Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
the internet isn't exactly the best place to get personal love advice, that said, just follow the unwritten rules of a break-up.

Rule #1 is Never Ever go back with an ex,

Not true. I have two friends who eventually got back together with their Ex's and all have been extremely happy. One couple has since gotten married. The other couple is very content with their "rediscovered relationship."

Getting back together with an Ex does work out well for a lot of people. Don't let anyone tell you otherwise. There's hope...and you may find that your relationship will be stronger than it ever was.

...of course that only works if the ex isn't crazy or destructive...or "toxic" as the OP says.
 
You don't really want her back.

I think you're only hurting at the fact that she got over you that quick once you made your decision and that now she's happy with someone else and not you. Also you seem to be addicted to the bad girl personality.

You desperately want what you can't have/tame anymore again probably because you think you'd be able to fix something this time.

My advice is to move on quick...start dating the people who actually care/like you and stop wasting time thinking about someone who is no longer thinking about you. You broke up with her for a reason.

Seeing a therapist for breaking up with someone you saw for 18 months?...girl must've worked you hard
 
New here, I'll try to keep it short...

I dated this girl (much younger than me) for a year and a half. We lived together, I recently broke up with her (2.5 months ago) We tried to stay together for the first two weeks, but It wasn't what I wanted. She was a very arrogant person with no friends. But very young and beautiful. She started seeing someone else (within 3 weeks) Now, I want her back so bad. I am very depressed. I told her how i feel, but she wont give in. I stopped contact with her. Now according to her myspace, she is totally in love with this new guy. I visit her page for my daily self torture. I am trying everything to get over her... I go to the gym every other day, eat healthy, hang out with friends and family, read, yoga, meditate, pray, I go to a therapist once a week, removed everything that reminds me of her. I've met at least 5 other girls since, and all of them are great and interested in me, but I'm just not ready. Nothing is working. I cry almost everyday. It sucks! I either want her back, or want to get over her.
What else can I do?

1. Stop visiting her MySpace page. It ain't going to make things any better for either of you.
2. Refrain from further contact with her because it'll only bring you heartache. You gave it a good try; now she knows you thought it was a mistake but she hasn't changed her mind which means she thinks she's better off without you now. Take the hint... it means "we all get to move on with our lives."
3. It's much cheaper to break up now than in divorce court. You done well.
4. It's history. She's history. Done with. Once you start believing that, that's when you'll be able to move forward with whatever tomorrow brings you.
5. Consider taking on a new hobby or something that will expose you to new people. Helping out at church, volunteering somewhere, taking flying lessons or scuba diving lessons, or whatever. Something, anything, really, that has a group of people with common interests coming together.

Good luck with seeing life has much more to offer to you -- and that you have much more to offer to someone else who hasn't yet discovered you.
 
1. Stop visiting her MySpace page. It ain't going to make things any better for either of you.
2. Refrain from further contact with her because it'll only bring you heartache. You gave it a good try; now she knows you thought it was a mistake but she hasn't changed her mind which means she thinks she's better off without you now. Take the hint... it means "we all get to move on with our lives."
3. It's much cheaper to break up now than in divorce court. You done well.
4. It's history. She's history. Done with. Once you start believing that, that's when you'll be able to move forward with whatever tomorrow brings you.
5. Consider taking on a new hobby or something that will expose you to new people. Helping out at church, volunteering somewhere, taking flying lessons or scuba diving lessons, or whatever. Something, anything, really, that has a group of people with common interests coming together.

Good luck with seeing life has much more to offer to you -- and that you have much more to offer to someone else who hasn't yet discovered you.

I still stand by my previous advice but you provided a nice post that I totally agree with.
 
Good God you people are simply wonderful! Lots of good advice and help. Here is what I've done so far: well first off I have deleted her completely from my life.. ie myspace, cell phone, email. etc.. NC!
2nd: I joined flight school which is very exciting, and I look forward to it everyday. And it definetly keeps my mind focused.
3rd: I started a saltwater fishtank which requires alot of my attention.

I have a cat and dog. I live alone in a big house with them. It gets a bit lonely at nights. I took up a new habit called drinking. It helps at nights. I also started on Anti-depressants (welbutrin). seems to be working so far... Along with the valiums... I'm a big ole mess. But I am determined to get better!
 
Good God you people are simply wonderful! Lots of good advice and help. Here is what I've done so far: well first off I have deleted her completely from my life.. ie myspace, cell phone, email. etc.. NC!
2nd: I joined flight school which is very exciting, and I look forward to it everyday. And it definetly keeps my mind focused.
3rd: I started a saltwater fishtank which requires alot of my attention.

