Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Needs more ram. a bigger battery, and an permanent sd card slot.

BTW has anyone actually moved files back and fourth on those photo card readers, could get a couple of 32 gigs and have some decent memory other than keeping up with them, and the reader dongle.
 
For light work, or a specific vertical market device, it's easy to see how some could make do with an iPad.

As a replacement for an engineer or other hi tech professional, computers are not going to vanish anytime soon. I couldn't use an iPad for a meager 10% of my work.

My iPad gets used at home for casual web surfing and the odd email. I have a huge widescreen smart TV for movies & video's, so the iPad is just a fun toy.
 
Check out this guy's site.

http://ipadalone.com/

He is a member here.

Sorry I've been a touch asleep at the switch. Haven't checked in around here in weeks but got a ton of traffic from this post Capt T, so...thank you!

I'm sure some other people must have tried or is trying to go iPad only(no main computer, just iPad). I know I could go iPad only if the storage wasn't an issue. I've been trying to find a way to add external storage without any success. Has anyone here successfully gone iPad only?

Thanks. Nice to see other people trying it.




What do you do to keep all your old documents? I've got a lot of documents I don't need to lug around on my ipad: hundreds of college papers, my movie and tv show collection, etc. You know, stuff I don't really need but don't want to lose.

Yup. I'm all iPad all the time. Full disclosure: I retain a household iMac which serves as a media storage/syncing hub. My iTunes library is waaaaaay too if for Match at this point. I have the media on a small raid array, and back it up to another drive via time machine. I do the same with my Documents folder.

If you don't want to maintain a computer at all for this purpose, this is what I'd do: put all that stuff on either Dropbox, box.net, the new Google Drive, or the like. Their various apps play pretty nicely in iOS and with the productivity apps (note this last bit can be crucially important depending on your usage/needs).

In my case, I set up a pointer between Dropbox and the Documents folder on my Mac. This automatically syncs all of my documents with Dropbox. And of course I use the dropbox app on my iPad. And I also paid for additional storage with Dropbox.

Here's where it can get tricky. In my case, I prefer the iWork apps over the various Office suite apps out there. Some of these alternative Office suites link rather nicely to the various cloud storage solutions. iWork however does not, at least not outside of iCloud which is still too half baked for my purposes. (To be clear, my issue here is that I don't want to store files by type, but rather by subject matter regardless of file type, e.g. all files - PDFs, spreadsheets, word docs, etc - about a home renovation in a single folder).

The tricky issue is "round tripping" or easily Opening a document in iWork, and Saving it back to where I want it, which in my case is Dropbox. To get around this I use the WebDAV capability within the iWork apps, which basically allows iWork apps to talk to external, WebDAV capable cloud storage solutions.

However, Dropbox isn't natively WebDAV capable (yet - apparently it's something they plan for "some point"). To get around this I signed up for dropDAV, which is a (paid) service that adds WebDAV capability to Dropbox. Note some folks have concerns about data privacy with dropDAV but I haven't had any issues.

I probably made it sound more complicated than it is. It's very easy to set all this stuff up.

So here's my workflow. I open an iWork app, say Pages. On the documents page I click the + button, then the WebDAV button. Up comes my Dropbox directory. I select the file I want, work on it as needed, then save it back to Dropbox by clicking on the wrench, and selecting Copy To WebDAV. Again up comes my Dropbox directory, and I just save the document over the existing one (or change the name and save it as a separate version).

It's basically like having a Finder within iOS, so I have ready access to all my content, which lives in the cloud, and is also backed up on my household iMac.

Honestly I will never ever go back. It may not work for everyone - though I think it'd work for 9x% of the people 9x% of the time - but it works for me.

Happy to help with any specific questions.

TM
 
For those where speed/power are necessary, it's an untterly ridiculous notion today. Key word is "today".
 
For those where speed/power are necessary, it's an untterly ridiculous notion today. Key word is "today".

Not trying to be argumentative but I think it depends a little more specifically how one defines speed or power, or to what those qualities are applied.

High end video editing, coding, and heavy spreadsheet jockeying are the primary examples that I would cite where an iPad falls somewhat short. That said...

- there are some pretty functional video editing apps on the iPad including of course Apple's - perfectly suitable for consumer use and very light pro use

- with Codea there is now an apple approved coding solution on the iPad (there's a great game called Cargo-bot that was coded entirely on the iPad.)

- viewing and tweaking existing spreadsheets, even complex ones, works fine

All a long way of saying that the list of shortcomings is pretty small, and getting smaller all the time. And in terms of speed - the kind we experience all the time whenever opening apps, files, switching, booting/turning on/off, etc. - I can say without hesitation that the new iPad is way quicker than the iMac is.

I'm a film producer. I do all my work on the iPad, as well as track and manage all my business and household finances on my iPad.

