Sidebar Sidebar
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

Flat = Good!

R

reznick

macrumors member
Original poster
Jun 24, 2013
71
0
It's official. Apple's decision to move iOS to a flat design style was the right move!

Just take a look at all the featured apps on the app store. They're absolutely beautiful. Flat design has removed the superfluous, and made all apps that have adopted the style rich with simplicity and beauty.


The world is better because of this shift. Digital interfaces are now more beautiful than ever. Bringing more smiles to more peoples faces.


It's official: Apple was right again.
 
reznick said:
It's official. Apple's decision to move iOS to a flat design style was the right move!

Just take a look at all the featured apps on the app store. They're absolutely beautiful. Flat design has removed the superfluous, and made all apps that have adopted the style rich with simplicity and beauty.


The world is better because of this shift. Digital interfaces are now more beautiful than ever. Bringing more smiles to more peoples faces.


It's official: Apple was right again.
Click to expand...

Both designs are good. I like simplicity, but do think that some aspects of iOS 7 are completely dumb. Seriously, why must I have dots rather than signal bars?
 
The only "official" thing about anything of this sort is that it's pretty much subjective and personal opinion and not much more. So not much of anything official whatsoever.
 
Altemose said:
Both designs are good. I like simplicity, but do think that some aspects of iOS 7 are completely dumb. Seriously, why must I have dots rather than signal bars?
Click to expand...

What difference does (for example) 3 dots out of 5 make compared to 3 bars out of 5? None. That's what! It's purely aesthetic. If dots verses bars confuses you- that's the real problem right there.
 
I've got an old iPod on iOS 6 and it's like a dark dungeon compared to iOS7 - while I didn't love the design straight away, I have grown to love it, and feel better about it. Especially now that they have ironed our most of the bugs.

Hopefully iOS8 is the same, just more refined.
 
Defender2010 said:
What difference does (for example) 3 dots out of 5 make compared to 3 bars out of 5? None. That's what! It's purely aesthetic. If dots verses bars confuses you- that's the real problem right there.
Click to expand...
If they don't make a difference and bars are the industry standard when it comes to
signal strength then why change them even for looks aside from basically change for the sake of change and nothing more.
 
C DM said:
If they don't make a difference and bars are the industry standard when it comes to
signal strength then why change them even for looks aside from basically change for the sake of change and nothing more.
Click to expand...

If you would know iOS 7 then you also would know that Apple is using many circles throughout the OS. It's an aspect of the whole design.;)
 
If flat is so good, then how come you have to explain that to everyone?
 
C DM said:
If they don't make a difference and bars are the industry standard when it comes to
signal strength then why change them even for looks aside from basically change for the sake of change and nothing more.
Click to expand...

I do believe the dots were what was originally in line for the first iPhone's software to display signal strength, but got changed to bars at some point. Somebody at Apple (Ive perhaps?) obviously preferred the dots.

Personally, I quite like them
 
Defender2010 said:
What difference does (for example) 3 dots out of 5 make compared to 3 bars out of 5? None. That's what! It's purely aesthetic. If dots verses bars confuses you- that's the real problem right there.
Click to expand...

The dots certainly don't confuse me, they just look gash.
 
Defender2010 said:
What difference does (for example) 3 dots out of 5 make compared to 3 bars out of 5? None. That's what! It's purely aesthetic. If dots verses bars confuses you- that's the real problem right there.
Click to expand...

It makes no difference but it was a change for the sake of change. In fact they take up slightly more space than the signal bars. If they would of used white signal bars it would have looked great.

And yes... I can read signal dots! :D
 
Altemose said:
It makes no difference but it was a change for the sake of change. In fact they take up slightly more space than the signal bars. If they would of used white signal bars it would have looked great.
Click to expand...

It was not...... You didn't notice all the circles throughout the OS?! It's part of the design language.
 
reznick said:
Just take a look at all the featured apps on the app store. They're absolutely beautiful [...] rich with simplicity and beauty. [...] more beautiful than ever.
Click to expand...

I would agree that they look good. The question remains whether they are always as usable and enjoyable to use as they could be...to me that's the difference between designing a magazine (or Metro signs, where MS took their inspiration from) and a UI.
 
Nice that Apple gets to decide this for me.

I would FaceTime and tell them myself how I dislike iOS 7 but that function has been removed to try and pressure users like myself to goose-step.

Even though I am the customer and I was the one who decided to purchase my phone based on what software it came with at the time.

Disabling features to pressure users into conforming to the Jonny world, is not something I am any longer willing to support.
 
John T said:
Surely subjective is personal? ;)
Click to expand...
Reiterates the point even though in a redundant manner.

----------
marvz said:
It was not...... You didn't notice all the circles throughout the OS?! It's part of the design language.
Click to expand...
How come they left the battery well alone and didn't do the circles there if it's part of the design language?
 
reznick said:
It's official. Apple's decision to move iOS to a flat design style was the right move!

Just take a look at all the featured apps on the app store. They're absolutely beautiful. Flat design has removed the superfluous, and made all apps that have adopted the style rich with simplicity and beauty.


The world is better because of this shift. Digital interfaces are now more beautiful than ever. Bringing more smiles to more peoples faces.


It's official: Apple was right again.
Click to expand...

The 3rd party apps look great now, I'll give that one, but Apple's default apps look like **** now (save for the weather app).

Too much white space, it looks sterile and dull. They may have gotten rid of the unnecessary textures but they had nothing better to replace them with. Hopefully Apple will figure out what to do thanks to the developers.

----------
Altemose said:
It makes no difference but it was a change for the sake of change. In fact they take up slightly more space than the signal bars. If they would of used white signal bars it would have looked great.

And yes... I can read signal dots! :D
Click to expand...

The dots are easier to see at a glance but they are a space waster. Hopefully they will reduce the size slightly and maybe give users the option to view signal strength as traditional bars.

----------
marvz said:
If you would know iOS 7 then you also would know that Apple is using many circles throughout the OS. It's an aspect of the whole design.;)
Click to expand...

Why isn't the wifi icon a bunch of circles then?
 
marvz said:
To both of you, how would you display the wifi or battery with circles? Thanks for ignoring common sense ;)
Click to expand...
Same way that you can with the signal
strength. Let's take the battery, have 4 dots, each one becoming empty means the battery is down 25%. Thanks for ignoring something that is simple and straightforward. ;)
 
C DM said:
Same way that you can with the signal
strength. Let's take the battery, have 4 dots, each one becoming empty means the battery is down 25%. Thanks for ignoring something that is simple and straightforward. ;)
Click to expand...

Hmm I don't want to discuss this even further.. People like you will always find something to moan about. If you don't want to see this and are saying that you would display the battery as 4 dots, I'm happy you are no iOS designer.

PS: looking forward to OSX 10.10 :p
 
marvz said:
Hmm I don't want to discuss this even further.. People like you will always find something to moan about. If you don't want to see this and are saying that you would display the battery as 4 dots, I'm happy you are no iOS designer.

PS: looking forward to OSX 10.10 :p
Click to expand...
I'm saying that your explanation about the circular design being the driving factor factor behind it has enough outlying elements throughout the OS to simply say that it's actually the driving factor.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.
Top Bottom
Back