fully agree, the new MBP of course has many aspects that are better than the previous model.
i thought that's out of question. however, it also comes with some drawbacks, some of which i consider totally unneccessary:
a) removed magsafe? facepalm. sure you can buy 3rd party alternatives for usb-c from $29 but that additional adapter just isn't the real thing and those will always be annoying during transport. just can't find any excuses for removing magsafe. magsafe was one of THE beautiful clever things that was simply better on mac than on all other laptops. not having that clever magnet makes you feel stupid three times: first not having it in first place, second having to pay $29+ for getting it back, third having to carry around that magnet adapter ;-)
b) ports - usb-c might be future proof but we are also willing to use that laptop today. without (!) adapters for literally everything! it could be future proof offering 2 usb-c ports while still offering e.g. 1-2 usb 3 ports and hdmi ... i don't think there is anything wrong about usb-c at all. it's future proof? yes. is it a hassle today not having at least one usb 3.0? - yes.
c) missing 32gb option. 16 gb limit. NOT apple's fault, of course. but it's still there, due to intels limitation. this limit will go away next year most likely and is one reason to be waiting for the next one. while there is absolutely nothing wrong about 16GB today, it makes that book a bad investment (for me, personally). i have been running 16 gb for years, and for today thats enough for me. i don't know about 2020 though and most likely i will want to be having 32 gb by then. and since apple is not allowing us to upgrade memory, i want the big package the moment i purchase.
d) touch bar: i think that's NOT considered to be "way better" by everyone. in fact i'd probably even pay a premium to NOT have that touch bar but real keys instead. but that's just my personal opinion, being a developer i love my Esc key.
e) 2tb option for 13" model.
f) price. it's the prices for the high end models that have become insanely high to the point where it becomes offensive. price for the top models has been raised dramatically over the past few years: from around EUR 3000 it now is at EUR 5000 for the 15". for a machine that is literally offering pretty much the same performance as my 4 year old maxx'd out macbook cMBP 2012. - that just doesn't sound right, even taking into account the awesome new form factor. the new machine of course has benefits, but not enough to justify a 5000 eur investment that comes with adapter hassle and 16gb limit.
i think there is room for improvement in 2017, and i hope apple will rethink some points for the next model.
so, as usual, things are not black or white, rather "fifty shades of grey"