Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
AppliedVisual said:
You're mostly right... The C2D gives about a 5% typical speed boost, up to 10 to 15% in performance apps, especially if they're 64bit optimized. They key here is not waiting for Sant Rosa (for Apple such a thing won't be part of their plan) it's waiting for the next Intel mobile chipset to compliment the Merom CPU - currently codenamed "Crestline". The new chipset will bring us expanded memory addressing capabilities and hopefully better power management and some other goodies.

IMO, a 64bit CPU and most current 64bit applications are pretty much worthless if we're still stuck with a 32bit memory limitation, leaving us with somewhere between 2 and 3 GB that we can actually use, not to mention the 2GB process limitation also still imposed by the current chipset since it forces the CPU to exist within 32bit memory space. Now that it's been over a month since the introduction of C2D iMac systems, I'm convinced that Apple is indeed waiting for Crestline before shipping Merom CPUs in their notebooks. Hopefully this happens soon and may they upgrade the GPU to an X1800, or nv7800/nv7900 pleeeeeeaaaaaase???

For me, no Crestline chipset, no MBP purchase - simple. If it takes them all the way until next spring to do it, when the next gen Centrino notebooks (erm.. Santa Rosa) hit store shelves, then so be it. By then we'll be looking forward to faster Merom CPUs with 800MHz FSB.

Hmm, seems like a lot of posters here don't comprehend 'Santa Rosa', Intel's code naming for the latest greatest component system to make a whole computer, your all inclusive design so to speak. Merom is Santa Rosa, or more correctly the CPU of choice for the Santa Rosa platform. Crestline is a part of the Santa Rosa platform also, it just hasn't been shipped by Intel yet. Merom came out 1st, and was made capable of being used in the older Intel designated platform called Napa.

Depending on what has been delaying the announcement of C2D (Merom) MBP's, if the MBP has been in production, and will be shipping shortly; then obviously fewer upgraded components will be included. The Nvidia 7800 mobile GPU's have been available for ions in computer time tables, no reason Apple would put them in any laptop now when more current models are available.

Apple could be working on a revised, cooler internal design, but I think anyone who thinks Apple has worked some miracle of cooling; such that they can now throw in a much hotter, battery draining, GPU; is just dreaming...it's not going to happen.

A FSB of 800Mhz (as has been said 'dozens of times before on MR'...hehe, sorry AV, I couldn't resist) will not result in some astounding increase in performance. An incremental increase, of some smaller amount- kind of like this quote from above "The C2D gives about a 5% typical speed boost, up to 10 to 15% in performance apps". Higher clocked DDR2 memory also generates more heat, uses more power. Same reason the Mobility x1600 is underclocked in the MBP 15in...too much heat. A likely GPU now; if the MBP C2D's are to be released this month, not in the future; the minor upgrade going from x1600 to the ATI Mx1700. But Crestline shipping now/soon? Not likely despite the typically inaccurate/optimistic dates given on this site:

http://www.mikeshardware.co.uk/RoadmapQ306.htm LOL, they state on this site that the " release of the nVidia GeForce Go G80M is expected to be released in November. The GeForce Go G80M is the mobile equivalent of the G80 GPU." So if it's based on the G80, will it also have a hybrid water/fan cooled operation and require a 450w PSU!!! Wow, "That's Hot!"

There you go, MBP update just before Thanksgiving...with the new mid-level "ATI Radeon Mobility M76 is expected to be released in November. This GPU is based on the R600 core and is targeted at the mid range mobile market." Don't forget that Panasonic slot loading Blu-ray, Apple will be 1st to market with that, trust me ;).


No Crestline until March 2007 according to this unreliable sitehttp://www.digitimes.com/mobos/a20061012A7032.html. Which means, unless Intel is ahead of schedule, don't expect Crestline (PM965 chipset) in a MBP revision @MWSF :(. There sure are going to be a lot of disappointed whiners on MR, when the current MBP gets updated. While Apple is under no obligation to use the full set of Santa Rosa components, it's almost a given they'll use many of the additional features of the platform. Interlaced screen, Robson NAND cache, etc. all to save more battery power. http://www.anandtech.com/tradeshows/showdoc.aspx?i=2845&p=2

Also http://www.channelregister.co.uk/2006/09/27/intel_intros_santa_rosa/

"Intel is still saying Santa Rosa will ship in H1 2007, though it's expected to come late Q1/early Q2."

