phone would just pop out. And didnt offer a lip so I feel as if the phone is sitting on its glass when i put it down instead of the case. I'm asking for a refund or an exchange- maybe for a white vapor pro or something.

I'd give it 6 out of 10.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.