I have a cat and dog. I live alone in a big house with them. It gets a bit lonely at nights. I took up a new habit called drinking. It helps at nights. I also started on Anti-depressants (welbutrin). seems to be working so far... Along with the valiums... I'm a big ole mess. But I am determined to get better!

Well, dunno what to tell you. I've been in yer shoes, taken my own advice, eventually did better with dealing with it after a while. Not something that happens overnight. But you have the power of free will and choice. Let's be honest here. It sucks right now, and it's not likely going to suck any less anytime soon. But if you sit on your gluteus maximus, waiting for change to come to you, then yeah, could be a while. What are you looking for here? Reassurance that it isn't going to suck, or will quickly become all perfect anytime soon? Sorry, pal, I can't honestly give that to you.

You mentioned starting flying lessons -- if you were serious with your reply as I was with mine, I would be more than happy to offer any tips with FAA regs, how to fly an airplane, tips/tricks, etc... (Flying is the easy part; landing is the harder one.) PM me if you'd like to discuss anything flying-related further.

I'm also here for you, but I believe that a key part of recovery is talking straight and being level with someone, so that I don't build up false expectations. Ultimately, if it's this deep-seated, you might be much better off chatting with someone who's professionally trained, 'cause I'm (or 99.9% of us here) not that person. I've also been there, done that, too, and there's no shame with getting a pro to help you think your way through a serious situation. None whatsoever.

Good luck with whatever you choose to do.
 
I dated this girl (much younger than me) for a year and a half.

How much younger? :eek: ;)

Pedobear+candy.jpg


I'm just kidding... but age can play a big part in a relationship, especially if the two of you are in your twenties. She may be acting all rude and arrogant now, however, in a few years she might look back and regret those actions. But I'm not saying that you should wait until she builds up some maturity!

There are plenty more fish in the sea. :)
 
The rule of never getting back with an ex is typically a good rule; but that really depends on why you guys broke up in the first place. If it is because of personality issues, or lifestyle -- they are gone. If it is something stupid like you forgot to take out the garbage on time, then there is hope. But in this case, write her off.

Second, drugs and alcohol are not the answer to the problem. Been there, done that, not worth it. Hobbies are a great way to get your mind off of the problem and onto something more constructive instead of destructive. Sounds like you're on this road. This is a good thing. I'd try stopping the alcohol after a few days; you really don't need it. The valumn the same thing, wean yourself off of it. I'd keep taking the anti-depressants until your doctor tells you to stop.

When your ready, and it shouldn't be too long, start getting out more. Going to places to make yourself happy. Be it bars, arcades, shopping, hiking, etc.. anything, get yourself out, and do things, maybe you'll meet someone new. But here is a tip, when you finally do meet someone new, don't drop all the hobbies you're picking up now, keep doing them. Flying, Biking, whatever. That is what make you, you, and she should accept that. I find way too many guys drop EVERYTHING and focus just on her. Not only does this end up causing tension but if things don't go well; the guys end up sucking wind and devastated.

I also would recommend living alone for a few years. Take the time, find out who YOU are and who you want to be. What makes you happy and what you can do to keep yourself from being depressed. Once you know what you want, and how to achieve it, adding someone into the mix is easier and less disruptive, just stay focused on who you are and what you want. Don't give up everything for someone else. If you both realize this, and don't get in each others way, if things go bad, it is much easier to chalk up to experience. But also, if things go good, it makes long term marriage much easier -- because you learn to not only take care of yourself, but to respect the other person's dreams / goals / ambitions.

If you have to give up the things that you love for someone else; then they really aren't the person for you. You don't need to do everything together as a couple, it is OK for her not to love Golf; you may not like some things she does. As long as you can respect each other and not let it come in the way, then you'll be OK.

Think for the partnership is not a bad thing, I'm not suggesting that people should be obnoxious and demand that their hobbies are more important then the relationship. No, I'm not saying that, but you shouldn't have to get rid of it either. If you're really into Model building and you really enjoy it; but she thinks it is a waste of money / time, then there WILL be problems. If she doesn't like it but understands you do; and you respect that and make sure that it doesn't come between you guys (example, her best friend is getting married on Sunday and she expects you to go, but there is a model show going on that same day . . . yes it is something you want to do, but you do have to bend once in a while, go to the wedding).

I've been married 14 years now. It hasn't been easy; in fact we were just one step away from divorce about 4 years ago. We were not seeing eye to eye, she made demands and if I didn't follow she would get mad. I finally grew a backbone and stood up to her and said no. I learned to be strong for myself and for me. Not to let her, or anyone else, walk all over me (very common geek thing to do btw). Once I stopped being a wimp and doing some things to make myself happy first; everyone was much more happy. We have a great relationship now, much stronger then before. But I also know what if it ever came down to it, and she left, I would be fine.

