Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
I doubt it.

Widgets have been a function of android since forever. iOS has never had widgets.

It hasn't stopped the iphone from being the single most successful smartphone of all time.

Among android people, there is some disproportionate significance put on widgets. But as a person who had them, and still went iOS, it's far from a deal maker or deal breaker.

I don't spend a lot of time looking at home screens is why, and I am not a fan of crashed widgets and forced restarts...

Crashed widgets? Forced Restarts? All that from widgets?! What kind of phone were you using? I can't speak for the cheap Android phones, but on a high-end Android phone I have never once seen a widget cause the phone to crash or even a widget crashing. What widget was this and on what phone?
 
Honest question, what advantage does NFC payments give you vs a credit card. I can't see myself leaving the house without my credit card, what happens if there's an emergency and I need to pay for something via phone...meaning reading my credit card number over the phone? What if my battery dies and I'm stranded without access to my money? What if my phone breaks while I'm out? What if I lose my phone or it's stolen, can someone easily copy my NFC data or break into my "wallet"...etc.

I can see so many negatives, but no benefits to paying for my Starbucks coffee with my phone.

Can someone enlighten me?

NFC has added security (at least vs. contactless debit/credit cards) as phones are password protected.

How many times does such an emergency happen? I haven't paid for anything over the phone in years, it's all online nowadays. Plus, is there a reason why you can't just read it off your phone? You can minimise the phone app whilst in a call :p

Do you think the same things when using your phone as a sat nav, camera etc? There's lots of what ifs, but my phone never does die when I'm out and it hasn't been stolen yet either. For peace of mind though there's nothing wrong with carrying a card as a backup. NFC is a convenience thing. It will be a long time until you can leave without your card anyway because NFC isn't that widely supported yet.
 
I doubt it.

Widgets have been a function of android since forever. iOS has never had widgets.

It hasn't stopped the iphone from being the single most successful smartphone of all time.

Among android people, there is some disproportionate significance put on widgets. But as a person who had them, and still went iOS, it's far from a deal maker or deal breaker.

I don't spend a lot of time looking at home screens is why, and I am not a fan of crashed widgets and forced restarts...

Nah there'd be lots of cries of "widgets done right" etc, I'm almost sure of it.

On this site back in the day, people used to say that we didn't need multitasking, it's only a phone etc etc. and now look...nobody says how unnecessary multitasking is.
 
I recently got an iPhone after spending several years with several different Android phones (most recently the Razr). I doubt I'll ever go back to Android at this point. iOS is just a better OS IMO. I have yet to have a crash or have to reboot, even after jailbreaking. Rebooting was a daily event with my Android phones.
 
Nah there'd be lots of cries of "widgets done right" etc, I'm almost sure of it.

On this site back in the day, people used to say that we didn't need multitasking, it's only a phone etc etc. and now look...nobody says how unnecessary multitasking is.

Possible depending on Apple's execution. But from where I am sitting I wasn't a huge fan on widgets on android and I have no reason to believe I would like them on iOS either. I'm not tripping all over myself to jailbreak and install widgets so clearly the value is not there for me.

Personally I think Windows Phone does a far better job of providing information at a glance than any android widget.

As for me, I'm fine with that content being neatly tucked away in notification center, and keeping iOS clean and stable.
 
Possible depending on Apple's execution. But from where I am sitting I wasn't a huge fan on widgets on android and I have no reason to believe I would like them on iOS either. I'm not tripping all over myself to jailbreak and install widgets so clearly the value is not there for me.

Personally I think Windows Phone does a far better job of providing information at a glance than any android widget.

As for me, I'm fine with that content being neatly tucked away in notification center, and keeping iOS clean and stable.

It's all down to preference, but I like having widgets with more features. The S Planner widget for the S3 can show my calendar for any given day in the widget itself. If I click the "+" button it opens up the add event button in the actual app.
 
Don't throw down iOS quite yet, because the next iPhone is probably going to be pretty sexy.

I've jumped because I'm quite confident the next iPhone is going to be very similar to every iPhone that has come before it.
 
