—I'm sticking with the better MBP by most measures.
Most measures? Name one.
Hint: It's not the ports, keyboard or battery life, because all are better on the new one.
[doublepost=1489528744][/doublepost]After several months, it's still one of the best computers I've ever used.
I won't repeat myself how the screen is great, or how I like the design, keyboard, trackpad, etc. If you like this new MBP, you know why you like it - it's obvious. If you don't, nothing I say will change that.
But here's a thing that surprised me: I really loved the MagSafe but I don't miss it. The ability to plug in from each side is just that great, as well as the ability to remove the cable from the charger entirely (makes packing easier).
As for the TouchBar it's good. It's not great, and not a reason to get this laptop, but I like having it. I use it for Photoshop mostly, there are some really nice things there. Also, it's useful in Safari and Mail. Sure, I could make keyboard shortcuts for most, if not all, things on the Touch Bar - but I don't think I would ever get myself to dedicate a weird cmd combination to, say, "Flip Horizontal" in Photoshop. And yet, I use this daily. I'm sure you can Archive and Delete mail without the Touch Bar, but this is one of the fastest ways to do it. I also like to swipe the tabs in Safari or seek videos. And I even prefer the press-and-slide volume controls on it to the old buttons (no, you don't need two presses, for those that somehow still think you do). As I said, it's nothing revolutionary - but I consider "touch" on laptops to be equally "good, not great", if not even less good. At least Touch Bar is optimized for what it's meant to do, while touch input almost never is on Windows.
Also, macOS keeps surprising me, even after all these years. Did you know that the Info screen (the CMD+I thing) lists Layers from a Photoshop file? Or that both Preview and Quick Look show OBJ files - in 3D (you can rotate and zoom them)?
Anyway - love this computer. It's amazing.