Like I said before, higher performing GPU's in a ultra thin Apple laptop, will require GPU's that consume less power, which means wait until they go below 80nm process, later next year?. Later next year 45nm CPU's

http://www.channelregister.co.uk/2006/10/11/intel_centrino_roadmap/

"Just as Santa Rosa hasn't followed hot on the heels of 'Merom', the Core 2 Duo mobile processor, so it seems likely Montevina will debut some months after Penryn. The 45nm chip is said to consume no more than 29W, compared to Merom's 35W TDP."

Analogous to Crestline is "Cantiga ups the frontside bus speed to 1,067MHz and looks set to support 800MHz DDR 3 in preference to the less power-efficient 800MHz DDR 2, the report suggests."
 
Butthead said:
Hmm, seems like a lot of posters here don't comprehend 'Santa Rosa', Intel's code naming for the latest greatest component system to make a whole computer, your all inclusive design so to speak. Merom is Santa Rosa, or more correctly the CPU of choice for the Santa Rosa platform. Crestline is a part of the Santa Rosa platform also, it just hasn't been shipped by Intel yet. Merom came out 1st, and was made capable of being used in the older Intel designated platform called Napa.

Depending on what has been delaying the announcement of C2D (Merom) MBP's, if the MBP has been in production, and will be shipping shortly; then obviously fewer upgraded components will be included. The Nvidia 7800 mobile GPU's have been available for ions in computer time tables, no reason Apple would put them in any laptop now when more current models are available.

Apple could be working on a revised, cooler internal design, but I think anyone who thinks Apple has worked some miracle of cooling; such that they can now throw in a much hotter, battery draining, GPU; is just dreaming...it's not going to happen.

A FSB of 800Mhz (as has been said 'dozens of times before on MR'...hehe, sorry AV, I couldn't resist) will not result in some astounding increase in performance. An incremental increase, of some smaller amount- kind of like this quote from above "The C2D gives about a 5% typical speed boost, up to 10 to 15% in performance apps". Higher clocked DDR2 memory also generates more heat, uses more power. Same reason the Mobility x1600 is underclocked in the MBP 15in...too much heat. A likely GPU now; if the MBP C2D's are to be released this month, not in the future; the minor upgrade going from x1600 to the ATI Mx1700. But Crestline shipping now/soon? Not likely despite the typically inaccurate/optimistic dates given on this site:

http://www.mikeshardware.co.uk/RoadmapQ306.htm LOL, they state on this site that the " release of the nVidia GeForce Go G80M is expected to be released in November. The GeForce Go G80M is the mobile equivalent of the G80 GPU." So if it's based on the G80, will it also have a hybrid water/fan cooled operation and require a 450w PSU!!! Wow, "That's Hot!"

There you go, MBP update just before Thanksgiving...with the new mid-level "ATI Radeon Mobility M76 is expected to be released in November. This GPU is based on the R600 core and is targeted at the mid range mobile market." Don't forget that Panasonic slot loading Blu-ray, Apple will be 1st to market with that, trust me ;).


No Crestline until March 2007 according to this unreliable sitehttp://www.digitimes.com/mobos/a20061012A7032.html. Which means, unless Intel is ahead of schedule, don't expect Crestline (PM965 chipset) in a MBP revision @MWSF :(. There sure are going to be a lot of disappointed whiners on MR, when the current MBP gets updated. While Apple is under no obligation to use the full set of Santa Rosa components, it's almost a given they'll use many of the additional features of the platform. Interlaced screen, Robson NAND cache, etc. all to save more battery power. http://www.anandtech.com/tradeshows/showdoc.aspx?i=2845&p=2

Also http://www.channelregister.co.uk/2006/09/27/intel_intros_santa_rosa/

"Intel is still saying Santa Rosa will ship in H1 2007, though it's expected to come late Q1/early Q2."

Like I said before, higher performing GPU's in a ultra thin Apple laptop, will require GPU's that consume less power, which means wait until they go below 80nm process, later next year?. Later next year 45nm CPU's

http://www.channelregister.co.uk/2006/10/11/intel_centrino_roadmap/

"Just as Santa Rosa hasn't followed hot on the heels of 'Merom', the Core 2 Duo mobile processor, so it seems likely Montevina will debut some months after Penryn. The 45nm chip is said to consume no more than 29W, compared to Merom's 35W TDP."

