I admit that I'm an enthusiast, but have you ever used a DSLR? Photo quality isn't the only reason why a DSLR is superior to a camera phone.and to whoever said use a digital camera, those are on the way out. lets be honest. only pro photogs and real enthusiasts have a need for a cam, the normal consumer uses their phone. why else would companies place such importance on the quality of their cameras?
For what it's worth, I started out with camera phones (back when the images came out at 640x480 resolution) and never foresaw myself as using a point-and-shoot, let alone a DSLR. A few years later, here I am... Given how important the quality of the phone camera is to you, I'd say that you're on the path to becoming a photo enthusiast, too. Go with the best camera you can get in your phone, but recognize that you might be reaching the point where no phone can match your expectations.
I'm still on an iPhone 4S, but I've been pretty impressed by its camera - enough that I don't drag my DSLR around with me everywhere I go. There are still many scenarios and situations where I wish that I had my DSLR with me, though.
I've been pretty impressed by the level of detail that the camera phones can eke out. I'm comfortable using the iPhone 4S as my primary day-to-day camera. It hasn't caused me to sell my DSLR and assortment of lenses, but I've been very pleased.I don't actually believe any of the camera's on phones are that good. I hardly ever use mine. They are a compromise. The best camera you can squeeze into a phone. Interestingly they are now working on the issue the other way round. Modern cameras have built in wifi etc. I use a proper camera.
To be honest, it's difficult to say. You're telling us that your hand was steady, that you focused properly, and that you're not a novice, but how do we know? I've been active on a number of photography forums and I've heard the exact same complaints. People claim that they're steady and that they know what they're doing, and then it turns out that there was a problem with their technique.Ok, here are some shots I have taken with my iPhone 5.
These are untouched, unedited photos.
Yes my hand is steady, yes I tapped to focus and auto is on. these are NOT zoomed in.
Like i said, no novice. You judge.
Your phone might truly have problems, or you might truly be pushing the boundaries. I wasn't there, I haven't seen you in action, I don't know. I know it's frustrating to hear "you're doing it wrong," but I'd suggest trying some stabilizing techniques and practicing with where you're trapping to focus to see if you can improve your technique even further.
I've heard this on the photo forums as well. Maybe you're experienced enough to say whether the lighting was truly mediocre or not; maybe you're still at the stage where you can't differentiate acceptable from mediocre lighting. None of us knows you well enough to say. If you're really good enough then just ignore the comments, but otherwise view it as something to potentially improve on.And it wasn't mediocre lighting. But I'll let you think you're right.