Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
I am waiting for a future where I can install some open source software to my car and customize it how I want. Maybe some Chinese brand will think of that and some Linux community will develop the OS.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RMMediccc
GM can't really monetize customers's data with Carplay.
I think they can monetize this -- aside from the subscription fees they plan to charge after 5 years. Looking not that far in the future, as the cars become more self driving, the passengers will be a captured audience for ads and consumption. GM wants to isolate the passengers from any competition while they are in the car. Imagine if you have sole access to consumers for ~40 minutes per day, while they are separated from being able to go anywhere or engage in any other media.
 
Like Apple, it is perfectly understandable that GM wants to control the entire ecosystem. CarPlay is no magic, it is simply streaming from your mobile with a very simple interface on the car. GM can develop many revenue generating opportunities with their own Apps.
 
  • Disagree
Reactions: RMMediccc
All I want out of a car infotainment is a good navigation (almost all have them) and a possibility to stream music (optional). I dont need my messages on screen, nor read to me, none of that - I don’t live in a car, it has to be comfortable for travel and to be reliable. Carplay doesn’t guarantee any of that.

All of “I won’t buy a car without apple car” are lying or are spoiled brats of a hyper fanbois. If a carplay is a crucial feature for you when buying a car, then you are a perfect sheep for any corporation/company.
There is nothing in the CarPlay except while streaming Music it categorises the tracks conveniently. This is not a big thing but Car companies are made to pay very heavy licensing fee for Apple which is why one after the other leaving Car Play. People won’t be able to see CarPlay in most of the cars sooner or later.
 
  • Disagree
Reactions: jbachandouris
I don’t want immersion from my infotainment system.
I want to jump in to more or less any car and know where everything is.
I got a Kia for work this week and guess what I know how all my maps and music works before I drive off the Hertz forecourt.
Haha… thank you for proving my point!
 
There is nothing in the CarPlay except while streaming Music it categorises the tracks conveniently. This is not a big thing but Car companies are made to pay very heavy licensing fee for Apple which is why one after the other leaving Car Play. People won’t be able to see CarPlay in most of the cars sooner or later.
One after the other? So what other carmaker has dropped CarPlay, apart from GM?
 
You know what's funny, pages of pages of people stating they'll not buy a car that doesn't have carplay, when I'd say imo, most of the car buying public that isn't part of MacRumors, won't care. Someone who needs a car, is going to buy the brand they trust most, and not base it on whether their iPhone automatically connects and uses apple apps.

Second point, car manufactoreres are more and more relying on data collection as a revenue source, so its not surprising more and more companies are leaving apple behind
 


General Motors began phasing out support for CarPlay in its electric vehicles back in 2023, leading to complaints from iPhone users, but the company has no plans to back down.

cadillac-lyric-infotainment.jpg

In fact, GM is going further and plans to remove CarPlay from all future gas vehicles, too. In an interview with The Verge, GM CEO Mary Barra said that the company opted to prioritize its platform for EVs, but the change will eventually expand across the entire GM portfolio.

When asked if users should expect that new gas cars will not support "smartphone projection" for CarPlay or Android Auto, Barra said "I think that's the right expectation. Yes."

GM Chief Product Officer Sterling Anderson suggested that GM's decision to embrace its own system is a "very Jobsian approach to things" that he likened to phasing out the disk drive.

Anderson said that GM's in-house infotainment option offers a "much more immersive environment" and can "do so many more things" than CarPlay.

In EVs, General Motors transitioned to an infotainment system that it previously called "Ultifi." GM said that eliminating Apple CarPlay gave it access to direct integrations and information that it needed for its electric vehicle line, plus the company claimed that an in-house unified solution was the better option for consumers.

Starting with the 2028 Cadillac Escalade IQ, GM is rolling out a centralized vehicle computing system that it says will overhaul how GM vehicles are built and how they can be updated over time. GM will share software across its portfolio, including all electric and gas-powered vehicles produced by its GMC, Chevrolet, Buick, and Cadillac brands.

Article Link: GM to Remove CarPlay from All Future Vehicles, Including Gas Cars
Apple should just buy GM lock stock and barrel and dump this crappy new infotainment system. Total market cap is only $65B. Much less than what Apple has already spent on developing the non-existent Apple Car.
 
All I want out of a car infotainment is a good navigation (almost all have them) and a possibility to stream music (optional). I dont need my messages on screen, nor read to me, none of that - I don’t live in a car, it has to be comfortable for travel and to be reliable. Carplay doesn’t guarantee any of that.

All of “I won’t buy a car without apple car” are lying or are spoiled brats of a hyper fanbois. If a carplay is a crucial feature for you when buying a car, then you are a perfect sheep for any corporation/company.
Personally I would never consider buying a GM, irrespective of whether the vehicle offered CarPlay. But I also wouldn't denigrate someone that would...because why would I care which car someone else wants to drive?
CarPlay has always been an optional interface that the consumer is free to completely disregard, and carmakers always offer their own interface as primary . . . so it's not entirely obvious to me how it is apparently the anti-"sheep" who would applaud a carmaker's efforts to deny customers that choice in order to essentially force them into using their proprietary interface.
 


