This makes me think of some road rager ramming someone off the road and then snatching their iPhone and running off
Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
iPhone 14's Crash Detection Mistaking Roller Coaster Rides for Car Crashes
- Thread starter MacRumors
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
That is one aspect of the crash detection that I didn't think of while watching the keynote, that is funny!
When WSJ tested it in junkyard and found that the crash detection did not work, an Apple Spokesperson said that " It wasn't connected to Bluetooth or CarPlay, which would have indicated the car was in use, and the vehicles might not have traveled enough distance prior to the crash to indicate driving. Had the iPhone received those extra indicators—and had its GPS shown the cars were on a real road—the likelihood of an alert would have been greater, he said." So, how did the rollercoaster trigger a crash warning even though the phone was not connected to airplay or satisfy the extra indicators to indicate driving? Was the Spokesperson talking fibbing when he spoke to WSJ?
While taking picsThe same who bring their iPads on roller coasters.
Or even better... Most theme parks are going cashless. People load their cards onto their phones to not have to carry a debit card/wallet (or purse) so it is right on their phone and they can't leave it in their cars. But yeah we get it, you walked up hill both ways going to school. Times changed, get over it.
If I have to turn the feature off before doing something, then I'm still a slave to my phone.
This sounds like one of the more straightforward use cases for Machine Learning - record a lot of data on roller coasters and train a model to recognize the difference. Apple could afford to send someone on every roller coaster in the world to create an essentially perfect training set.
Let's hope we all have Apple reflex boosters by the time that becomes common
The issue is that with this stuff it's so touchy. You don't want to miss a crash, but if it's too aggressive, you get lots of false positives that wastes emergency resources. Worst case you get what I was thinking and someone else posted that someone dies in a real emergency because of the false crash calls.
It just works, haha 🤣
The iPhone 14's Crash Detection feature is accidentally being triggered and therefore calling emergency services when users are riding a roller coaster rather than being involved in a real automotive accident.
As reported by The Wall Street Journal, several users of the new iPhone 14 and iPhone 14 Pro at amusement parks across the United States have reported emergency services and contacts being alerted that they've been involved in a car crash as they've ridden roller coasters. The accidental trigger of Apple's latest safety features is likely caused by the sudden breaking and movement of roller coasters, triggering the iPhone's sensors to misinterpret the movement as a car crash.
The Wall Street Journal reports at least six incidents of emergency services being called for false alarms. In response to the false alarms, an Apple spokesperson said Apple tested the feature with over a million hours of car crash data and real-world driving analysis. Several tests have already been done to test the accuracy of the iPhone 14's Crash Detection, with varying results.
In response to a test done by The Wall Street Journal in a junkyard where the iPhone failed to notice some car crashes, Apple said the testing condition did not provide the iPhone with enough factors to trigger an alert. Apple said the iPhones were not connected to Bluetooth or CarPlay and may not have traveled enough distance before impact for the device to register the crash. Crash Detection is available on the iPhone 14, iPhone 14 Pro, Apple Watch SE, Apple Watch Series 8, and Apple Watch Ultra.
Article Link: iPhone 14's Crash Detection Mistaking Roller Coaster Rides for Car Crashes
All roller coasters allow you to take a phone with you. Unless they have permission to pat you down before each ride, which they don't. They won't let you take them out to video while riding, but even that isn't enforceable once the train has left the station. (Never get to use that phase literarily)
And when someone has a heart attack while driving on a back country road? Let's put a persons life in the "Most likely" category. No point in looking both ways when crossing a street, cars are most likely driving on the correct side of the road.
That is incorrect. Irresponsible jackasses ignore the rules and tend to run away hoping to avoid the consequences of ignoring the rules. You are right the park owners are not going to engage in an invasive search to make sure riders are not violating the rules but the rider is liable if they injury a rider by violating those rules.
I'm surprised that this triggers since I would think the phone would detect movement after the "crash"
They need to AND this data with whether the user is on the road or not. It may be hard to do, but perhaps it's doable.
That is not doable since vehical crash or rollovers can take you quite a distance away from the road. The easiest solution which some poster said is to have the GPS to check if you are at an amusement park which would eliminate the false triggers.
The OnStar in my 2019 Corvette Z06 Convertible has never has a false positive crash detection and I do put my Corvette thru its paces. I my opinion I think your sources of information are misinformation and total BS.
Just because you have not had it happen does not mean other owners of OnStar equipped cars have not had a false crash detection activation. It does happen but I do not know what the percentage of those false activation are and the circumstances that enabled that to happen. I imagine it is low or you would hear more about those incidents.
Here's a banana. You seem hangry.
The fact is that old logic no longer applies to our new world. So much is changing, so fast, and we need our expectations to adjust along with those changes.
For example, we're driving down the road in our home town, complaining about how much traffic there is now compared to "before". (Population in our communities has grown by 40% in past 20 years... that' s lot of new people). Yet, we fail to realize that we're in a car, too, just like them. Everybody has the right to have their own car. Do we spend our lives frustrated and complaining about that, or just accept it, be happy, and learn to live with it?
Just because our new phones have a fancy feature doesn't mean that we've giving something up of ourselves. We're not "living at the mercy" of these phones. It's a handy safety feature that may save our life one day. It's a value-add, as our world gets more complicated and busy. Our devices can help.
As for turning off some features before going on a rollercoaster, I agree. I had no idea that Android had crash detection back 3 years.... that was news to me, so is clearly not working well since I don't see any articles claiming that the feature saved people's lives, or went off accidentally.
But we will see articles about iPhones saving people's lives. That I'm sure.
So, my phone is going to just slide out of a zipped shut pocket? I guess I need a better zipper guy.
What happens if you're driving down a lonely deserted spooky road in the Bayou at night, and a swamp thing scares you and you careen off the road and crash into the swamp, and get surrounded by hungry alligators while slowly sinking, all while nobody else is around to see or help you?
In reality this coaster thing isn't much of an issue as you have to be connected to something on Bluetooth too. But I can see Apple adding a toggle for it to control center, like next to Airport Mode or something.
Why would you leave your stuff with a stranger when you can put it in a locker?