Become a MacRumors Supporter for $25/year with no ads, private forums, and more!

HomePod's Sound Continues to Receive Top Marks After Listening Demos in New York and London

MacRumors

macrumors bot
Original poster
Apr 12, 2001
50,414
11,806



Apple last week invited select reporters to one-hour-long HomePod listening demos in New York City and London, resulting in several first impressions of the speaker's sound quality being shared online over the past few days.


We've rounded up all of the first impressions we've come across so far, and highlighted some excerpts that we thought were interesting below. If you spot an article not listed here, let us know in the comments section.

o Business Insider
o TechCrunch
o CNET
o Engadget
o iMore
o Mashable
o TechRadar
o Digital Trends
o Tom's Guide
o Expert Reviews
o Wired UK
o iNews UK
o Huffington Post UK
o Vogue UK
o Refinery29
o Gear Patrol
o Stuff.tv
o Alphr
o Lance Ulanoff
o T3

The consensus is that the HomePod sounds very good, although some felt the quality isn't exactly worth the price. A few reporters were more impressed by upcoming stereo sound capabilities of two HomePods in the same room.

Keep in mind these listening demos were conducted by Apple in controlled environments, so we'll have to wait for more in-depth reviews once reporters and customers get the speaker into their hands and try it out.

Business Insider's Avery Hartmans
After spending an hour demoing Apple's new HomePod smart speaker, I can say one thing with confidence: it sounds incredible.
Overall, HomePod is both louder and better-sounding than I expected. The bass was strong without being too heavy, vocals were crisp and clear, and the overall sound felt somehow bright and energized. I also got a demo of a stereo setup using two HomePods -- that functionality is coming later on through a free update -- and was blown away. So while I can't give a definitive verdict until testing it for myself, I will say that HomePod gives a great first impression.
Wired UK's Jeremy White
We will have much more to say in a full review, but on first impressions while the HomePod looks great, is super simple to set up and is undoubtedly powerful, the sound produced does not immediately match up to its £319 price tag.
What becomes immediately apparent is the formidable bass the HomePod kicks out. What's more, the sound remains constant as you walk around the room, no doubt thanks to those beam-forming tweeters. The vocals are clear as a bell, too. It's not all good news, however. There is a distinct lack of mid-range, leaving you feeling that something is missing in the mix.
TechCrunch's Brian Heater
As advertised, the thing sounds great.
Apple's engineers were able to get a lot of rich and full sound out of that little footprint. The speaker is particularly adept as isolating vocals and maintaining often muddled aural aspects, like background singers and audience sounds in live recordings.
CNET's David Carnoy
Ultimately, my initial impression is that the HomePod sounds very good for the type of speaker it is and it certainly stacks up well against the competition -- some of it less expensive, some of it more.
But like all speakers, it has its limitations and the HomePod left me wanting for true stereo sound. Which is probably why the only time I got truly jazzed during the demo was when they paired the two HomePods together and delivered some real separation.
iNews UK's Rhiannon Williams
While it's difficult to get a proper grasp of how a speaker sounds in a short space of time, a second listen to the HomePod reinforces my earlier favourable impressions.
While at just under seven inches tall it's undoubtedly on the small side, it's capable of incredible volume, easily filling a room and reinforcing its house party credentials. This is particularly true when two of them pair to play the same song simultaneously: it's a bassy tour-de-force.
Apple began accepting HomePod orders through its online store and Apple Store app on Friday in the United States, Australia, and United Kingdom, with the first deliveries to customers estimated to arrive Friday, February 9.

Update: A user on the audiophile subreddit who claims to have been present at Apple's listening demo believes the HomePod, based on its size and price, is significantly better than most bookshelf speakers under $1,000.

Article Link: HomePod's Sound Continues to Receive Top Marks After Listening Demos in New York and London
 
  • Like
Reactions: MrUNIMOG

naltst*

macrumors member
Apr 14, 2005
79
8
I have a few airport expresses connected to decent sets of studio monitors, my surround sound system and a stereo system. Pick any speakers you want or already have...

The stereo has digital in and a decent DAC. Others by 3.5mm jack.

Multi room works great from iTunes (but not iOS unless the airport express gets airplay2) and has FOR YEARS! I use the remote app to play from iTunes rather than playing from the device itself.
 
Comment

Relentless Power

macrumors Nehalem
Jul 12, 2016
34,613
35,993
Free units often get good reviews. Don't want to cut the hand that feeds you right?
I'll wait for paying users to post some reviews.

I don't really consider these "Reviews." These are more hands on or first impressions by demoing. None the less, I would say the HomePod has some initial positive feedback thus far. I expect user reviews to be very promising, which I to prefer user reviews Over journalists or critics.
 
Comment

gnasher729

macrumors P6
Nov 25, 2005
17,376
4,607
There is no such thing as "true stereo sound". Stereo sound is not "true". Stereo sound is an attempt to approximate the correct listening experience by producing sound from two different positions. HomePod approximates the correct listening experience in a different way. It will not be equal to stereo sound, and it won't try to make it equal. The questions isn't whether it's the same, but whether it is as good as stereo.
[doublepost=1517102281][/doublepost]
My $30000 Duntech Crown Sovereigns want to cash u outside, how 'bout that?
But in all seriousness, after the $5k point, you begin encountering seriously diminishing returns.
The music store where you buy begins encountering seriously increased profits :)
[doublepost=1517102395][/doublepost]
I was under the impression it shows up as an airplay device.. so how exactly is it limited to Apple Music?

You can still stream Spotify etc through AirPlay.

Correct me if I'm wrong

According to Tom's Hardware, if it's playing through AirPlay, it's not worth it. If you find that opinion strange, so do I.
 
Comment
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.