No...he's right. Internet browsing on the iPhone is abysmal after a while if compared to the iPad. Scroll left, scroll right, scroll left again, zoom in, pan right...just to view an entire page....yeah, that's desirable. Not to mention, you'll need glasses after a while reading such small print, so you are right, the zooming feature is certainly needed.
"Having a smaller screen forces users to be more efficient"...do you actually read what you type? That's a laughable statement. Then why don't you mount a 13" LCD on your living room wall for entertainment. Maybe you'll suddenly become more 'efficient'....lol.
Yes, I DO READ what I type!
So if my logic ~ which is done in practice for years ~ is so incorrect then WHY:
After several years of having 12/13/14" G3 based laptops then going to the G4 did Apple go BACK to the 12" & now 13" laptops which ARE the best sellers EVEN if the current Core i5/i7 chips used in the 15/17" laptops with HIGHER resolutions?! Pontificate that for a moment, and not isolate solely based on price. MANY in threads here and abroad have clearly stated that they prefer the 13"MBP vs the 15/17" MBP regardless of price.
I've been surfing the web & mobile web on feature phones and smartphones for YEARS:
SonyEricssons: T18z, T36m, T68m (an Ericsson), K790a and K800.
Nokia: 6600, 6620, E71x2, E66, and N85.
BlackBerry: 8100, 8700, 8800/8820, 8300/8310/8320, 8900, 9700 currently.
Motorola: I think it was the M9 or something *9 model that was designed to mimic a BB and was a 3G device for AT&T while also being a CDMA device for Verizon (I used Fido's model here in Canada).
I've posted on multiple forums ~ mostly phone forums like HowardForums, Esato, here, etc directly from ANY of those feature/smartphones without issues ~ save for the widespread implementation of Flash use on sites.
IT's amazing how efficient you can become with:
* Tabbed browsing
* Zooming - not EVERYTHING on a home page is what you're after (source reading is the key not reading the entire site which is not what you're after).
* isolating your searches to get what you're after (I actually suck at this on ANY site but I try).
- And I do this with a D-Pad, Trackpad, numerical keys, etc. Imagine the efficiency of using a full multi-touch screen. Unlike many others taking their sweet time to stroke and pet the multi-touch screen to show off just how EASY it is I go to work and get straight to it: try using 2 thumbs during navigation, not just your 1 index finger (its a machine NOT a pet to stroke).
I don't NEED a large screen to enjoy the web and if you're sold on the iPad just cause of the large screen then you've been duped if that is the BEST browsing experience.