Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Health app forces tracking on everyone and logs it!
- Thread starter X-X
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
Regardless Apple should have an option to turn it off. Say for example you told your GF you're gonna be home all day but want to surprise her later that night with a gift you decided to pick up. She comes home and hops on your phone and for some reason goes to the health app, and sees you have a few thousand steps. Well there goes the surprise.
Because one can't walk 1000 steps at home in a day..or, hell, even go for a short walk?
so you're actually defending Apple for not giving us an option to turn it off? Actually days I stay home I don't even get 1000 steps.
I went to health app - I have a 5s on 8.02 and it says no data. Is that where some people are upset about how many steps? Or should I look elsewhere?
I love it people use Google and Facebook who collect more data than anyone else and sell it, etc. but no one complains about them. Anyone who actually thinks the government is capable of using this data lives in a different country than I do (US).
I love it people use Google and Facebook who collect more data than anyone else and sell it, etc. but no one complains about them. Anyone who actually thinks the government is capable of using this data lives in a different country than I do (US).
No. When you're home, you're not allowed to do any chores, run errands, walk the dog, etc. You have to stay in bed all day without getting up to eat or use the restroom.
I do think OP is being a little paranoid, if his stated reasons are genuine. At the same time, all the posts basically saying "get over it" might be missing the point. I don't blame OP for wanting the option of removing that kind of information from his phone, especially since it's not crucial for the device to operate properly.
It would be one thing if it took a tech wiz and special hardware to access the information, but this seems to be a case where any Joe Shmoe can view it at anytime, as long as OP or someone with the passcode wakes the device.
It would be one thing if it took a tech wiz and special hardware to access the information, but this seems to be a case where any Joe Shmoe can view it at anytime, as long as OP or someone with the passcode wakes the device.
Then it's time to change your girlfriend for invading your privacy, which is what you are desperate to protect from Apple and everyone else...
So, due to this thread, I fired up the Health app for the very first time. I went to the Walking/Steps sections and was easily able to "Clear All". So, it's really not a big deal. It does seem like recording all that information is using up processing power, but it is what it is.
to the OP...the good news is the info my iPhone 6 tracks is shoddy at best.
Flights of stairs, totally OFF
Steps and time, OFF
Nike + App totally OFF
I wish I could find a way to calibrate this Health App. It is neat but doesn't actually work for me.
in the past pedometers would never accurately measure my steps (and thus mileage) at least most had a sensitivity toggle but even then it was off.
Out of the box most pedometers are 20% OFF my steps/movements. I can get close to 5-10% but it will always be under what I actually step.
I've been told I have a soft walk and guessing that's why these things are really off for me.
so, to the OP, put the phone down when you can around the house. don;t take it everywhere...and "you're walking wrong"
Flights of stairs, totally OFF
Steps and time, OFF
Nike + App totally OFF
I wish I could find a way to calibrate this Health App. It is neat but doesn't actually work for me.
in the past pedometers would never accurately measure my steps (and thus mileage) at least most had a sensitivity toggle but even then it was off.
Out of the box most pedometers are 20% OFF my steps/movements. I can get close to 5-10% but it will always be under what I actually step.
I've been told I have a soft walk and guessing that's why these things are really off for me.
so, to the OP, put the phone down when you can around the house. don;t take it everywhere...and "you're walking wrong"
I think surprise would be ruined if she goes poking through your Frequent Locations history. Which records and shows every location you visit on the map. It also shows the number of visits, date, and time spent at a location.
The OP's seems to just have an axe to grind. Step counting and logging has been in place since the M7 chip was introduced with the iPhone 5s LAST YEAR. The data remains resident on the chip for one week before it automatically deletes. Installing a step tracking app can pull the data from the M7, and trace the data back for a full week. Did ANYONE complain about this, or cite privacy concerns last year?
Without taking additional steps, the Health app, by default, only tracks the steps and miles walked (plus altitude if you're using the new M8 chip that comes with the 6/6 Plus). Anyone who's paranoid, can delete the data from the app. But, as mentioned, the M7 chip implemented built-in step tracking more than a year ago. I have not seen any reports of anyone treating this as some privacy breach.
For the Health app, any other health information requires additional signal inputs that are not built into the iPhone. People who use the Health app for more sensitive health tracking would presumably not care that the phone tracks this information, given that they would have already authorized external devices to send this information to their phone.
And anyone who's really that concerned about step tracking being sensitive information that must be protected from peering eyes at all costs, would probably already use a strong passcode to lock their device.
Without taking additional steps, the Health app, by default, only tracks the steps and miles walked (plus altitude if you're using the new M8 chip that comes with the 6/6 Plus). Anyone who's paranoid, can delete the data from the app. But, as mentioned, the M7 chip implemented built-in step tracking more than a year ago. I have not seen any reports of anyone treating this as some privacy breach.
For the Health app, any other health information requires additional signal inputs that are not built into the iPhone. People who use the Health app for more sensitive health tracking would presumably not care that the phone tracks this information, given that they would have already authorized external devices to send this information to their phone.
And anyone who's really that concerned about step tracking being sensitive information that must be protected from peering eyes at all costs, would probably already use a strong passcode to lock their device.
