Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Ahhh, I was looking for a thread like this the other day.

My favorite scotch is The Macallan. I have a bottle of double cask and sherry cask, both 12 years old. Very nice stuff.

I’ve only read very good things about Macallan. As I recall it’s listed as a scotch one should try before dying. Haha.

I only started drinking scotch a few years ago and Macallan was on the list to try but didn’t. I probably landed on the Glenmorangie for less cost and unsure I’d developed a taste for scotch. I’m guessing I’d be a Macallan drinker if I had started with it. Fall is closing in on us fast....maybe I’ll buy one in October.
 
I fully intend to purchase a bottle of the 18 year old Macallan, quite possibly around the holidays.

Excellent.

I’ve only read very good things about Macallan. As I recall it’s listed as a scotch one should try before dying. Haha.

I only started drinking scotch a few years ago and Macallan was on the list to try but didn’t. I probably landed on the Glenmorangie for less cost and unsure I’d developed a taste for scotch. I’m guessing I’d be a Macallan drinker if I had started with it. Fall is closing in on us fast....maybe I’ll buy one in October.

There comes a sweet point where cost and quality intersect - as in, you will get extremely good quality for a cost that does not break the bank or your arm or leave your credit card and/or wallet smoking.

For me, for port, that means a 20 year old tawny - this is where the difference in quality between the 20 year old and the 10 year old (which itself, is very good) is noticeable, striking, and well worth the difference in price.

Granted, the 30 and 40 year olds are excellent, sometimes superlative, but, unless I am working abroad - one of the advantages of which tends to be a silly salary, I cannot justify paying the price.

Re whisky, I find 14-18 year olds to be the sweet spot in terms of price and quality;

In common with many others, I drank some ghastly stuff - cheap, nasty, horrible hangovers - as a student, and didn't touch whisky for years, decades, until I was sent to central Asia for the best part of two years a few years ago.

Our small bar had a rather nice tradition whereby people returning from leave would donate a bottle of really good whisky (they also accepted decent cognacs) - such as Macallan 18 year old, Glanmorangie 18 year old, and so on to the bar; over time, they amassed an enviable collection. A glass would set you back $5-6 €5-6, and it was rather nice to have one occasionally as a night cap after a beer.

That was where I learned to appreciate good scotch, and tasted some whiskies I had never even laid eyes on, but I am by no means an expert.
 
Last edited:
A shrink friend of mine ordered a gift for me, without my prior knowledge, and it arrived today. A t-shirt about how I love scotch. It came from the UK and oddly smells like vinegar. o_O

IMG_8473.JPG
 
A shrink friend of mine ordered a gift for me, without my prior knowledge, and it arrived today. A t-shirt about how I love scotch. It came from the UK and oddly smells like vinegar. o_O

View attachment 777991

That is a lovely (and most thoughtful) not to mention a very apt, gift from your shrink friend. Enjoy wearing it, and please pass on my best regards to him.
 
I ran out of the regular scotch last night and resorted to some Johnny Walker Black tucked in the back. I’m not a snob really I’m not, but jeeezzzz. It tasted like rusty nails.

So out of frustration I poured it out and logged into Total Wine and had them set back two bottles (and a few creame de cacao).

Home Sweet Home

37B196D7-B64B-4172-B864-2455CA502B07.jpeg
 
I ran out of the regular scotch last night and resorted to some Johnny Walker Black tucked in the back. I’m not a snob really I’m not, but jeeezzzz. It tasted like rusty nails.

So out of frustration I poured it out and logged into Total Wine and had them set back two bottles (and a few creame de cacao).

Home Sweet Home

View attachment 781426
I don't think you have to be a snob to enjoy a good drink. If something tastes like rusty nails then you shouldn't need to drink it. I look at it the same way I do most everything else, 'if you like it, that's what matters most'. Screw the rest!

I'm glad you posted this too. I just ordered a bottle of The Macallan: Edition No 4 this evening.
Screen Shot 2018-09-13 at 7.44.52 PM.png
 
Been on a roll with bourbon and rye based mixed drinks, tonight a traditional Old Fashion with Knob Creek rye.


