Welp, I've come full circle. I got the P10PXL at launch and returned it because it would refuse to work with my Galaxy Watch Ultra. Bought and sold Oppo X9P, OnePlus 15. Currently have the S26U. Saw a P10PXL at Best Buy open box for $740, applied $25 rewards as well. Phone is pristine and looks unused, not even a micro-scratch on the screen. Couldn't resist for the price, one of those rare Best Buy open box gems. Been using it for 2 days, my Watch Ultra now syncs perfectly w/ the Pixel. Having BB Total membership also adds re-assurance.
I like the S26U but want more for $1300 and am just "meh" about the phone. Little issues such as poor fingerprint recognition despite multiple fingerprints / resets / tuning and screen protectors. Lack of unified visual voicemail within the Phone app. I still find battery life to not be great and use the phone in "light" performance mode. With the S25U this was fine, with the S26U I've seen little hitches and micro-stutters. Battery life has been better so far on the Pixel, but it's new and has far fewer apps so we'll see. And software updates, I like day 1 updates rather than waiting months for Android 17.
I love OneUI and all of its features. Luckily the Panels app on the Play store is really solid and I don't miss any features I have on the Edge panel of the S26U. I have been getting many spam calls as well for some reason, they have disappeared on the Pixel (for now). The only game I play is Retro Bowl so I don't care about Snapdragon vs Tensor. Have to say the haptics on the Pixel are the best, the keyboard really is excellent.
I think I'll be sending the S26U back to Amazon, I have 5 more days. I'm spoiled by iOS and live activities on the lock screen which I use all the time and really miss on Android. I like what I'm reading about Android 17 on the Pixel and hope that it'll finally utilize live activities (and force devs to implement it).
I'll be tempted by the upcoming Z Fold Wide and iPhone foldables for sure. But after my experience with some Chinese phones and S26U I've grown to appreciate the Pixel again. Thanks for reading!