Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Sorry if off topic, but I could use some advice.

I am experiencing the video card issue for a second time with my 15" early 2011 MBP - happened just this morning. Blue screen with jagged lines, then an attempt to reboot and each time it ends with a grey screen. It was repaired for this same issue about two years ago by a Apple authorized dealer. I have an appointment at an Apple Store tomorrow morning to deal with the current problem. Does the fact that my machine was repaired for this already once make me ineligible for another repair? I'm not sure if I should mention the previous repair, play up how this is the second time this is happening, or not mention it at all?

Thanks in advance for any help, and sorry if I'm out of line for posting here (feel free to mention another thread where I should ask about this).

No in fact if your repair was done by an authorised Apple technician they should pay you back for that as well.

However this issue seems just about unfixable all the "new" boards seem to be poorly fixed refurbished and often die within a few months to a year. The extended repair program ends at the end of 2016, so you'll probably be looking at a new computer sometime next year so I'd start considering that now.
 
No in fact if your repair was done by an authorised Apple technician they should pay you back for that as well.

However this issue seems just about unfixable all the "new" boards seem to be poorly fixed refurbished and often die within a few months to a year. The extended repair program ends at the end of 2016, so you'll probably be looking at a new computer sometime next year so I'd start considering that now.
Yeah, the only real way to get it fixed for good is to have a professional service reball the GPU with lead based solder. I found one on eBay to do mine, and it worked great afterward. (Costs about $150)
 
  • Like
Reactions: ajcgn
Hi @Samuelsan2001. Thank you for your reply.

Sorry I did not mention - my previous repair came just under the wire of my Apple Care - a few days or weeks before it expired, so I did not have to pay for that repair. This time I have no such coverage, but now there is Apple's repair program. An Apple agent said by phone that my MBP's serial and date of purchase means I am eligible, assuming the Apple Store tomorrow confirms the issue via their diagnostics. My concern is that might say I am not eligible because of the previous repair. Any thoughts? Thanks for any advice!

I have been eagerly awaiting the 2016 redesigned model, and have money set aside, but a working machine is crucial for my work until I can get my hands on one! :)
 
Yeah, the only real way to get it fixed for good is to have a professional service reball the GPU with lead based solder. I found one on eBay to do mine, and it worked great afterward. (Costs about $150)

True if you can find someone to do a leaded solder fix it should last well.
[doublepost=1464189089][/doublepost]
Hi @Samuelsan2001. Thank you for your reply.

Sorry I did not mention - my previous repair came just under the wire of my Apple Care - a few days or weeks before it expired, so I did not have to pay for that repair. This time I have no such coverage, but now there is Apple's repair program. An Apple agent said by phone that my MBP's serial and date of purchase means I am eligible, assuming the Apple Store tomorrow confirms the issue via their diagnostics. My concern is that might say I am not eligible because of the previous repair. Any thoughts? Thanks for any advice!

I have been eagerly awaiting the 2016 redesigned model, and have money set aside, but a working machine is crucial for my work until I can get my hands on one! :)

No that's fine they will keep fixing it until the end of this year.
 
  • Like
Reactions: groundcontrol
My concern is that might say I am not eligible because of the previous repair. Any thoughts?
- Not relevant at all, as mentioned. Lots of people have had 3 or 4 repairs on the same machine.
A friend of mine is coming into his 4th logic board (so 3rd repair) now, with the 3rd board lasting only a few days.

Mine is still fine now 15 months after the first repair, and the Radeon GPU gets pretty much constant use in clamshell mode.

There's no discernible pattern to it...
 
  • Like
Reactions: groundcontrol
Thanks @Samuelsan2001 and @JTToft. So Apple will repeatedly fix the same machine until the end of the year? Good to know.
- Indeed. Or up to four years from the original date of sale. Whichever is longer.
http://www.apple.com/support/macbookpro-videoissues/

Local laws may extend the period. For instance, I am entitled to free repairs for three years from the date of the most recent repair - no matter the original date of sale or expiry of Apple's programme.
 
  • Like
Reactions: groundcontrol
Yeah, the only real way to get it fixed for good is to have a professional service reball the GPU with lead based solder. I found one on eBay to do mine, and it worked great afterward. (Costs about $150)

For what it's worth, I had mine reballed a little over a year and a half ago and it's been fine since.

Please tell me where you get your lead reball service.

I want to keep mine working since Apple doesn't make 17-inch MacBook Pro anymore.
 
Just to follow up about my early 2011 15" MBP video card issue...took it to an Apple Store today and they are going to fix it without any charge. I should get it back in 3-5 days. I'm very relieved.

Thanks to everyone who replied to my post. I'll certainly keep the reball option in mind as we get past the end of the year (if I haven't bought the new 2016 MBP by then!).
 
  • Like
Reactions: JTToft
Totally not the question that I asked.

A Google search would bring up plenty of results.

I work in manufacturing, actually we do quick turn and prototyping. Anyway, when something goes wrong and we damage a BGA that can't be replaced, we've sent it off to these guys and they've done a good job so far.

http://www.circuitrework.com

I'm sure they'll charge you an arm and a leg for the service, but it might be worth it for you?
 
I just ran into this thread after I made a thread...

I had my logic board replaced in my late `11 in my last week of Applecare in end of '14 for the video and random restart issues... it was before the recall.

However, it has happened again this work! I need to go to apple to see how it will work to replace my logic board again. I think all of our MBPs are lemons. Very frustrating since my MBP is fast enough to last for longer if the logic boards keep working...
 
  • Like
Reactions: Queen6
I just ran into this thread after I made a thread...

I had my logic board replaced in my late `11 in my last week of Applecare in end of '14 for the video and random restart issues... it was before the recall.

However, it has happened again this work! I need to go to apple to see how it will work to replace my logic board again. I think all of our MBPs are lemons. Very frustrating since my MBP is fast enough to last for longer if the logic boards keep working...

That's how a lot of us feels.
 
That's how a lot of us feels.

Apple replaced my logic board and clamshell under the recall. Not excited to see it fail after the end the year. It was a headache to go to the store 2x and leave it overnight for testing to see the fail for my 2nd logic board. I call it a lemon. They should replace it with a latest equivalent model if I pay the difference if they don't offer anything better.

On the topic... An apple genius told me that his same '11 mbp has had 2 logics replaced. Interesting while I picked up my machine.
 
So what was the consensus about reballing being an appropriate long-term fix? Is that Rossman video correct about the chip being dead and that heating it restores it to life temporarily? Or does reballing actually fix it?
 
So what was the consensus about reballing being an appropriate long-term fix? Is that Rossman video correct about the chip being dead and that heating it restores it to life temporarily? Or does reballing actually fix it?
For what it's worth, from what I've read on forums, people who heat the motherboard find it to be a temporary fix at best. I've read that reballing is a permanent fix.

My only first hand knowledge is that my reball from more than a year and a half ago has stood up. I do a lot of video editing that raises the cpu temp from 34c to 93c and haven't had any problems with my 2011 MBP since the original GPU failure.
 
My second Logic Board repair has failed today. It didn't even last 4 months. The backlight doesn't to on, I can barely see the mouse to login... It goes and turns itself off before anything else shows...

I want apple to take this lemon POS back since it's going into the 4th logic board.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Queen6
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.