The good: iOS's facial recognition is IMHO "pretty good". And with all ML models, it gets better as you identify more people, too.
The bad: When it makes a mistake, the UI makes it a massive pain to correct. In my case, there's a large volume of mistakes, and it's just absolutely impossible for me to make corrections at a high speed.
My case, specifically, I recognize is rare, but it highlights how bad this UI is. My wife is an identical triplet. As a result, iOS frequently mistags them. I have historically just ignored the "People" tab and I recently decided I want to actually get it corrected. This shouldn't be a big deal; I should be able to go in and fix the tags, right?
If you pull up a photo normally (i.e. not through the "People" album), then swipe/pull up on it, you see underneath the photo a list (in the form of thumbnails) of all people tagged in it. If it doesn't recognize the person, the thumbnail will be their face in this photo. If you tap that image, you can then tag them.
However, if the tagging is wrong, you can't correct it. If "Joe" is tagged as "Bob", and you see "Bob"'s thumbnail, and tap it, it will bring up a menu to rename Bob, not to change the tag to Joe. If you try to change "Bob" to "Joe", it will merge all of Bob and Joe's photos into the same person! It's easy to fix an unknown tag; but in fact, there's absolutely no way to fix a wrong tag from this screen.
Worse, you can't even see which tag goes to which person. In the case of my wife, a photo of my wife and her sister might be correctly tagged as my wife and her sister, but I can't see which face is which tag, so I don't actually know if they are tagged correctly (which may affect the ML model in the future).
Okay, so if we look at Apple's documentation, how do we fix this? Well, we're supposed to go to the People album. If we go to the People album, and pull up "Bob", then press "Select" (very unintuitive), we can scroll until we find the mistagged photos (this might be a lot of scrolling! And with "select" checked swipes can accidentally select photos). This is also the only place to check for mistagged faces since you can now select "Show Faces". But once you find the mistagged photos, you still can't correct the tagging. You can select the photo and click the "Share" button (unintuitive!) and then click "Not This Person".
Now, the photo is removed from the album. And now you can't find it. So now you have to go back to your main library, and manually find the now-untagged photo, and then you can tag it correctly.
This whole process becomes basically impossible when dealing with a large volume of photos. If a photo of my wife's sister is incorrectly tagged as her, I can't remove the tag from the actual photo. I have to instead go to my wife's "People" album, manually scroll through thousands of photos until I find it while the "Select" action is on (avoiding accidental selections), and then pick it and hit "Not This Person", then find the photo and re-tag it as her sister.
And I suspect there's several photos where she's double-tagged (it's hard to tell with Apple's bad UI). For example, there's a photo with myself, my wife, and my wife's sister. The photo is tagged...myself and my wife. It either doesn't detect the third face, or it's tagged my wife twice and doesn't show me that it has done so (since you can't tell what tag goes to what face). And there's absolutely NO way to untag her.
This is one of the worst UI situations I've seen from Apple. It's a complete nightmare to untag incorrect photos or tell if two people's tags are mixed up. I get that, in my situations, mistakes happen more than most people, but still, it shouldn't be THIS hard to fix mistags. You have to constantly switch between different views to get it done. If it was Facebook's tagging system I could literally just click on the face that's tagged and change the tag.
Anyone else experienced frustration with this? I typically expect better from Apple.
[automerge]1578696679[/automerge]
[automerge]1578696823[/automerge]
Side note: It's nearly impossible to search for stuff relating to identical twins and triplets and the Photos / face tagging because all the results are flooded by "Can FaceID be fooled by twins?!" articles.
The bad: When it makes a mistake, the UI makes it a massive pain to correct. In my case, there's a large volume of mistakes, and it's just absolutely impossible for me to make corrections at a high speed.
My case, specifically, I recognize is rare, but it highlights how bad this UI is. My wife is an identical triplet. As a result, iOS frequently mistags them. I have historically just ignored the "People" tab and I recently decided I want to actually get it corrected. This shouldn't be a big deal; I should be able to go in and fix the tags, right?
If you pull up a photo normally (i.e. not through the "People" album), then swipe/pull up on it, you see underneath the photo a list (in the form of thumbnails) of all people tagged in it. If it doesn't recognize the person, the thumbnail will be their face in this photo. If you tap that image, you can then tag them.
However, if the tagging is wrong, you can't correct it. If "Joe" is tagged as "Bob", and you see "Bob"'s thumbnail, and tap it, it will bring up a menu to rename Bob, not to change the tag to Joe. If you try to change "Bob" to "Joe", it will merge all of Bob and Joe's photos into the same person! It's easy to fix an unknown tag; but in fact, there's absolutely no way to fix a wrong tag from this screen.
Worse, you can't even see which tag goes to which person. In the case of my wife, a photo of my wife and her sister might be correctly tagged as my wife and her sister, but I can't see which face is which tag, so I don't actually know if they are tagged correctly (which may affect the ML model in the future).
Okay, so if we look at Apple's documentation, how do we fix this? Well, we're supposed to go to the People album. If we go to the People album, and pull up "Bob", then press "Select" (very unintuitive), we can scroll until we find the mistagged photos (this might be a lot of scrolling! And with "select" checked swipes can accidentally select photos). This is also the only place to check for mistagged faces since you can now select "Show Faces". But once you find the mistagged photos, you still can't correct the tagging. You can select the photo and click the "Share" button (unintuitive!) and then click "Not This Person".
Now, the photo is removed from the album. And now you can't find it. So now you have to go back to your main library, and manually find the now-untagged photo, and then you can tag it correctly.
This whole process becomes basically impossible when dealing with a large volume of photos. If a photo of my wife's sister is incorrectly tagged as her, I can't remove the tag from the actual photo. I have to instead go to my wife's "People" album, manually scroll through thousands of photos until I find it while the "Select" action is on (avoiding accidental selections), and then pick it and hit "Not This Person", then find the photo and re-tag it as her sister.
And I suspect there's several photos where she's double-tagged (it's hard to tell with Apple's bad UI). For example, there's a photo with myself, my wife, and my wife's sister. The photo is tagged...myself and my wife. It either doesn't detect the third face, or it's tagged my wife twice and doesn't show me that it has done so (since you can't tell what tag goes to what face). And there's absolutely NO way to untag her.
This is one of the worst UI situations I've seen from Apple. It's a complete nightmare to untag incorrect photos or tell if two people's tags are mixed up. I get that, in my situations, mistakes happen more than most people, but still, it shouldn't be THIS hard to fix mistags. You have to constantly switch between different views to get it done. If it was Facebook's tagging system I could literally just click on the face that's tagged and change the tag.
Anyone else experienced frustration with this? I typically expect better from Apple.
[automerge]1578696679[/automerge]
[automerge]1578696823[/automerge]
Side note: It's nearly impossible to search for stuff relating to identical twins and triplets and the Photos / face tagging because all the results are flooded by "Can FaceID be fooled by twins?!" articles.
Last edited:
