Wouldn't it be easier to just get a CD player or an iPod/digital music player instead of using a PDA as a jukebox?
Originally posted by Bunzi2k4
*gasp* i want one!... too bad I already have an ipod... hmm... spray paint sounds good right now...
Originally posted by edesignuk
So I take it the Apple iPod looks like sh*t as well?It's the same damn thing in a different colour!!!
Originally posted by Bob Knob
The video is one of the funniest things I've ever seen...
"Why did Apple come to HP... HP's skill/technology/engineering..."
Hmm, HP is the innovator? That's like saying the guy who put the first whitewalls on tires invented the wheel. I think she has been drinking the same water that Gates does.
Originally posted by slowtreme
How is having Apple in control on my music rights any better or worse.
Originally posted by D0ct0rteeth
Yep. identical.. except that it is grey.
If it was deep polished black with a brushed aluminum back and brushed aluminum scroll wheel... blue backlighting..
That would be a sexy alternative, but its just a different color plastic..
Nothing special or artistic.
- Doc
Originally posted by Bob Knob
I also like HP stuff and have been using various HP printers and scanners for years.
However, her statements in the video clip clearly contradict themselves. In the opening she says how HP looked at Apple's system and found it superior, then she goes on about how Apple "came" to HP because of HP's engineering and integration skills. As is the iPod and iTunes runs on Macs and Windows, HP is doing nothing but repackaging it.
BTW, none of your stats you posted have anything to do with innovation... and no, I am not saying Apple invented the player market either, they just made a very successful one.
Originally posted by thatguy_youknow
They offer it as a service http://www.colorwarepc.com/content.aspx?id=16
They also paint powerbooks (don't know why somebody would want to paint over the Al) and iBooks (maybe if mine wasn't in the pooper with a logic board problem)
Originally posted by PDubNYC
regardless of your opinion of Thurrott or whether WMA is a superior format, I think that it would be nothing but a good thing to support multiple formats. I have friends that have their music in WMA format (keep your knee-jerk reactions to yourselves) and that is the only thing holding them back from buying an iPod.
Bottom line, more formats=more customers for Apple.
Originally posted by PDubNYC
regardless of your opinion of Thurrott or whether WMA is a superior format, I think that it would be nothing but a good thing to support multiple formats. I have friends that have their music in WMA format (keep your knee-jerk reactions to yourselves) and that is the only thing holding them back from buying an iPod.
Bottom line, more formats=more customers for Apple.
Originally posted by niter
Black would have been a nicer color, but really, I am not too worked up about the color as I like the white iPod the best.
I think this deal is great, but I am left questioning one thing, as many have. Why is there going to be an HP iPod when the current iPod is already Windows compatable.
Originally posted by iChan
does apple really NEED HP to help them to develop WMA on an iPod??? I think Apple would be able to do it themselves...
but i doubt it will happen anyway.
but if it did, wouldn't it make more sense for Apple to go to MS?
Originally posted by Maclarny
Hmmm...now that I tihnk about this new HP iPod I have some concerns. Doesn't this seem a lot like when apple started liscensing it's own OS to ther companies. Could Apple be pitching off a really good product only to have their own profits get sucked away?
Originally posted by Powerbook G5
It has been my experience that HP printers don't play well with Mac OS X, though. My family's all in one doesn't work with Panther, only Jaguar, and my girlfriend has tried two different kinds of HP printers, one of which came with her iMac when she bought it at CompUSA as a package deal. I always assumed that HP just didn't play well with Apple, so this is a bit of a surprise.
Originally posted by Maclarny
Hmmm...now that I tihnk about this new HP iPod I have some concerns. Doesn't this seem a lot like when apple started liscensing it's own OS to ther companies. Could Apple be pitching off a really good product only to have their own profits get sucked away?
Originally posted by sparks9
I hope Apple wont loose the iPod in this. Maybe people will think, wow HP sure is a great company making such a cool music player next time I'll buy a HP computer.
That would be sad.
Originally posted by the_dalex
From a marketing perspective, there are good reasons to play WMA, because that would pull Microsoft's last rug out from under them. If I were SJ, and if I wanted to stick it to Microsoft in the music world I would...
1) Build up the iPod into the most popular music player (done)
2) Build up the ITMS into the most popular online music store (done)
3) Let them criticize the only "flaw" being that it doesn't play Microsoft's proprietary format (done)
4) Suddenly allow the iPod to play WMA via a firmware update, in a final death blow (pending?)
When I look at the business model Apple has chosen, I don't see why this wouldn't work. We all are aware that the ITMS breaks even or at best makes a small profit, and the money is in the iPods. You don't want to sell music in WMA format, because you want the iPods to sell... but why not let the iPod play WMA? The only thing I can think of is that Microsoft would want a royalty or licensing fee, but if Apple came to them now, Microsoft can't deny them or gouge them without being dragged into court after their statements about "choice" being so important. Plus, I imagine if you just want a license to decode instead of encode, it wouldn't cost much.
I personally believe that the ITMS is the best music store out there, and I know SJ agrees. Let customers try them all with their iPod, and they will use the best service (or a combination of them all), but the important thing is...they have an iPod.
Now is the perfect time for the death blow, with the upcoming Pepsi promotion and the new HP crossover. Apple can completely take over the market by opening the iPod to WMA, and Microsoft has basically challenged them to so they can't get in the way. Microsoft's predictable behavior has them in a real pickle, but they've walked themselves into a trap.