Analogous to Crestline is "Cantiga ups the frontside bus speed to 1,067MHz and looks set to support 800MHz DDR 3 in preference to the less power-efficient 800MHz DDR 2, the report suggests."

Long and short of it is... it is always gonna get faster.

In a way Yonah to Merom is a big step, because while speed increases come all the time, they do not switch instruction sets with every other generation!
 
Didn't want to pick through all this... But just wanted to comment that I don't foresee the next revisions of MBP systems being 1" thin. Apple will have to deviate in order to provide ample cooling. I think they will continue with the mid-range GPU offerings - that's just their style. But it would be nice if they could find a way to offer the more powerful (and power-hungry) GPU offerings. The market for them does exist... I'm used to notebooks with zero battey life. My current MBP replaced an HP ZD7000 17" monster. It lasted about 22 minutes on a full charge under moderate load. And thwat was with a 3.2GHz northwood P4, 2GB PC3200 RAM, 100GB 5400rpm HD, and an overclocked nvidia 5700. The thing is nearly 3 years old now though.

Butthead said:
There you go, MBP update just before Thanksgiving...with the new mid-level "ATI Radeon Mobility M76 is expected to be released in November. This GPU is based on the R600 core and is targeted at the mid range mobile market." Don't forget that Panasonic slot loading Blu-ray, Apple will be 1st to market with that, trust me ;).

We'll see... I do expect a GPU bump with the MBP revision whether it happens this next week or or not. I'm not expecting miracles, but the X1600 is a dog. As for the BluRay drive.... I'd be surprised if they add that to the MBP line before the end of the year, but I'd definitely welcome one. I think a slot-load BD-RW drive for the upcoming iTV is a no-brainer.

No Crestline until March 2007 according to this unreliable sitehttp://www.digitimes.com/mobos/a20061012A7032.html. Which means, unless Intel is ahead of schedule, don't expect Crestline (PM965 chipset) in a MBP revision @MWSF :(.

I sure hope they're wrong. I don't have a link handy, but I've read that the i96x mobile chipset series are already shipping in sample form. But then again, I don't know how reliable that source is either. All the decent news sites seem to have nothing to report on the matter.
 
AppliedVisual said:
Didn't want to pick through all this... But just wanted to comment that I don't foresee the next revisions of MBP systems being 1" thin. Apple will have to deviate in order to provide ample cooling. I think they will continue with the mid-range GPU offerings - that's just their style. But it would be nice if they could find a way to offer the more powerful (and power-hungry) GPU offerings. The market for them does exist... I'm used to notebooks with zero battey life. My current MBP replaced an HP ZD7000 17" monster. It lasted about 22 minutes on a full charge under moderate load. And thwat was with a 3.2GHz northwood P4, 2GB PC3200 RAM, 100GB 5400rpm HD, and an overclocked nvidia 5700. The thing is nearly 3 years old now though.

Ehh... that is not a very fair comparison because the P4s are such inefficient beasts.

AppliedVisual said:
We'll see... I do expect a GPU bump with the MBP revision whether it happens this next week or or not. I'm not expecting miracles, but the X1600 is a dog. As for the BluRay drive.... I'd be surprised if they add that to the MBP line before the end of the year, but I'd definitely welcome one. I think a slot-load BD-RW drive for the upcoming iTV is a no-brainer.

The worrisome bit about that hypothesis is that the recently iMacs got updated and they still have the x1600s. Chances are Apple will stick with them for the MBPs too, at least until next year.

AppliedVisual said:
I sure hope they're wrong. I don't have a link handy, but I've read that the i96x mobile chipset series are already shipping in sample form. But then again, I don't know how reliable that source is either. All the decent news sites seem to have nothing to report on the matter.

How long does it usually take for something to get from sampling to production?

Doesn't the 965 express chipset also require the new Socket P?
 
Multimedia said:
Well you've sold me. I won't buy until you do. Keep in touch. ;)

Will do. I'll probably be hanging out here in these MBP update threads until I do buy anyway. I'm now at the 3 week mark with my current MBP and all I can say is that it's a great system. I've had a little bit of fan noise/whine, but the thing is super-quiet compared to my HP ZD7K it replaced. My biggest issue is still the 2GB I have installed is just coming up a bit short on some tasks, but I knew that going into it.. Nothing I can do until a capable system ships with the new chipset. So with this system, I can definitely wait it out.

