Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Mine shows December online, or 18 months after I bought the 3G.
I believe that when AT&T calculates upgrade eligibility, they do take into consideration how long you've been a customer. I think that for those of us who switched to AT&T in order to buy the first iPhone in 2007 and then bought a 3g in June 2008, that 2-year history with the company is what is causing them to make us upgrade-eligible 18 months into our current contract. Some people with a 3G are posting that they are upgrade eligible in July -- I would guess that those people have a longer history with AT&T.

It's generally cheaper to keep a current customer than to sign up a new one, so the mobile companies generally do reward long-term customers with treatment that is designed to cause them to stick around.
 
I just sent a email to Apple about AT&T's upgrade policy. They are punishing the loyal customers who would buy iPhone every year. Maybe if enough people complain, they will change it.

http://www.apple.com/feedback/iphone.html
They can't change it.

AT&T is giving you the phone cheaper because of the 2 year contract.

If you keep upgrading early, AT&T loses money.

So there is not a thing Apple can do about it.
 
Great point, I believe I had my iPhone 3G replaced in March because of a defect. I'm checking my Bro's who also has got a 3G on launch day and hasn't had it replaced to see what his upgrade says.

I think that's it..

This is what my Bro's says for upgrade:
As a valued AT&T customer, you may be eligible for an upgrade on this line, with reduced equipment pricing when signing a 2-year contract. Click ‘Upgrade Today’ to view your upgrade options.

Here we go, I'll be making a rage-inducing phone call to the idiots at at&t... I'll report back on results later.
 
I believe that when AT&T calculates upgrade eligibility, they do take into consideration how long you've been a customer. I think that for those of us who switched to AT&T in order to buy the first iPhone in 2007 and then bought a 3g in June 2008, that 2-year history with the company is what is causing them to make us upgrade-eligible 18 months into our current contract. Some people with a 3G are posting that they are upgrade eligible in July -- I would guess that those people have a longer history with AT&T.

It's generally cheaper to keep a current customer than to sign up a new one, so the mobile companies generally do reward long-term customers with treatment that is designed to cause them to stick around.
Yet, me, who has been an AT&T customer since I bought my StarTAC gosh knows how many years ago, has a bill over 240 a month, can not get anything but the $599 and $699 prices???

What a crock!!
 
I believe that when AT&T calculates upgrade eligibility, they do take into consideration how long you've been a customer. I think that for those of us who switched to AT&T in order to buy the first iPhone in 2007 and then bought a 3g in June 2008, that 2-year history with the company is what is causing them to make us upgrade-eligible 18 months into our current contract. Some people with a 3G are posting that they are upgrade eligible in July -- I would guess that those people have a longer history with AT&T.

It's generally cheaper to keep a current customer than to sign up a new one, so the mobile companies generally do reward long-term customers with treatment that is designed to cause them to stick around.


Thats not true I bought the first gen phone and the 3g and I'm not eligible till April next year. Not like I care but I don't think logevity has anything to do with it.
 
I think if you've had your 3G replaced, it screws you out of getting the 199/299 upgrade price.
I bought this iPhone 3G on launch day, 4th in line and 4th to get one at the store I was at.

Never been replaced.

It keeps quoting me the very high prices. ($599 and $699.)

Something else is going on.
 
(Caveat: Apple/AT&T noob)

What's my best course of action to get 3GS ???

I bought a ($99) 8GB 3G on June 11th; signed my first ever AT&T contract. I have 2 days left in my 30-day return policy.
 
Here we go, I'll be making a rage-inducing phone call to the idiots at at&t... I'll report back on results later.

Please let me know how it goes, because I had my 3G replaced in March because of a defect, and my upgrade status says, I qualify at a discounted higher rate and I can qualify for standard pricing in March of '10.. which is a year after I got the replacement unit.
 
"iPhone 3g users stiffed" = iPhone 3g users held to contract they signed when given a $500 phone for an up front cost of $200.

Yeah, but who can blame 'em? We live in a society where athletes hold out 2 seasons into a 5 season contract because they don't feel they're getting paid what they're worth. Not saying I agree with it, just pointing it out.

