Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
it's amazing how you could take such a nice looking phone and turn it so ugly with a case. i never used a case on my 3gs. the rear was plastic so it scratched, but the front never scratched because it's ****ing GLASS

the only point of a case is to prevent it from breaking when it drops... otherwise those screen protectors and anything else you stick onto the phone are a joke
 
No bumper for me... I have to ring in on the "hated it" side. I liked the look and feel, but it blocked ALL of my accessories and all of the older cables I had. Since I didn't want to have to pop it on and off 20 times a day to dock the phone in various places, I shipped it back and am awaiting a refund.

It also seemed to have a habit of pressing and holding the sleep/wake button, so I was always finding my phone sitting there on and saying "Slide to turn off."
 
I picked up the Incipio DermaSHOT on 6/24 at Radio Shack--needed something fast to insulate the antenna.

Turns out to be a really nice silicone skin, and makes the phone much more pleasant to hold. The silicone on the back also keeps the phone far more stable on surfaces.

The docking hole is big enough for old iPod cables, and all buttons are echoed (in rubber) with a cutout for mute. Much to my pleasant surprise, iPhone 4 + case fit well in a universal dock with no inserts.

Also came with a screen protector that I'm largely ignoring. :) Was $20.
 
i'm sorry, but I can't justify paying $29 for a little piece of molded rubber/plastic that costs maybe 25 cents to make....

Make sure you never buy a wire again. Not for audio, video, computers, electrical. You wouldn't want to be in that position of paying so much. Not even the $3 extension cords, clearly the margin is too high for you.
 
Yuck!

What's the point of the industrial design, if you have to put on one of these hideous-looking things?

OK, I get the part that you don't have to, only if you don't want dropping calls and wifi.
 
SO what happened to the "iPhone 4 is 0,05inch thinner than the 3GS, Woa" ??

I choose the Iphone because it's sleek, and it take not much place in my pocket. There's not way I pay, for a case that will make the iphone uglier and bigger.

People who put cases on their iPhone are effin stupid, and if you don't understand why, then you surely don't understand why I use Mac OSX over Windows...
 
Sgp

I've used the SGP case on my 3G for a while, and it is a nice case. Mostly just as a scratch protector for the curved back, but I bought it as a package with the anti-fingerprint matte screen protector. Have been very satisfied, so I purchased the screen protector for the iPhone 4...

Arrived a few days ago-it comes as a package, with that "Invisible Shield" type stuff for the sides/back (large sheet to cover the back, and individual strips for the sides/top) and a different material for the screen up front. It wasn't too hard to install-mostly a static cling type thing, and once in place, it's on for the duration. I tend to put the phone down on its back, so the tougher skin for that side is great.

The front protector is just that-a protector. They didn't have the anti-fingerprint skin in stock when I ordered, so I have what amounts to a screen protector with similar problems with fingerprints as the naked screen. Does provide a bit of peace-of-mind. Nice thing is that this system doesn't change the look of the phone at all, so good for those who simply want protection, rather than a bulky case.

SGP is a great company to deal with, despite their spelling errors on their site. Nice people, and they stand behind the products (not affiliated in any way).

Chris

Oh yeah-just wanted to add that the "Invisible Shield" type stuff for the sides/back seem to insulate the antennae, for those concerned
 
Bumpers are so ugly...almost al of them. What is the point to buy an iPhone ad add a ugly bumper. I had 2 iPhones (3G & 3Gs) with only a case (beyzacases...very nice). So each time i use it i have the real iPhone on hand and not with a bumper or cover. I never had a simple scratch on both iPhones....and I use them a lot!

Now when I hear Apple asking us to buy a bumper to fix the issue or hold the iPhone on the right hand, it is like they are aknowledging an HW issue...

I will hold buying the iPhone 4 for now.
Thoughts?
 
Got my bumper yesterday and it's just terrible, it's a poor product, has tons of play on the sides, doesn't work with the dock.. ugh, I was hoping it would fit tightly seeing as it's an Apple official product, boy was I wrong..

I hope no one buys this thing, although a ton already have, vote with your wallet, this thing is crappy, I'm returning mine.
 
bumper

i got my black bumper case from Manchester Apple store, i have to say £25 is way over the top for what it is. i don't really know how this is meant to protect your phone if anyone knows please let me know. lol.

it has helped the signal level though since its been one the signal bars haven't dipped when holding (which it did when the bumper wasn't on after a couple of tests)
 

Attachments

  • Photo on 2010-06-29 at 17.33.jpg
    Photo on 2010-06-29 at 17.33.jpg
    83.8 KB · Views: 89
So stupid!