Multimedia said:
Should we have a contest to see who can get their 2.66GHz 8-Core Mac Pro delivered first? :D

Hehe... Sure, but I don't know if I'll buy it when first offered or not, I guess it depends on where I'm at with current projects and budget. I don't tend to buy and add new systems or software to my workflow in the middle of a large project. Now I may build some more PC systems for render nodes, but that's a bit different.
 
generik said:
Ehh... that is not a very fair comparison because the P4s are such inefficient beasts.

True... "inefficeint" doesn't even begin to describe it...

The worrisome bit about that hypothesis is that the recently iMacs got updated and they still have the x1600s. Chances are Apple will stick with them for the MBPs too, at least until next year.

That worries me too, but in the end I'll still buy the updated MBP once I can put my 4GB in there, regardless of GPU choice. It would just be nice if we had the option of something more powerful, even if it did sacrifice battery life. And like Butthead wrote, it's not going to work out in the current design. Either way, I think the days of the 1" thin MBP are over or seriously short-numbered.

How long does it usually take for something to get from sampling to production?

I guess that depends on the product. Lately Intel has been kicking ass. I think Merom went from first engineering samples shipped to final shipping product in about 12 weeks.

Doesn't the 965 express chipset also require the new Socket P?

It doesn't require one, but does support one. The 800MHz FSB Merom CPUs next spring will require the updated socket, IIRC.

Anyway, I guess we will just have to see what Apple throws at us.
 
AppliedVisual said:
That worries me too, but in the end I'll still buy the updated MBP once I can put my 4GB in there, regardless of GPU choice. It would just be nice if we had the option of something more powerful, even if it did sacrifice battery life. And like Butthead wrote, it's not going to work out in the current design. Either way, I think the days of the 1" thin MBP are over or seriously short-numbered.

Isn't it true that the new 24" iMacs use a new form factor kind of graphics cards? Will those fit into laptops?
 
WOW. first MacBOO, now the true macbook PRO, what next red ipod shuffles?
macboo2.jpg

macbookpro0120060109.jpg

red.jpg
 
generik said:
Isn't it true that the new 24" iMacs use a new form factor kind of graphics cards? Will those fit into laptops?

They use a new laptop format graphics card - so yes. They will fit into laptops designed to use the new format (though it remains to be seen how easy upgrading to a new card would be... it is more a "convenience of manufacture thing rather then end-user-upgrade option).
 
Goooood afternoon all, hows everyone doing. Anyways to anyone who cares which i'll assume is nobody, i just got off the phone with Apple and asked when the MBP updates were debuting and dude goes "we Apple employees are kept in the dark just as you are in other words i have no idea" i asked him for an educated guess and he says "safe assumption would be MWSF".

I then proceed to tell him "in that case i'd like to swap my refurb MBP for a Mac Pro and pay the difference and he goes "excellent choice".

Anyway not to bore you bottomline, i've swapped for a Mac Pro 2.66 GHz/2GB/160GB HDD/BT+AE/Radeon X1900XT which comes to around what i would pay for a new maxed out MBP anyways so its all good. est delivery date is Oct 23.

This also means i will probably be skipping merom altogether, wait for penryn and in the meantime get AppleCare for my PB to prolong its life.

I hope the MMBPs debut for you guys next week. Have a great one.
 
daneoni said:
Goooood afternoon all, hows everyone doing. Anyways to anyone who cares which i'll assume is nobody, i just got off the phone with Apple and asked when the MBP updates were debuting and dude goes "we Apple employees are kept in the dark just as you are in other words i have no idea" i asked him for an educated guess and he says "safe assumption would be MWSF".

I then proceed to tell him "in that case i'd like to swap my refurb MBP for a Mac Pro and pay the difference and he goes "excellent choice".

Anyway not to bore you bottomline, i've swapped for a Mac Pro 2.66 GHz/2GB/160GB HDD/BT+AE/Radeon X1900XT which comes to around what i would pay for a new maxed out MBP anyways so its all good. est delivery date is Oct 23.

This also means i will probably be skipping merom altogether, wait for penryn and in the meantime get AppleCare for my PB to prolong its life.

