I got a matte black feather for my iPhone 4 a couple of days ago, and so far, i'm delighted with it. It has more of a 'rounded square' cut out around the camera/flash rather than the more tear shape that ive seen in pics posted here. Hoping the rubber coating lasts better than indicated here. Hopefully early issues were a result of issues with initial production runs. But at this stage, 10/10. 