Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
This thread:
> Loathes skeuomorphism
> Loves Shelf

What a god-awful concept. Widgets are a joke. Apple, avert your eyes. If iOS 7 turns out anything like this, we'll know Apple has no good ideas post-Jobs.
 
I would really like to see the glass icons to be done with. The shine or glare that they use on the stock apps looks bad. Maybe Jony Ive thinks the same and will just take the glare off of them.
 
The widget implementation is flawed... the idea behind widgets is you don't have to interact with the app to get an update.

Here you're still having to tap the icon, so why limit the functionality of the single tap when it could load the entire app in the same amount of time?

Also, would you really want to be able to reply to messages or change settings from the lock screen? Emphasis on the lock...

The thing is sometimes you dont need to use full functionality of an app. You just need to use a portion of it. It is very useful. You may not like widgets but a lot of people find great use in them.

I have an android phone. I'm not too big on them. I only use the weather and google widget. But some of my friends have loads of widgets.
 
This thread:
> Loathes skeuomorphism
> Loves Shelf

What a god-awful concept. Widgets are a joke. Apple, avert your eyes. If iOS 7 turns out anything like this, we'll know Apple has no good ideas post-Jobs.

Yes because all their ideas for iOS when Jobs was in charge were good. :rolleyes:
 
so when I click the weather icon I see the that it's 73 degrees when I could had saw the same thing from the icon? I would rather see the 10 day forecast and more info. The way these widgets made are horrible.
 
Quick Settings with Auxo are way more elegant IMHO


auxo-cydia-iphone_thumb.jpg
 
Last edited:
If even half of those concepts come to fruition, iOS7 will be a major upgrade.

Android does all of that and in much better ways. LAME!!

----------

Some of the ideas are good but the widgets concept is about as dumb as it is on Android. Why not just open the app and get the full deal rather than the limited info that comes with widgets? The apps on iOS open blazing fast. It's not like opening Photoshop or something on a slow spinning hard disk.

Heck, I never use widgets even on my old slow Mac. And Apple has had widgets on Mac since forever it seems. I'm pretty sure they know full well whether people on average find them useful or not. My guess is not really.

What planet are you on. Android Widgets are much better than this. This is sort of like Samsung's Mini app idea on Android, which I don't like either. Very lame. Sorry but iOS is lame, old and retarded compared to Android and WinPhone8. This is yet another example of trying to tack on more modern features onto something never designed for it in the first place. OS is more like a Palm Pilot than anything else. Android at least took it a couple steps forward, but is still app-centric. I prefer WinPhone for being more people-centric.

----------

The widget implementation is flawed... the idea behind widgets is you don't have to interact with the app to get an update.

Here you're still having to tap the icon, so why limit the functionality of the single tap when it could load the entire app in the same amount of time?

Also, would you really want to be able to reply to messages or change settings from the lock screen? Emphasis on the lock...

Agreed. It's stupid and it's not at all how widgets work on Android as someone said here. This is lame.

----------

WTF! Wow, shows how blind and easily pleased people can be if they see this as a giant leap forward for IOS. If something like this is the best Apple can come up with then please people, do what I did and sell your iPhone and try a windows Nokia instead! Best move I ever made!

Right on!!!
 
Apple isn't going to take iOS features from a youtube video. The person who made it is then going to want payment for it.
 
Android does all of that and in much better ways. LAME!!

----------



What planet are you on. Android Widgets are much better than this. This is sort of like Samsung's Mini app idea on Android, which I don't like either. Very lame. Sorry but iOS is lame, old and retarded compared to Android and WinPhone8. This is yet another example of trying to tack on more modern features onto something never designed for it in the first place. OS is more like a Palm Pilot than anything else. Android at least took it a couple steps forward, but is still app-centric. I prefer WinPhone for being more people-centric.

----------



Agreed. It's stupid and it's not at all how widgets work on Android as someone said here. This is lame.

----------



Right on!!!