FWIW, I personally don't think the new 3GS is worth the upgrade over my current 16GB 3G. The good news is that my wife can now upgrade her first gen iPhone to a 3G for $99. Maybe next year if Apple really steps up I'll consider a new phone, but for now, with the 3G and 3.0 OS, I'm more than content to spend my money on more important things. :)
 
It may be correct regarding the replacement. I got my 16GB 3G on launch day and then got a replacement about two weeks later. This is what the Apple site says for my info:

Review iPhone pricing.

We can offer you an iPhone at the full retail price. On 01/08/2010, you may qualify for a standard iPhone upgrade.

* $499.00* — 8GB iPhone 3G (black)
* $599.00* — 16GB iPhone 3G S (black or white)
* $699.00* — 32GB iPhone 3G S (black or white)

I have a 450 min plan with 200 text messages if it could be related to that. Apparently if your iPhone had problems and needed to be replaced you aren't such a "valued" customer to AT&T. Oh well, I still wouldn't upgrade for $500. I would for the standard upgrade price.
 
I bought this iPhone 3G on launch day, 4th in line and 4th to get one at the store I was at.

Never been replaced.

It keeps quoting me the very high prices. ($599 and $699.)

Something else is going on.

It sounds like they just took darts and threw them at an upgrade list.
 
(Caveat: Apple/AT&T noob)

What's my best course of action to get 3GS ???

I bought a ($99) 8GB 3G on June 11th; signed my first ever AT&T contract. I have 2 days left in my 30-day return policy.

Return it...Now; today ASAP and then wait and get the 3gs in 2 weeks.
 
The reality is that AT&T, like all the US carriers, make you sign a two year contract. Their assumption has been for ages that a person would have their phone for two years before getting a new one.

The iPhone changes a lot. Apple, and other phone makers, are upgrading their phones far more regularly -- it is a more competitive business because of the iPhone.

As a result, if you bought a phone with the past year you are probably screwed. AT&T probably could not imagine you'd want to upgrade again so quickly. They are, to say the least, Neanderthals. (And business people to say the least.)

I still have a first gen iPhone and will obviously qualify. But I would be shocked if AT&T doesn't create a promotion to lure 3G iPhone users to upgrade. Let's face it: business sucks, they will have to do something to spur sales.

As for the 3GS, I will upgrade some day. I am only disappointed that the new model is still going to feel cheaper than my first gen iPhone. It was a big mistake replace the metal back with plastic. My first gen iPhone still feels like a superior product. The 3G and now the 3GS will feel cheap in comparison.
 
What I don't understand is that friend of mine and I bought 3G on the same day. Back in August 08 he was qualified and I wasn't for 3G. I just checked Apple's website and he's already qualified as of today and I'm not till 7/23/09 :confused:



As a valued AT&T customer, AT&T can offer you an early iPhone upgrade with a new 2-yr commitment and an $18 upgrade fee. You may qualify for a standard iPhone upgrade on 07/23/2009.

* $299.00* — 8GB iPhone 3G (black)
* $399.00* — 16GB iPhone 3G S (black or white)
* $499.00* — 32GB iPhone 3G S (black or white)
 
It may be correct regarding the replacement. I got my 16GB 3G on launch day and then got a replacement about two weeks later. This is what the Apple site says for my info:

Review iPhone pricing.

We can offer you an iPhone at the full retail price. On 01/08/2010, you may qualify for a standard iPhone upgrade.

* $499.00* — 8GB iPhone 3G (black)
* $599.00* — 16GB iPhone 3G S (black or white)
* $699.00* — 32GB iPhone 3G S (black or white)

I have a 450 min plan with 200 text messages if it could be related to that. Apparently if your iPhone had problems and needed to be replaced you aren't such a "valued" customer to AT&T. Oh well, I still wouldn't upgrade for $500. I would for the standard upgrade price.

Yeah, it's really looking like if you had your 3G replaced for whatever reason, it tacks on a year from when you got the replacement thus making you ineligible for the standard pricing.

I just had another friend check who DIDN'T/HASN'T had his iPhone replaced and his says' As a valued AT&T customer, you may be eligible for an upgrade on this line, with reduced equipment pricing when signing a 2-year contract. Click ‘Upgrade Today’ to view your upgrade options.
 