I have the 3G iPhone, used to have the case for it, I hate it, I don't want to use one.
I was thinking of buying iPhone 4 but now I don't know if I want to get a phone that I must buy additional ugly bumper in order to prevent signal loss.

Stupid! Stupid! Stupid!!!
 
Bummer!

This is a 3G - prepared for a night out and hard drinking.
 

Attachments

  • Photo on 2010-06-29 at 17.48.jpg
    Photo on 2010-06-29 at 17.48.jpg
    58.7 KB · Views: 92
i wouldnt judge the look of the bumper until you actually see it in person on the phone. i was at apple on launch day and was actually suprised at how good the black bumper looked on the phone. it really does look like it belongs there. the only other color i like besides black is the white one that is nice as well. the other brighter colors arent my thing but im sure some people like them just not for me. but the pictures wont really do it justice until you see and feel them in your hands (no homo) ;)
 
This phone is simply too nice to put a case on. I've had a case on my 3G and 3GS, but never on the original, not on this one either. Simply too enjoyable to hold. Not going to ruin the all glass, disappearing phone look with a frigging rubber.

Some people don't want this to happen when they drop their iPhone 4:

Screen%20shot%202010-06-29%20at%207.17.01%20AM.png



w00master
 
From the website:

SGP Skin Guard, DESIENED FOR iPhone 4

Don't know about you, but it's hard to take an accessory manufacturer seriously if they can't spell "designed".

It's hard to take a company seriously when they design a phone you can't make calls with while holding it in your hand.
 
i got my black bumper case from Manchester Apple store, i have to say £25 is way over the top for what it is. i don't really know how this is meant to protect your phone if anyone knows please let me know. lol.

Most of the time, a drop is onto a fairly flat surface. IF the iPhone hits on an edge, the case supposedly cushions the edges, since it covers the edges, with both rigid plastic, and elastic rubber.

even if the iPhone hits Flat, which is unlikely, the raised edge doesn't let the phone rest on it's flat front or back, it rests on the "raised" edge of the surrounding case. It also keeps the phone from abraision if it slides or is dragged across a surface, by the same raised edge keeping the glass suspended above the surface.

The only thing that would not be protected, is if the phone comes in contact with a convex, pointed, or edge-corner with the phone's glass front or back surface. Unless you are dropping it on a spike, or dropping something sharp on the phone, that isn't entirely likely, and would likely defeat most other cases and most other phones, as well, and becomes a replacement event in most circumstances, even with other comparable touchscreen phones.

But there are plenty of other cases coming out if you wish to have more front and back surface protection.

I don't see the appeal of cases either.
It's like buying a brand new Porsche and driving it around with some type of car cover on it ...

No, it is like buying a brand new Porsche, and putting the Porsche OEM stone guards on the wheel wells to protect the bodywork from stones being flung by the tires, clear-bra to prevent stone chips from other cars, and a good hard coat of wax or sealant to protect the paint.

Unlike the Apple, though, touching the bodywork or even normally gripping the steering wheel, won't kill the engine's ignition system, grinding normal function to a halt.
 
Personally I find bumper case seriously ugly. I would never ever use one.
I guess it's a matter of preference but for me it's a no no.
 
i'm sorry, but I can't justify paying $29 for a little piece of molded rubber/plastic that costs maybe 25 cents to make....

Then why spend $500 + for a phone that only cost $180 to make ?

The fact is that your not seeing research and development costs, your just looking at the parts and materials used, You cant just look at one thing and forget about the other.

SO what happened to the "iPhone 4 is 0,05inch thinner than the 3GS, Woa" ??

I choose the Iphone because it's sleek, and it take not much place in my pocket. There's not way I pay, for a case that will make the iphone uglier and bigger.

People who put cases on their iPhone are effin stupid, and if you don't understand why, then you surely don't understand why I use Mac OSX over Windows...

Oh ok then, So you would be the one that crys when you drop your beautiful unprotected iPhone on the ground while the others just laugh and pick it up without harm. wow dude your the one that's effin stupid.
 
As far as those invisible shields and nonsense go, if something is strong enough to scratch glass, it's going to eat right through that filmy screen protector joke.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.