I hope the MMBPs debut for you guys next week. Have a great one.


are you NUTSICLES????!!!!! its 8:50 AM where I am *grumble grumble* No one can be that cheery anytime of the day. Anyway, now that my pmsing is through, congrats on your Mac Pro!!!!!!! :)
 
AutumnSkyline said:
are you NUTSICLES????!!!!! its 8:50 AM where I am *grumble grumble* No one can be that cheery anytime of the day. Anyway, now that my pmsing is through, congrats on your Mac Pro!!!!!!! :)

Its actually 2PM here in London. Oh and a Mac Pro would make anyone cheery;)
 
daneoni said:
Its actually 2PM here in London. Oh and a Mac Pro would make anyone cheery;)

Just stating my hate for time zones and the fact your over there with your tea time or whatever, and I am half asleep in my Apple Jacks. And touche to the Mac Pro thingy.....Yes I am using that right.
 
generik said:
Ehh... that is not a very fair comparison because the P4s are such inefficient beasts.



The worrisome bit about that hypothesis is that the recently iMacs got updated and they still have the x1600s. Chances are Apple will stick with them for the MBPs too, at least until next year.



How long does it usually take for something to get from sampling to production?

Doesn't the 965 express chipset also require the new Socket P?

I recently built a new PC with the Core 2 Duo and a intel board with the desktop version of the P965 chipset. The end result is that the new chip is good, but the chipset is blah. Not bad, but not terrific. New revisions of the chipset have come out since then, and it is possible that a certain amount of reworking will have to take place with crestline as well.

I wish I had caved in to my inclinations and just bought a mac instead... but somehow being dissowned by my family just didn't seem worth it :eek: . Oh well. It will last until XP SP2 is no longer supported, then goodbye PCs :D
 
:( :( :( :( :( :( :(

I got my 0% credit card today, which i ordered to buy my Macbook Pro, but it only has a £1000 credit limit, i will have to order another and hope they spread the cost over 2 cards!
 
jl234 said:
Here's a little something to get it back on track. I'm sure this was posted on earlier pages, but I've not been back far enough to be sure.

AppleInsider is reporting that a major supplier of MB's and MB Pro's in Europe is totally out of stock and expect to replenish around Oct. 31. Could this be the updated systems?

I'm still betting on around Oct 24th or a little bit later - on a side note its not just Europe that is running low on stock, if you search a lot of the major retailers their inventory is thinning out a bit. That doesn't mean there is an update in the works, but it is a good sign for those (like me) that want to be hopeful...
 
sblasl said:
Where did everyone go?:cool:
They're resting... Got a big week ahead of us what with this week (amazingly enough) having another Tuesday in it!!! Who knows when it'll ever happen again... The odds are unfathomable.
 
sblasl said:
Where did everyone go?:cool:

I'm still here:cool: hehe

I've been reading everyone's posts, but I've become a bit too disenheartened up until now to write my own... oh, bitter disappointment.
 
xVeinx said:
I recently built a new PC with the Core 2 Duo and a intel board with the desktop version of the P965 chipset. The end result is that the new chip is good, but the chipset is blah. Not bad, but not terrific. New revisions of the chipset have come out since then, and it is possible that a certain amount of reworking will have to take place with crestline as well.

I wish I had caved in to my inclinations and just bought a mac instead... but somehow being dissowned by my family just didn't seem worth it :eek: . Oh well. It will last until XP SP2 is no longer supported, then goodbye PCs :D

What's wrong with the P965 chipset? It stinks for "overclocking" and stuff in my experience but it has been very stable so far, at least for mine... still sitting there churning out good amounts of Boinc WUs :rolleyes:
 
logicpro7 said:
i think they have all gone over to the "powerbook G5 next tuesday...." thread.

:D

I am starting to believe that Apple couldn't put merom in the MB/P, and either decided to trash the design to put it in just like the powerbooks, or they are just waiting for a new chip to throw in, also hopefully rebuilding. Or Steve is reading this right now, on his Merom MBP of course, and is getting off from seeing you guys suffer, prolonging your pain.
 
AVonGauss said:
I'm still betting on around Oct 24th or a little bit later - on a side note its not just Europe that is running low on stock, if you search a lot of the major retailers their inventory is thinning out a bit. That doesn't mean there is an update in the works, but it is a good sign for those (like me) that want to be hopeful...

Yeah, that's what I kept telling myself while I waited months for the 15" Aluminum Powerbook to be released too... :D

(For those who don't remember, the previous model 15" Powerbooks completely sold out something like 5-6 months before the Aluminum update finally happened)
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.