The SD card slot is as thin as USB-C and it makes sense to include for people who need it.
Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Hands-On With Apple's New 16-Inch MacBook Pro
- Thread starter MacRumors
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
Here’s my take, which is worth what you paid for it
- First gen issues: keyboard would be the most likely to have a problem, it’s the only first gen component that comes to mind
- NVidia anything: 0% chance as long as Jensen is CEO imo
- Optional Touch Bar: 0% chance until at least 2024
- FaceID: I would guess maybe a 25% chance
- “expected” 1080p camera: 50/50. I do expect improved quality overall but might very well remain 720p.
I think my word choice was perfect. And more people have liked my comments than disliked them. 🙂
A product that’s inconvenient to hold and lug around (due to its need for additional hardware) is a product that’s inherently less portable than one which is easy to lug around (without the need for additional hardware).
My 2015 MacBook Pro is inherently more portable than my thinner/lighter 2017 MacBook Pro, because it consists of less stuff I have to carry.
In fact, 2015 Macbook´s Pro are the most wanted on the second hand market.
Apple has an entire team dedicated to examining pro workflows. But it’s possible they aren’t familiar with yours.
Some of us here with a background in your profession may be able to help you with your problem, if you’re interested in solving it.
I haven’t really been following your issues that closely, though I understand you want an SD card reader in your laptop. How important is an internal SD card slot to your workflow? Are there other ports you also need?
Not knowing your profession it’s impossible to say, but there could be ways to meet your requirements that I and others might be able to help you with.
I think the Touch Bar is useful. However like you, I usually work docked so the usefulness is greatly diminished. I really had expected Apple offering an external keyboard with Touch Bar.
Anyway, about the function keys; did you know you can configure the Touch Bar in the Keyboard panel of System Preferences? The setting "Touch Bar shows" can be set to Expanded Control Strip. This makes it basically have the same layout as the external keyboard.
I know it might not seem like it to you but you are in an overwhelming minority here. Apple is clearly listening to and implementing changes were it is deemed necessary to keep its customers. It seems to me that new MacBook Pro 16” is nearly perfect for pro/power users and will probably only get better when all the minor issues are rolled out. You have gone on quite the rant about having to plug in a dongle to use an SD card and the inconvenience of having to swap between a Touch Bar keyboard and non-touch bar keep bar keyboards but it’s obviously not an issue for the vast majority. I think you’re just gonna have to deal with it or keep using your 2015 MacBook Pro, or buy a pc 😬
Key word in your post: "I."
Think about that.
[automerge]1573889311[/automerge]
Pure speculation based on no facts. 0/10 credibility.
[automerge]1573889361[/automerge]
Despite my 2 comments above...same. I'll take the tradeoffs.
[automerge]1573889480[/automerge]
This is true. I started using the 2017 15" that my work provided this past summer, ditching my 2014 15" that I gave to my parents. The dongle situation continuously annoys me — and was ultimately unnecessary.
This idea that "Apple can do no wrong" is simply absurd. I don't know why people buy into it. Nor do I understand why "I don't need X so most people don't need X" is the mindset of so many people.
Oh wait. I do. Cognitive biases and arrogance.
Only Apple could market a 'new' scissor keyboard to replace their grossly unreliable butterfly keyboard as a notable feature.
Such a ridiculous price too, not that it surprises me anymore.
Such a ridiculous price too, not that it surprises me anymore.
Wait, I'm no Apple defender here, but how is the price any more ridiculous than the models from the last 2 years?
Yes it would be very easy to include an SD card slot, but then people wouldn't be forced to buy even more expensive storage upgrades from them.
[automerge]1573890137[/automerge]
You're right, it's not more ridiculous than the last 2 years, which is why I said that it didn't surprise me. I just don't think that the price is reasonable for a laptop.
Macs are Pc´s.
[automerge]1573890255[/automerge]
Soldered everything.
Apple is laughing at ALL of us as they spend the money we gave them. The new MBP is better, but its not what it should be and besides that it replaces utter garbage. Demand everything you want! You worked hard for your money so be slow to give it up. If Apple doesn't make what you want or need, don't buy it. We can't pay them big dollars for mediocrity and expect them to do better. They aren't going to crumble quickly after throwing us this leftover design from 2016. Its NOT a new design people or it WOULD have an SD card reader and a decent web camera. This thing is stinking old crap. DEMAND BETTER!!!! WE control them with our money, not the other way around. Get Woke already.