I'm a firm believer that an iPad would suit 9x% of the people 9x% of the time.
 
I use my computer at work for all my excel and word documents and such. It's work related stuff only. As far as my personal usage, I could easily disregard my laptops at home and go strictly iPhone/iPad. As it is I use my iPhone for 99.9% of my personal computer usage. Now since I bought an iPad, I think it will become my device of choice at home.
 
I need Flash for my Calculus homework, otherwise I might be iPad-only already. Well, as for as mobile devices are concerned. I'll always need a desktop PC to pump the juice into certain applications (Photoshop, etc).

Unfortunately I'm probably going to have to buy a MBA for the schoolwork that needs Flash. Sucks. It will be hard to justify the iPad after that.
 
So, replacing a laptop with an iPad isn't actually replacing a laptop with an iPad if you also use a desktop. :rolleyes:

This thread is about going iPad-only, not using an iPad with a desktop. The iPhone already largely killed off the whole portable wifi laptop around the house thing. At home, I just leave the laptop docked, and if I need something somewhere else, the iPhone can usually do it. If not, I just walk upstairs. In a way, my laptop replaced my desktop, and my iPhone replaced my laptop.
 
This thread is about going iPad-only, not using an iPad with a desktop.

That is what the original post was about. You said an iPad "fundamentally can't replace a real computer." You were wrong about that.

But the discussion about your dad replacing his laptop/desktop with an iPad was a separate conversation.

The iPhone already largely killed off the whole portable wifi laptop around the house thing.

For some people.

At home, I just leave the laptop docked, and if I need something somewhere else, the iPhone can usually do it. If not, I just walk upstairs. In a way, my laptop replaced my desktop, and my iPhone replaced my laptop.

Thanks for describing your situation! Again.
 
I guess the conclusion is that the iPad can't replace another computer. Except for all the cases where it actually does. But that doesn't count, because those people aren't doing Real Serious Computing (like moving files around, or just selectively picking something the iPad can't do as an example of what is Real Work by Professionals).
 
That is what the original post was about. You said an iPad "fundamentally can't replace a real computer." You were wrong about that.

But the discussion about your dad replacing his laptop/desktop with an iPad was a separate conversation.
For some people.

Thanks for describing your situation! Again.

I love how you just argued both sides of the debate in the same post. Amusing.

If the iPad replaces a laptop, and you still have a desktop, it didn't replace having a real computer. You still HAVE a real computer.
 
I like playing PC games, doing visual design for a living, and using Logic Pro to record. Unfortunately I can't ever see this happening in my lifetime.
 
I love how you just argued both sides of the debate in the same post. Amusing.

If the iPad replaces a laptop, and you still have a desktop, it didn't replace having a real computer. You still HAVE a real computer.

What? It replaced a laptop, full-stop. A laptop isn't a 'real' computer? The iPad in this case presumably does everything the laptop did for the user in question. They had two 'real' computers, now they have one and an iPad. Also there's no such thing as a 'real' computer vs. other kinds of computers; it's just a self-serving distinction without a difference.

EDIT:
MR: "Hey BiggAW, I threw out my laptop because I can do everything I used to do on it with my iPad."
BiggAW: "Wow, that sounds like you replaced your 'real' computer with an iPad, whaddaya know."
MR: "Also, there is a desktop on a table inside my house."
BiggAW: "Guess that means you didn't replace your 'real' computer after all, heh."
MR: "No, wait, I lied, I don't have a desktop. Did I replace a 'real' computer or not?"
BiggAW: *passes out from his cognitive dissonance*
 
Last edited:
I love how you just argued both sides of the debate in the same post. Amusing.

If the iPad replaces a laptop, and you still have a desktop, it didn't replace having a real computer. You still HAVE a real computer.

I love how you can't distinguish between replacing a single computer and replacing all your computers.
 
What? It replaced a laptop, full-stop. A laptop isn't a 'real' computer? The iPad in this case presumably does everything the laptop did for the user in question. They had two 'real' computers, now they have one and an iPad. Also there's no such thing as a 'real' computer vs. other kinds of computers; it's just a self-serving distinction without a difference.

EDIT:
MR: "Hey BiggAW, I threw out my laptop because I can do everything I used to do on it with my iPad."
BiggAW: "Wow, that sounds like you replaced your 'real' computer with an iPad, whaddaya know."
MR: "Also, there is a desktop on a table inside my house."
BiggAW: "Guess that means you didn't replace your 'real' computer after all, heh."
MR: "No, wait, I lied, I don't have a desktop. Did I replace a 'real' computer or not?"
BiggAW: *passes out from his cognitive dissonance*

Wow the concept of replacing your computer entirely and replacing a second computer went right over your head didn't it?
 