Good luck, and believe it or not, you're not alone.
 
Sounds like she is sticking it to you. Go have meaningless sex with someone in the mean time. Then give yourself time to heal and start anew with someone else. If you go back to her....you may find yourself in the same situation later down the road. Save yourself the headache/heartache and move on.
 
first off I have deleted her completely from my life.. ie myspace, cell phone, email. etc.. NC!
2nd: I joined flight school which is very exciting, and I look forward to it everyday. And it definetly keeps my mind focused.
3rd: I started a saltwater fishtank which requires alot of my attention.

I have a cat and dog. I live alone in a big house with them. It gets a bit lonely at nights. I took up a new habit called drinking. It helps at nights. I also started on Anti-depressants (welbutrin). seems to be working so far... Along with the valiums... I'm a big ole mess. But I am determined to get better!

I'll approach this in two ways.

First, I'll answer it from someone who's been where you are. I posted this in a similar thread from another member:

I'm sorry for your loss. Getting over a relationship is not easy especially when you thought everything was going well and the other person blindsides you. I know you are reeling right now and all the "don't worry and just move on" won't help at this point in the grieving process.

The best thing I can tell you is don't break crazy. This happened to me in college with a girl that I was ready to marry. I lost it and unfortunately broke crazy. You know what I'm talking about the whole "why, why, why" thing. I called her, talked friends ears off about it, tried to get information on who and what she was doing, etc. etc. etc.. No matter how bad you want to do these things and no matter how bad you want to understand; just stop, make it a clean break, and put yourself on lockdown. The only thing worse than getting dumped is turning into "that guy" who can't get over it.

I'll try to make you smile/laugh by telling you one of the things that happened to me. A few weeks after she ended it I called a female friend who lived in the dorms because I was feeling down and wanted to talk to someone about it. Her answering machine picked up and I left this horrible, sappy, woe is me message about how I was devastated and what did I do wrong etc. etc. .... Well, a couple of hours later the friend calls me back and the first thing she says is "I'm so sorry about what just happened."

She proceeds to explain that she does not use the school's provided private voice mail system, but a personal answering machine that she brought from home. You know the kind that uses tapes and has a speaker so that your message plays out loud for anyone and everyone to hear. Yeah... well "when you called I obviously wasn't here, but your ex was visiting my roommate and they overheard your entire message as you left it".

Call it what you want, epic fail, living in loserville, or simply being a moron. The point is don't do what I did, work through your grief privately as best you can and maintain your self respect in the process.

Second, I'll answer from a professional perspective since I happen to be a LPC. Your situation doesn't sound too good, but I like your optimism and your desire to get better. Don't rely on alcohol to get you over this and for goodness sake please don't mix alcohol with your medication. Wellbutrin and Valium are serious, don't risk your health. Additionally, it kind of sounds like you might have addictive or obsessive personality traits and you don't need to move from one negative to another in your life. Focus on your new hobbies and keep yourself busy. As I wrote to the other poster above, grieving takes time, but if you take an active approach to the process then you will thank yourself later.

So, to review.

Alcohol and becoming the guy with too many pets = bad plan for getting over a break up. :(

Flight school and the possibility of joining the "mile high club" = good plan for getting over a break up. :)
 
Well you've hit the denial phase already. It's only natural that you would want to get back with her, but avoid any contact. You'll get over he eventually.
 
dont do remorse, pack up and move on with your life, try to learn where ya went wrong and next time use what you've learnt ;)
 
holy crap 5 girls later????

My advice:

Turn off your laptop she'll realize your stealing her WiFi, quietly exit the shrubbery you are hiding behind and go home before the cops catch you.
 
You broke up with her for a reason. Don't forget that.

I'm willing to hedge my bets that you don't really want her back, you just want "a girlfriend." Find someone who is better suited for you and she'll slip off the radar screen.
 
the internet isn't exactly the best place to get personal love advice, that said, just follow the unwritten rules of a break-up.

Rule #1 is Never Ever go back with an ex,

like the dude above me said, you guys broke up for a reason. Sounds like you have that feeling people have right after they make a big purchase and then walk out the store and regret it, buyers remorse. Its normal but trust you made the write decision.

Hopefully the replies will instill confidence in that you made the right call.

Certainly a +1 on that from me, after me and my last girlfriend broke up 3 times in less than 3 months!

Thing is, you always miss the person right after something like that happens because they where a big part of your life.

You have to forget about her though. Cut her off like a Scientologist (LOL) and certainly stop looking at her MySpace page.

From your description, it should be easy. I got over my last girlfriend in about a week, despite the fact I felt very upset after the break ups... Learnt a very important lesson though... Well, two, but the other isn't relevant to this thread.

Good luck, and life goes on!
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.