Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
I have a family that primarily uses iPhones and iPads. It’s not uncommon for there to be several iPhones and iPads in the kitchen and family room area during the hour leading up to dinner while we cook. We also have two paired OG HomePods that serve this area. It’s become laughable how useless Siri is when we want to listen to music, change the volume, add something to the shopping list, etc. And it keeps getting worse over time. It would at least be bearable if we saw improvement. We will ask SirI to play music and instead of music starting on the HomePods, an iPad starts playing. We will get music going on the HomePods and then ask Siri to change the volume and one of the iPads will blurt out “Media will play softer from now on” but the volume on the HomePods is unchanged. We will ask again, and a different iPad will respond. I have tried turning off Siri on the iPads but that causes Shortcuts that I have created to not work when spoken to the HomePods. It’s as if Apple engineers have created this huge tangled mess that even they can’t figure out. It’s almost comical, but I’m not laughing Apple. The only FEMALE in the ENTIRE house of 3 people will ask Siri to do something and Siri constantly asks her “Who’s speaking?” Apple, please get your act together. And I am totally open to suggestions to tame this beast. I’m about to throw kitchen knives at Siri when I cook!

It truly is pathetic. It’s been over 10 years and feels like it’s only gotten worse
 
Actual exchange I had last night:

Me: “Hey Siri, turn off the fan in 15 minutes”

HomePod: “I’m sorry, you must set automations at least one minute in advance”

Me: “Hey Siri, turn off the fan in 15 minutes”

HomePod: “I’m sorry, you must set automations at least one minute in advance”

Me: “Hey Siri, turn off the fan in 15 minutes”

HomePod: “I’m sorry, I’m not sure who’s speaking. Who is this?”

Me: “David”


HomePod: “I’m sorry, you must set automations at least one minute in advance”


Me: “Hey Siri, just turn off the fan”

Siri: “okay”
The definition of insanity is doing the same thing over and over and expecting different results. Siri is borked, but the user here doesn't learn very fast and is about as smart as Siri.
 
Easy improvement would be alternative trigger phrases like Alexa has.

I have to disable Siri on all devices permanently (not necessarily a bad thing) except for HomePod, just to make the HomePod usable.
 
Last edited:
The watch can already do this. You don't need to say Hey Siri - just raise and speak. Software wise, this is already a solved problem. The issue is how to do this in a deliberate way with phones and HomePods without false activations.
What? No. Instead of 'hey Siri', it's using the wrist raise action as a prompt to listen. This is not the same problem at all.
 
My wife is British. She and Siri have communication problems.

I do not really want Siri "awake" all the time. So easy then to have all of our communications monitored by some outside authority without our knowledge. Read George Orwells "1984" written in 1954 to see how this will play out. We are nearly there now. We power off the Home Pods so we can chat in the living room.

The ethernet cable going to the television on the wall works in both directions and a small monitoring camera in the bezel would allow visual monitoring. Many TVs are already "voice" controlled...... How about that iPhone, iPad, and laptops with video cameras for FaceTime? We put a sticker over the camera on the iPads and laptops.

How about the alarm cameras throughout the house?

We the people have made it ever so easy to be monitored 24/7 in the "privacy" of our own homes.....
 
I'm all for Siri improvements, but they should probably focus on their evident server-side issues first. *Every* time I want to turn "living room lamp to X percent," Siri first says it can't find anything in Home with that name. The second time it works immediately. Just one of many, many, many, many examples.
 
Why not just scrap Siri and start over. Apple ignored Siri for like 5 years after introduction. Everyone else has moved on to something that works. Changing "Hey Siri" is not going to fix it.

100% this. Siri was initially introduced as nothing more than a gimmick, but then competitors began developing useful versions and for some reason Apple has never cared to follow suit. Siri remains almost as useless as introduced on the 4S…
 
My wife is British. She and Siri have communication problems.

I do not really want Siri "awake" all the time. So easy then to have all of our communications monitored by some outside authority without our knowledge. Read George Orwells "1984" written in 1954 to see how this will play out. We are nearly there now. We power off the Home Pods so we can chat in the living room.

The ethernet cable going to the television on the wall works in both directions and a small monitoring camera in the bezel would allow visual monitoring. Many TVs are already "voice" controlled...... How about that iPhone, iPad, and laptops with video cameras for FaceTime? We put a sticker over the camera on the iPads and laptops.

How about the alarm cameras throughout the house?

We the people have made it ever so easy to be monitored 24/7 in the "privacy" of our own homes.....
Do you ever leave your house? There are cameras EVERYWHERE in public watching you! ;)
 
Perhaps it’s me who’s the odd one out. I find it excellent for sending a quick text to my wife when out and about. Just take my phone out of my pocket, no need to unlock and squint at the screen in the sunshine. Just say “ Hey Siri, message *wife* that I’m on my way and it’s done
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.