I've jumped because I'm quite confident the next iPhone is going to be very similar to every iPhone that has come before it.

No, you don't say. And that's been a terrible thing, right? iPhone 5 will break all previous sales records and be the top selling device just as the previous iterations have been. So I'm guessing it's a pretty good formula for success.
 
I recently got an iPhone after spending several years with several different Android phones (most recently the Razr). I doubt I'll ever go back to Android at this point. iOS is just a better OS IMO. I have yet to have a crash or have to reboot, even after jailbreaking. Rebooting was a daily event with my Android phones.

Let me guess, you had one of those 99 cent Android phones right? iOS apps crash more than Android apps
 
He said the razr :p

Gotta say neither OS is bad for crashing for me!

I just had the Razr Maxx for 6 months, not one single reboot or restart. User error for sure. Someone clueless like that should stick with an iPhone.
 
I have been a member here on MacRumors since 2007 and I can't remember a time that I've seen as many posts and discussions regarding the possibility of straying from the iPhone. Just look at the threads up now. A lot of talk about iPhone vs. the Galaxy. iOS vs. Android (and Windows). Talk about the Nexus and other smartphone options.

I have to admit, I'm starting to think about jumping ship too (I'm test driving a Lumia 900 now. I like it but still lean slightly towards my iPhone 4...but I digress). The Galaxy S3 look mighty sexy. I'm still waiting to see what the iPhone "5" shapes up to be but, if it's essentially a longer (4 inch) iphone with LTE, I'm gonna have to give some serious thought to alternatives...something I would have NEVER done even a year ago. I've had every iteration of the iPhone and used nothing but an iPhone for the last 5 years.

I'm a major Apple fanboy (friends and family actually tease me about my Apple obsession) so it's tough to admit that the iPhone might be falling behind a bit. That is my personal impression of course.

I do realize that my observations are purely anecdotal but, it just seems that I'm not the only Apple nut feeling this way lately.

Damn, the S3 IS pretty sexy. I'm rooting for an awesome new iPhone in a few months though. I hope. :)
Yeah, I'm with you there. I'm out, my 3GS has been great for me- it has been really dependable and was awesome for the time, but I tried a Galaxy S3 in person the other day and they just feel light years ahead of iPhones.

Coupled with the awful experience my girlfriend and I had at the Genius bar two weeks ago and I think I'm done with iOS products. The 'Genius' spoke down to my girlfriend the entire time, refused to acknowledge the problem my girlfriend was having with her Mac and mocked her when my gf said she'd also had to have her iPhone replaced recently (for continually echoing during phone calls), asking if the phone and the computer were having the same problem, when it was an issue that clearly doesn't affect phones. Speaking to her manager yielded better results, but it was still an awful experience. It really upset my girlfriend, she sold her Mac and is now refusing to buy another Apple product ever again.

Come contract renewal time, I'll be getting an S3 (or possibly a Windows Phone 8 handset- depends what they're like). Unless, of course, the new iPhone is a absolutely amazing, which I doubt it will be after seeing IOS6. Plus I really don't want the downgraded Maps, which will no doubt be terrible in Australia for a long, long time, as Apple focuses heavily on the US.

While it's true that we on here don't represent the majority of consumers, I'm sure a lot of us are the ones who recommend phones to friends and family. I know my parents, brother and some of my friends will get what I recommend.
 
Anyone else notice the list of things that make the iPhone "better" are getting awfully short and irrelevant?

The only uncontested one left that I still consistently see is that iPhone sales surpass that of individual Android devices, therefore it's better.

It's cool if you prefer iOS/iPhone, but it seems to me rising to its defense is becoming increasingly difficult.
 
I just had the Razr Maxx for 6 months, not one single reboot or restart. User error for sure. Someone clueless like that should stick with an iPhone.

My Galaxy S2 suffered random reboots when I got it. I updated the firmware which fixed it, but that wasn't user error on my part.

You can't say that unless you know the circumstances.
 