General Motors began phasing out support for CarPlay in its electric vehicles back in 2023, leading to complaints from iPhone users, but the company has no plans to back down.

cadillac-lyric-infotainment.jpg

In fact, GM is going further and plans to remove CarPlay from all future gas vehicles, too. In an interview with The Verge, GM CEO Mary Barra said that the company opted to prioritize its platform for EVs, but the change will eventually expand across the entire GM portfolio.

When asked if users should expect that new gas cars will not support "smartphone projection" for CarPlay or Android Auto, Barra said "I think that's the right expectation. Yes."

GM Chief Product Officer Sterling Anderson suggested that GM's decision to embrace its own system is a "very Jobsian approach to things" that he likened to phasing out the disk drive.

Anderson said that GM's in-house infotainment option offers a "much more immersive environment" and can "do so many more things" than CarPlay.

In EVs, General Motors transitioned to an infotainment system that it previously called "Ultifi." GM said that eliminating Apple CarPlay gave it access to direct integrations and information that it needed for its electric vehicle line, plus the company claimed that an in-house unified solution was the better option for consumers.

Starting with the 2028 Cadillac Escalade IQ, GM is rolling out a centralized vehicle computing system that it says will overhaul how GM vehicles are built and how they can be updated over time. GM will share software across its portfolio, including all electric and gas-powered vehicles produced by its GMC, Chevrolet, Buick, and Cadillac brands.

Article Link: GM to Remove CarPlay from All Future Vehicles, Including Gas Cars
I’ll be removing GM from my next car shopping list.
 
No, they don't want you use systems they can't get your data or sell you subs.
This is why.

I own a Chevy, and the amount services behind the a subscription is surprising. This is for a 2021 truck, I believe there's even more locked behind a paywall in newer trucks. There's also been articles in how car manufacturers are using data collection to supplement their income
 
Sadly, if this works for GM, we will see other car brands follow suit. This is Apple and Google stepping on their turf and with CarPlay ultra, it’s Apple squeezing in even more.

Google is happy to partner with GM for the data collection, but I could see more and more car companies push back on CarPlay for their own dumb solutions full of subscriptions and data harvesting.

Sure, there’s a portion of the market that won’t buy anything without CarPlay, but there’s a very large portion of the market that doesn’t even know what that is, or buys GM fleet vehicles, etc etc.

The fact that this didn’t fail spectacularly when they made the change for just their EV’s is not a good sign and if GM pulls this off, so too will others.

Overall, I fear that Apple introducing CarPlay ultra might have been the straw the broke the camels back for these manufacturers. CarPlay was fine when they could sell it as a feature that lets you use maps or play music - but now Apple is wanting to control features that the auto makers want to charge for such as HUD, weather, seat controls, etc. these are all things they want to lock behind a paywall. Automakers don’t want to just be the body while Apple and Google monetize the brains of the car - they are pushing back.
This post won’t get many upvotes here, but is probably the most logical take on this thread.

I expect a car to be around for many years, so I think regular CarPlay (and Android Auto) should be provided if for no other reason, to have the ability to use nav and other connected services long after manufacturers drop support, or mobile technology in the vehicle sunsets. It should be really good for the handful of functions the phone does well, and not much more. I wish Apple would improve it to make it more useful without physical interaction, but unfortunately that requires a more capable Siri. Ultra is an entirely different situation, and offers little if any upside to the auto manufacturers. The massive shrinking of the list of automakers supposedly supporting Ultra between the original announcement and now is pretty significant.

I agree with you about car buying in general, especially looking at the big, worldwide picture. For every person commenting about CarPlay (myself included) in a tech forum, there are 100 others for whom phone connectivity doesn’t even make their top 5 criteria when buying a car. It’s almost a “1st world problems” kind of thing.

So, while I think regular CarPlay should be offered, I also think it’s a little rich to complain when an automaker is trying to control the entire hardware-software stack for user experience purposes when that is precisely what Apple has done from the start.
 
I will not buy a car that doesn't come with CarPlay included. It is a deal breaker for me and all my family feel the same.
I like many people have limited options financially when it comes to buying vehicles, and the lack of carplay is down the priority list.

for example, I get more truck with a chevy colorado, then I do with a Toyota Tacoma dollar for dollar. The Taco, has a stellar reputation, but the price points were such (when I bought my truck) that I'd be paying significantly more for the Taco. Instead, I got a near top of the line Colorado for several thousands less then the Tacoma. Plus the chevy dealership was willing to negotiate, the toyota said, the sticker is what you pay - no movement.

My point is when it comes to vehicles, and extremely expensive purchase, people value quality, features, and their comfort level, i.e., I've always bought brand x, and they've been solid, so I'll keep buying brand x.

I said this earlier for most of the car buying public, car play, isn't something that will drive (pun intended) to (or away) to a particular car maker.
 
I have never seen standard car software that's been good. They are often slow, buggy and over complicated to use and navigate.

I will not buy a car that doesn't come with CarPlay included. It is a deal breaker for me and all my family feel the same.

Or that they don’t nickel and dime charge you. Toyota connect comes to mind. Navigation software. Etc. Yep screw that. CarPlay and android is a must for me. And GM? I don’t buy American made cars. Lifetime of lemons and bad times. Been there done that multiple times.
 
  • Like
Reactions: stephen82
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.