A shrink friend of mine ordered a gift for me, without my prior knowledge, and it arrived today. A t-shirt about how I love scotch. It came from the UK and oddly smells like vinegar. o_O

View attachment 777991

Looking through my two displays from my office I can see Ron Burgundy off in the distance. on the wall ...
 
  • Like
Reactions: Gutwrench and S.B.G
I have a bottle of Knob Creek! A buddy loves it.

I have a pretty standard rotation of bourbons and rye, depending on the price, then occasionally I'll spring for something unique, but usually here at the WorldHQ we have one of these usual: 4 Roses (small batch), Buffalo Trace, Knob Creek, Elijah Craig (12 Year), Bulleit Frontier - sometimes Rye from the same companies, then I'll pick up something like Hudson, or Woodford Double.

Mostly I drink these with ginger beer, or as some mix drink.
 
Ever since I sneaked into my parents' liquor cabinet many years ago and found a bottle of 16 year old Lagavulin it was love at first sip. My father had gotten that bottle as a birthday present, and he couldn't, and still can't stand the taste. That being said, anytime there's something to celebrate he will still join me for a dram or two.

Gosh, I'm getting that sweet smokey flavour in my mouth just writing this. As a rule there are two bottles in my "liquor cabinet" at all times. A bottle of Lagavulin, and one of Jim Beam.
 
JW Black is just, to me, a very generic blended scotch with a smoky front and a medicinal finish. For day to day drinking, it's fine. If you want something more nuanced and diverse, you'll want to opt for a better quality blend or a single malt. Or if you have access to good American bourbons, then that. At any one time we've probably got anywhere from 30-50 bottles in the house. Company, events, special days, etc. These days I probably have a drink 3-4 times a month versus 2-3 times a week. A combination of wanting to drink less and not really having the time to sit back, put a record on and relax.

I mean if you can find it for a minimal price different, opt for JW Gold. But my honest opinion, and having been around JW for a long time and several dozen bottles, skip the blue and green labels. Your money is best spent on a single malt at that price point and tasting notes. You can also try Irish whiskies. They're phenomenal.
 
I don't think you have to be a snob to enjoy a good drink. If something tastes like rusty nails then you shouldn't need to drink it. I look at it the same way I do most everything else, 'if you like it, that's what matters most'. Screw the rest!

I'm glad you posted this too. I just ordered a bottle of The Macallan: Edition No 4 this evening.
View attachment 781436

Macallan is on my radar! Enjoy.

Might I recommend Yellow Spot to you both; a lovely smooth whiskey.

Another whiskey I have sipped, sampled, and savoured in recent times, is the Redbreast Lustau Edition (a whiskey which for the final stage - "the final period of maturation" - has been matured in casks seasoned by Oloroso sherry from the Lustau Bodegas).
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Gutwrench and S.B.G
Bourbon is my drink on occasion. :) Can you put into words what what you like about it? My favorite bourbon at this moment is Wild Turkey.

It's manages to be smooth and crispy without being sweet, my go-to has always been Jim Beam but recently it's started to give me heart burn so I've been looking for something new
 
  • Like
Reactions: Huntn
To ruin everyone's scotch talk

I bought a bottle of Bird Dog bourbon the other day and it's fast becoming my favorite

Bourbon is my drink on occasion. :) Can you put into words what what you like about it? My favorite bourbon at this moment is Wild Turkey.

I purchased a bottle of Bird Dog (small batch) today and it stuck me favorably, although I still prefer Wild Turkey at this point. Sometimes a new brand of whisky grows on me, So I’ll report any changes instatus. :)

 
  • Like
Reactions: Gutwrench
I'm European, so my whiskies of choice tend to hail from Ireland or Scotland (both countries produce some superb whiskies).

Any thoughts (or recommendations) on or about Japanese whisky? I've heard some excellent accounts and read some very good reports on the whiskies that are available from there.
 
  • Like
Reactions: S.B.G
Whoever curates or stocks the booze section of my local supermarket really knows their scotch and has great taste. I picked up another bottle of The Macallan 12 years old Double Cask today and there was a sign indicating it was an 'expert pick'.

View attachment 781978

Wow, Highland Park and I think Balvenie we’re both on the Scotch Bucket List too, but I don’t remember which one. (And I can’t find it, although there’s many lists available.)
 
  • Like
Reactions: S.B.G
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.