Anyone else notice the list of things that make the iPhone "better" are getting awfully short and irrelevant?

The only uncontested one left that I still consistently see is that iPhone sales surpass that of individual Android devices, therefore it's better.

It's cool if you prefer iOS/iPhone, but it seems to me rising to its defense is becoming increasingly difficult.

Developer support.
 
Anyone else notice the list of things that make the iPhone "better" are getting awfully short and irrelevant?

The only uncontested one left that I still consistently see is that iPhone sales surpass that of individual Android devices, therefore it's better.

It's cool if you prefer iOS/iPhone, but it seems to me rising to its defense is becoming increasingly difficult.

Developer support
App selection
Games selection
Timely OS updates
Ecosystem
Apps, hardware and software are all optimized to work together
High resell value to fund future phone purchases
 
Crashed widgets? Forced Restarts? All that from widgets?! What kind of phone were you using? I can't speak for the cheap Android phones, but on a high-end Android phone I have never once seen a widget cause the phone to crash or even a widget crashing. What widget was this and on what phone?

Me either. Dont pay any attention to Technarky. He has nothing possitive to say about Android . Apparently he didnt know how to use them. Went thru 8 phones in 3 years. Im on my second in two years.

Originally Posted by Technarchy
I doubt it.

Widgets have been a function of android since forever. iOS has never had widgets.

Exactly, and many here have said they would like to have widgets. Guaranteed this place would go nuts and say what a great thing it is that Apple did.
 
Apps, thats all they have left...

Even if that were true, that's enough. Are we really at the point where people are making fun of an operating system, saying, "Haha, the only thing your operating system has is APPLICATIONS!"

I think you have lost sight over what operating systems are designed to do.
 
I've jumped because I'm quite confident the next iPhone is going to be very similar to every iPhone that has come before it.

Yeah, who cares if the next iPhone is an amazing, revolutionary device. If it looks the same it's obviously garbage! /sarcasm
 
Even if that were true, that's enough. Are we really at the point where people are making fun of an operating system, saying, "Haha, the only thing your operating system has is APPLICATIONS!"

I think you have lost sight over what operating systems are designed to do.

I mean the variety of apps. Some people get all caught up on the sheer number of them. However, most of them are complete useless crap like games. I am looking at the top paid and free apps in the app store right now on my iPad and there is not ONE important app in there I can't get on my Galaxy S3, not one. I think I can live without Snow cone maker and Wheres my Perry :rolleyes:
 
I just had the Razr Maxx for 6 months, not one single reboot or restart. User error for sure. Someone clueless like that should stick with an iPhone.

Got the Eris when it first came out. It was a POS. Then the Incredible. It was the best of the three I had. I ended with the Razr. I absolutely hated it. Too big, terrible battery and Blur.

You can claim user, but that sounds can fanboyish to me. I never rooted so I have no idea how anyone with three years of Android experience could screw up a non-rooted phone.
 
No, you don't say. And that's been a terrible thing, right? iPhone 5 will break all previous sales records and be the top selling device just as the previous iterations have been. So I'm guessing it's a pretty good formula for success.

It was the original formula that got the iphone to were it is. It is the consumer following that has kept it selling like hotcakes. That has less to so with design amd more to do with loyalty, as long as each iphone adds a significant feature it will outsell the previous one. However, it appears to me people are expecting a completely new design. They are tired of the same old one. All those iphone 5 mock ups is proof of that.

----------

Exactly, and many here have said they would like to have widgets. Guaranteed this place would go nuts and say what a great thing it is that Apple did.

I have widgets and have found them to waste power and eat up screen space. I can't imagine the short battery life people on an Android phone would have if they had a bunch of these widgets running at once?

Widgets can be useful for seeing data at a glance, but at what price?
 
Developer support
App selection - Unecessary
Games selection - Unecessary
Timely OS updates - Unecessary
Ecosystem - Unecessary
Apps, hardware and software are all optimized to work together - Unecessary
High resell value to fund future phone purchases - Necessary when people realize they need to sell off their poop iPhone
:rolleyes:
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.