Is the keyboard on this Macbook Pro smaller in side to accommodate for bigger speaker grills on the sides?
I cant help thinking compared to my own 2012 MBP i had in the past (with the same speaker grills) they are actually smaller and larger keyboard, while this 2019 MBP is smaller keyboard and larger grills
I'm kinda also surprised Apple decided t go "back" to this grill design, while you had a larger keyboard and no grills from recently.
Personally, i perfer the large keyboard anyday..
I cant help thinking compared to my own 2012 MBP i had in the past (with the same speaker grills) they are actually smaller and larger keyboard, while this 2019 MBP is smaller keyboard and larger grills
I'm kinda also surprised Apple decided t go "back" to this grill design, while you had a larger keyboard and no grills from recently.
Personally, i perfer the large keyboard anyday..
Can anybody tell me what's the benefit of Apple now using a 16" screen instead of 15.4"?
As far as I can tell there is absolutely no benefit. The footprint of the device has only gotten bigger and heavier. The screen has exactly the same work space scaling resolution. So no benefit there. So basically, content will appear slightly bigger on this 16" display than on the 15" version.
For me it seems they f'd themselves with keyboard and cooling issues in the past. Needed a bigger case. Didn't want huuuge bezels when using a 15.4" screen. So decided to make the screen a bit bigger instead of shrinking the chassis...
As far as I can tell there is absolutely no benefit. The footprint of the device has only gotten bigger and heavier. The screen has exactly the same work space scaling resolution. So no benefit there. So basically, content will appear slightly bigger on this 16" display than on the 15" version.
For me it seems they f'd themselves with keyboard and cooling issues in the past. Needed a bigger case. Didn't want huuuge bezels when using a 15.4" screen. So decided to make the screen a bit bigger instead of shrinking the chassis...
You totally nail it.
I would love to spend 3k on an new MBP since years, but these two points still hold me back on my 2015 MBP. I just want to go to clients and wework and plug in any Minidisplay, HDMI, USB-A Stuff or SD Card without to think about bringing or in worst case forgetting my dongle. Or permanently placing them in several working spaces.
And i want to control volume, brightness, play and so on with a fast and haptic keyboard click.
Hope, it wont take Apple another 4 years Apple to finally get back to that real Pro Layout and Usability.
[automerge]1573893950[/automerge]
Sure you need to use the touchbar since its holds main functionality like Play, Volume, Brightness etc. And why carry an dongle, when it could be avoided like in most other laptops or my actual MBP 2015? No need for that, it just works out of the box!
simple question, what's more portable, a computer with ports and slots integrated, or one where you have to carry a bag of dongles for everything you want to connect?
Don't forget RED Mag. That's the pro-est of the pro!
All those Youtubers with RED cameras have been using Mac laptops like this without a card slot.
Yet I never hear them complain that they have to buy a separate RED Mag reader.
The thing I most dislike about the 2018 keyboard I have is the size. I’ve not had any problems with dead keys (yet), I actually like the travel, I don’t mind the noise - basically I can type pretty well and can adapt to different keyboards pretty well for the most part. I do however find the keys slightly too big and slightly too far apart and that is the one thing I’ve not adapted too and at this point probably won’t - and that alone makes me make a lot of typos. If this new layout has slightly smaller keys I’m very happy with that
Please speak only for yourself and not for „us all“.
I don’t need removable RAM and if I need more storage I plug in a tb or usb drive.
Couple of questions w.r.t. display resolutions; does the small bump in screen diagonal make a difference to the usability of the 1920x1200 resolution over the 15"? I find it borderline on the 15" at present so wondering if the slight bump in size makes it more comfortably usable?
Additionally, is there an integer scaled resolution (1536x960) or just the scaled resolutions Apple lists on their website? (I'm guessing it still defaults to 1680x1050?).
Additionally, is there an integer scaled resolution (1536x960) or just the scaled resolutions Apple lists on their website? (I'm guessing it still defaults to 1680x1050?).