It may be correct regarding the replacement. I got my 16GB 3G on launch day and then got a replacement about two weeks later. This is what the Apple site says for my info:

Review iPhone pricing.

We can offer you an iPhone at the full retail price. On 01/08/2010, you may qualify for a standard iPhone upgrade.

* $499.00* — 8GB iPhone 3G (black)
* $599.00* — 16GB iPhone 3G S (black or white)
* $699.00* — 32GB iPhone 3G S (black or white)

I have a 450 min plan with 200 text messages if it could be related to that. Apparently if your iPhone had problems and needed to be replaced you aren't such a "valued" customer to AT&T. Oh well, I still wouldn't upgrade for $500. I would for the standard upgrade price.
I am getting the same thing and I got my on launch and it has never been replaced.
 
It may be correct regarding the replacement. I got my 16GB 3G on launch day and then got a replacement about two weeks later. This is what the Apple site says for my info:

Review iPhone pricing.

We can offer you an iPhone at the full retail price. On 01/08/2010, you may qualify for a standard iPhone upgrade.

* $499.00* — 8GB iPhone 3G (black)
* $599.00* — 16GB iPhone 3G S (black or white)
* $699.00* — 32GB iPhone 3G S (black or white)

I have a 450 min plan with 200 text messages if it could be related to that. Apparently if your iPhone had problems and needed to be replaced you aren't such a "valued" customer to AT&T. Oh well, I still wouldn't upgrade for $500. I would for the standard upgrade price.

I actually like how they say I "may" qualify for a standard upgrade in January. It is like a cliffhanger to keep me on the edge of my seat for the next 7 months.....ok, not really.
 
Thats not true I bought the first gen phone and the 3g and I'm not eligible till April next year. Not like I care but I don't think logevity has anything to do with it.

Wrong, you signed a two year contract, one year later does not mean you can upgrade. There are exceptions to that rule:

Some business accounts
Monthly total in excess of $140 per month, multi-line account in good standing and have been a valued customer for more than two years.

I bought this iPhone 3G on launch day, 4th in line and 4th to get one at the store I was at.

Never been replaced.

It keeps quoting me the very high prices. ($599 and $699.)

Something else is going on.

No, you just are not eligible, period! We've been telling you people this for the last 5 months and you wouldn't believe us. Now you still don't want to believe us even though the "writing is on the wall."

It may be correct regarding the replacement. I got my 16GB 3G on launch day and then got a replacement about two weeks later. This is what the Apple site says for my info:

Review iPhone pricing.

We can offer you an iPhone at the full retail price. On 01/08/2010, you may qualify for a standard iPhone upgrade.

* $499.00* — 8GB iPhone 3G (black)
* $599.00* — 16GB iPhone 3G S (black or white)
* $699.00* — 32GB iPhone 3G S (black or white)

I have a 450 min plan with 200 text messages if it could be related to that. Apparently if your iPhone had problems and needed to be replaced you aren't such a "valued" customer to AT&T. Oh well, I still wouldn't upgrade for $500. I would for the standard upgrade price.

Having your iPhone replaced has nothing to do with it.
 
Yeah, it's really looking like if you had your 3G replaced for whatever reason, it tacks on a year from when you got the replacement thus making you ineligible for the standard pricing.

I just had another friend check who DIDN'T/HASN'T had his iPhone replaced and his says' As a valued AT&T customer, you may be eligible for an upgrade on this line, with reduced equipment pricing when signing a 2-year contract. Click ‘Upgrade Today’ to view your upgrade options.

I've had mine replaced under warranty several times and get the "reduced" prices of 399/499

The "reduced" pricing is a combination of how long you've been an AT&T customer, when you last upgrade was, what plan you have, how many features you, if you've ever made a late paymet have etc etc

Even a AT&T rep can't tell you how they calculate the date.
 
How are you guys getting to the upgrade screen where you're seeing the screen (as current 3G owners) where it is showing $399- 16GB and $499 32GB?

I can't find it via logging into my AT&T account.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.