Android Android Android Android Android Android Android Android OK we get it you love your Android. Most ppl in this thread don't care how it's done on android. I been there and done that and will not be going back to android.
 
Apple isn't going to take iOS features from a youtube video. The person who made it is then going to want payment for it.

Depends on if he trademarked or copyrighted any of the ideas contained within. And even if he did, he'd have to prove that...

A. They're unique enough Apple couldn't have come up with them on their own, and...

B. That the video was posted long before Apple started implementing any of the ideas.

Plus...

C. Since everything within either plays off or expands upon features both Apple and Google both use elsewhere, there's not much he himself could do about it. Mission Control? Widgets buried inside the folder view? OS controls accessible from the notification center? We've seen those in other places.

...though he could get them on the implementation, but then you'd have to consider A. again.
 
My understanding is that this is not Apple's list but regardless I saw some things I liked and those that I didn't like.

I like the reply to text feature early in the video and I like the ease of activating airplane mode as well as the update style for the app store.

However, I don't really care for widget mode (hopefully that will be disable-able (making that a word). I also don't really get the point of shelf when you already seem to have left newsstand intact. They seem to be redundant and I know most people already dislike newsstand.

Personally, I like newsstand because I get my daily newspapers from there but I know very people who like that and I think this is just going to irritate them further.
 
Depends on if he trademarked or copyrighted any of the ideas contained within. And even if he did, he'd have to prove that...

A. They're unique enough Apple couldn't have come up with them on their own, and...

B. That the video was posted long before Apple started implementing any of the ideas.

Plus...

C. Since everything within either plays off or expands upon features both Apple and Google both use elsewhere, there's not much he himself could do about it. Mission Control? Widgets buried inside the folder view? OS controls accessible from the notification center? We've seen those in other places.

...though he could get them on the implementation, but then you'd have to consider A. again.

Trademark doesn't apply at all. And for copyright to apply, Apple would have to directly copy actual code (which doesn't exist). So no. He could do nothing if Apple simply took everything from the video. They won't though.
 
I'd venture to guess that it's because unlike Flight Mode, Bluetooth has additional options like pairing and selecting devices, etc. Its not as simple as on/off. While they could have a menu option for on/off and then the other options in a submenu below it, this is Apple. They want to keep things as clean as possible and having Bluetooth take up 2 spaces in the Settings wouldn't work with that.

Pretty simple solution to that issue.
Screenshot_2013-04-06-15-47-26.png
 
Last edited:
Wow. If ios7 ends up being like that, Apple is in trouble. Far from being a game changer. Luckily they dont have that guy working for them, but actually some smart people.

The smart software people that took three shots at iOS to innovate both copy and paste features?
 
Trademarks could apply to the icons, and some of the "look and feel" aspects of it.

...which are mostly based around Apple's core designs for iOS, so even then there's not much he could do.

That's trade dress, but it would have to acquire secondary meaning since it's not inherently distinctive of anything, and this random youtube user isn't exactly a brand at the moment. There are simply too many hurdles here for him to acquire any rights in the material(Besides the video as a whole. Apple can't run the video as an advertisement or anything) for the foreseeable future.

Not to mention, as you said, the design of the icons and such are pretty much just taken out of Apple. If anything, Apple is the one with the rights here.
 
I don't understand how a concept design is considered front page news on these rumor sites. Create like a separate concept blog or post it in the iOS blog, but front page news? Lol.
 
I agree with anyone who said these don't look to be a huge overhaul of iOS.
While some features would be nice, I think the general consensus is that the look and feel of iOS is becoming boring.

The iPad looks to be especially boring. I've still yet to know why for a tablet, there's so much wasted space as the icons are so small and boring. If MS could be creative and utilize the screen real estate to allow for attractive and informative tiles, I'm sure Apple can do something towards that direction.

Hoping for a nice and unexpected change from them soon.
 
i guess this guy didn't realize that double tapping an app icon wouldn't really work...
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.