I think this and many other posts is are great examples of — yes it makes sense for apple to give people a choice, but is it actually good if most people are just making ill-informed choices?
First of all, the digital profiling tech companies are no where near sophisticated as people think, or as portrayed in popular media.
Second of all, even if it was, this tracking prompt does not prevent any of the things you mentioned.
All advertisers do today is when you visit their website, they, the business you interacted with, not Facebook, sends what you did on their website to Facebook or google. Then FB tries to match up with your profile, and show you ads based on the data that the business shared with FB, because the business asked them (and paid them) to do so.
What data is it basing off of? Well if you visited their website, the business will most likely want to retarget you. If you made a purchase, they just want to find more people like you, who might be likely to make the same purchase.
Thats all there is to it.
Apple doesn't care about your privacy, they are just worried that FB advertising is sidelining the actual App Store. No one goes to the App Store to discover things. Mobile developers especially gaming app developers advertise on FB to drive traffic and revenue. As the mobile phone market saturates, apple is looking for new sources of revenue, and advertising is a great one.
They are the ones knee capping competitors in the advertising space, while developing a different set of rules and requirements for their own ads. These will be based on EVERYTHING you do on your phone, your location, your search, what apps you use the most, what apps you spend most amount of time in, what news you are interested in, what you watch, what your purchasing habits are like (remember the Apple Card?) Don't take my word for it, here's an article from financial times
View attachment 1765206
and here's a screen of apple advertising terms and services — don't you just love how people give a long spiel on how much they care about "privacy", and they think they were offered controls for it, yet every activity on their phone is still being tracked and used for ads
Oh, this is all AFTER paying $1200 for the phone itself. I guess "you are the product" after all.
View attachment 1765210