Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
iOS 14 Picture in Picture No Longer Working With YouTube's Mobile Website in Safari [Without Premium]
- Thread starter MacRumors
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
Apple needs to end this crap and just make it work when using the Safari video player.
Just like Apple needs to end the same crap on Apple TV.
Just like Apple needs to end the same crap on Apple TV.
I assume that it isn't about it being difficult, it's about ads. If you play a video in picture-in-picture on iOS, you can swipe the video away and listen to it. That kills ad viewability.
YouTube, always going the extra mile to make their service suck as much as possible. Good job!
It doesn’t even work with YouTube premium on iOS 14.
They give it away for free on android.
I’m surprised they didn’t do this sooner... now mine immediately pops back into the viewer the instant I tap the PiP icon. I was so happy during the beta series with this feature. I even got used to using the desktop site in Safari. That’s stupid that Apple allows them to detect if the video is playing in PiP and disable it, if that’s the case here. YouTube is now blocking a native feature of the device in the browser. That’s ridiculous. They might be able to get away with that in the app, and skirt the specific App Store guideline about blocking native features behind a paywall, since they likely don’t use Apple’s player, but in the browser? That’s stupid. I really hope this is a bug. YouTube’s app has gotten crazy with the length and frequency of ads and the insanely annoying prompts for a free trial of YouTube Premium when I no longer qualify for it. It has also been incredibly buggy. That’s part of the reason it was easier for me to switch to the browser. 90% of the time, my main feed would only load like 6 videos and then it wouldn’t load anymore as I continued scrolling.
Edit: looks like it still works on the iPad, but not on the iPhone. Maybe it is a bug...
Edit: looks like it still works on the iPad, but not on the iPhone. Maybe it is a bug...
Last edited:
I use background audio on YT a lot for some of the more data heavy content. GamersNexus and TechnologyConnections have amazing content, but there are often long periods where I am just looking at their faces.
Now the iPad is where it has actual value as I can actually do some work reading or writing something and pull up a video for reference.
That’s assuming this whole thing wasn’t enabled on their end to begin with. Seems stupid to me to let the site know that you are viewing in PiP, so hopefully it is a hack that Google used that Apple will fix but I doubt it.
Knew they’d block PiP for us peasants who aren’t Premium subscribers. The workaround will most likely be patched soon now that they’re aware of it.
Google, charging people for an iOS feature. Stay classy.
If its added as an app on android mobile then no reason why it can't happen on iOS.
Oh nm... its all apple...that vp9 stuff...something businesses have to figure it out....normal people won't.
Could be apple blocking it, they want you to have 2 hardware devices to multitask
Google disabled it. It was working yesterday. They also disabled 8K playback on portable Macs.
As others have pointed out, PiP “just works” on the iPad but it doesn’t on the iPhone unless you request the desktop website first, then it works. Auto-playing the next video has also been broken. 😕 Seems too much of a coincidence for these features to suddenly stop working right after iOS 14 launched, so I’m sure Google have done something to deliberately knobble it and were just waiting for iOS 14 to go live.
Google’s YouTube app has always been awful, right down to using their own custom player which puts controls in different places to the standard iOS video player that virtually all apps use. There’s no on-screen volume controls either, terrible UX seems to not bother Google.
Google’s YouTube app has always been awful, right down to using their own custom player which puts controls in different places to the standard iOS video player that virtually all apps use. There’s no on-screen volume controls either, terrible UX seems to not bother Google.
Screw you Google. Punish your customers over a format war that doesn’t matter at all. Idiots...
Google has been leveraging YouTube against other platforms for a long time. Remember when Google refused to build an app for Windows Phone in the early 2010s and sent Microsoft a cease and desist letter asking it to remove the YouTube app they had to build for themselves?
YouTube PIP while using Safari is still working for me on my iPhone 11 Pro w/ iOS 14. What am I doing differently?????
They should add it to the app but we all know how useless YouTube is with that