In my case, is there Microsoft Office 2010 or 2011? Didn't think so.
Cloudon gives you Office 2010.
In her case, I don't know where my grandmother is uploading, some club she's in and edits minutes for.
So if you don't know enough about her situation, why argue it can't be done? There are plenty of FTP programs and other utilities that allow uploading files, but if you start with the premise it can't be done, surprise surprise, you'll never figure out how to do it.
 
Wow the concept of replacing your computer entirely and replacing a second computer went right over your head didn't it?

Not at all.

What if my laptop in this scenario was my primary computer? What if I told you I tossed my desktop but not my laptop? What if I replaced both? What if I have three computers? What if I replaced an Apple II with an iPad? (Those are rhetorical questions, don't bother)

Your argument divides the world into two kinds of computers, 'real' ones and some other kind. You've implicitly defined 'real computer' as 'not an iPad', and then conclude 'the iPad will never replace a real computer' as though it's some kind of insight.
 
The one thing holding me back from getting rid of my tower at home is all the content I have from BEFORE iOS devices were the center of my digital life:

1) Large video files. We used to use a camcorder with DV Tape. When the tape was full, we would play the video into the computer via Firewire and create files out of them for burning to DVD or even just streaming to the TV over the network. I can't fit all those on an iPad. I suppose I could put them up on the cloud somehow, but that will be costly. I do use iTunes Match for all of our music, so I'm not too worried about that.

2) Software. I still have a program ESSENTIAL to my workflow that does not run on the iPad.

3) Backups. I don't like keeping one copy of anything. I like my backups and I have them run once a night from all my important folders. I like the fact that if my house is on fire, I can grab my Western Digital 3 TB external hard drive and leave with everything. In a less dramatic example, if my whole computer crashes, I'm fine. Still have the backups. Again, some really robust cloud storage would probably be a smarter and safer way to to this, but also expensive.

But like some other people have commented, my tower PC has been reduced to a backup runner/media server that runs one piece of software I still need. The rest of my life exists in iOS. I think for someone who has ALWAYS done all this stuff in iOS, you could very easily go PC-less.
 
Cloudon gives you Office 2010.

So if you don't know enough about her situation, why argue it can't be done? There are plenty of FTP programs and other utilities that allow uploading files, but if you start with the premise it can't be done, surprise surprise, you'll never figure out how to do it.

Why are you trying to do some bizarre Mcgyvver-around with an iPad, when, guess it, a real computer does it just fine?

Cloudon wouldn't work without an internet connection, and that defeats the whole concept of going "iPad-only", as you are just remotely connecting to a Windows VM with some extra GUI/fullscreen apps wrapped around it.

What if my laptop in this scenario was my primary computer? What if I told you I tossed my desktop but not my laptop? What if I replaced both? What if I have three computers? What if I replaced an Apple II with an iPad? (Those are rhetorical questions, don't bother)

You'd still have a real computer in either of those scenarios.
 
You'd still have a real computer in either of those scenarios.

Amazing. You bothered to reply to rhetorical questions and completely ignored the substantive point. Do you know 'rhetorical questions' are ones which aren't looking for an answer? Here's the substantive point again, since you've committed the same mistake, talking about 'real' computers which is a meaningless concept:

Your argument divides the world into two kinds of computers, 'real' ones and some other kind. You've implicitly defined 'real computer' as 'not an iPad', and then conclude 'the iPad will never replace a real computer' as though it's some kind of insight.
 
Why are you trying to do some bizarre Mcgyvver-around with an iPad, when, guess it, a real computer does it just fine?

Because the point of the thread is going iPad only. You don't have to, but many can, including apparently your grandma's use case.

Cloudon wouldn't work without an internet connection, and that defeats the whole concept of going "iPad-only", as you are just remotely connecting to a Windows VM with some extra GUI/fullscreen apps wrapped around it.
If your grandma has an internet connection to be able to upload files, then she has an internet connection to be able to use CloudOn ;)

The point of this thread isn't that in some specific cases there may be a better tool for the job, but that the iPad can be used to get the job done. A similar parallel would be that there are plenty of professional applications that benefit from having one or more high resolution monitors, but you can also use a lower resolution laptop to get the job done. It's not the best tool for the job, but it can be done.
 
As soon as apple ports Xcode to iOS.

Although I would still be missing a photoshop replacement. I need something to match its layers and layer styles for creating graphics.

Also, it would still need a more integrated file system, as if I make music in GarageBand I would have to email it to myself to put it into Xcode..every time it changes. Not fun.

Also, faster text selection would be good. And I would be using my Logitech/zagg BT keyboard. (Also need them to implement an app switching keyboard shortcut.)

So not anytime soon, unless Apple has a big announcement at WWDC this year :D
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.