Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

Is your black iPhone 5 scuffed, chipped or scratched?

  • Flawless

    Votes: 1,158 46.1%
  • Flawless because I put a case on it.

    Votes: 198 7.9%
  • Scuffed out of the box

    Votes: 820 32.7%
  • Scuffed/scratched shortly after

    Votes: 334 13.3%

  • Total voters
    2,510
My replacement was hand inspected by the looks of things. Before I even took it out of the box I noticed fingerprints all over it. And yes, it was a sealed phone.

Did they send you a new phone? My replacement is coming directly from China. I wish it was the white box phones. I feel like there is a better chance for it arriving without dings or dents.
 
Nope, don't have Applecare. I should mention, this is in the UK. Might be different in the US.

I see. I talked to a "senior adviser" yesterday about getting a replacement, and he told me an express replacement (where they put a full price hold on your CC) would cost $30 extra for shipping/return shipping charges, unless I had AppleCare Protection Plan or AppleCare+. Otherwise my only other options would be to wait til my local store gets more in stock, or send in my current iphone by UPS/Fedex and wait til a replacement arrives.
 
My replacement was hand inspected by the looks of things. Before I even took it out of the box I noticed fingerprints all over it. And yes, it was a sealed phone.

Mine was in a white box, no accessories. It was sealed with a sticker saying something about inspected by Applecare. It had finger prints on it. Still had the scratch.
 
Called Apple Care this morning about the very small scratch (about 2mm where the bezel and band meet above the lightning port) on iPhone 5 64B Black. Wanted to make sure they documented it in the event things get worse.

Phone Rep said Apple was aware of the scuff out of the box issues, and that this was happening to the pre-ordered phones that came directly from China!!!

Where does he thing the "others" come from?!?!?
 
Just Received my black 64gb replacement today. It was not a new box, it was a replacement and it said "Inspected by Applecare".

The phone looked to be flawless, but there is scratch on the back where the edge meets the backing. What's even funnier is the replacement phone has the + and - volume keys reversed. I think I am just going to keep my original one and forget about it.
 

Attachments

  • photo.JPG
    photo.JPG
    1.7 MB · Views: 884
Did they send you a new phone? My replacement is coming directly from China. I wish it was the white box phones. I feel like there is a better chance for it arriving without dings or dents.

They sent me a new one yeah. It only took a day for delivery as it was sent from the UK strangely.
 
applecare +

I've seen some of you mentioning applecare+, is this available in the uk? I can only see the option for standard applecare on the apple website. I'm still wanting for my ip5 to be delivered and want to look into this before it arrives.
 
For those getting replacements in the UK when order online straight from Apple, does your replacement arrive as new in a sealed iPhone box just like you'd bought it new?

I've just got my replacement ordered. Have to say Apple UK were fantastic about it, wasn't on the phone 10 mins and they had approved it. It should be here in 3-5 days and they said to arrange a date for pickup of my old one for after the new one arrives so I won't be without a phone. Ideal!

But after reading some of this forum I was wondering if it'll be like new, sealed in the box with all accessories?

Cheers
 
. . . What's even funnier is the replacement phone has the + and - volume keys reversed. I think I am just going to keep my original one and forget about it.

Wow . . . . how in the world could that pass any stringent QA tests?

I really hope you get something sorted.
 
Just Received my black 64gb replacement today. It was not a new box, it was a replacement and it said "Inspected by Applecare".

The phone looked to be flawless, but there is scratch on the back where the edge meets the backing. What's even funnier is the replacement phone has the + and - volume keys reversed. I think I am just going to keep my original one and forget about it.

My gosh....super fail.
 
have y'all tried your cameras yet? purplehazegate here we come!!

i took a bunch of pictures, playing with camera and i saw all of these purple rings in the pictures - did not know if i should call the long island medium or applecare!

when i called applecare as i just wanted it to be documented, he had no clue how i could pull up my profile page and he told me that he has not received one complaint about the iphone 5 at all!

i did a google search and i guess it is on the list of problems - wonder if this can be fixed with a software update?? found this article here
 
If you don't have apple care and they send you a replacement via Fedex or UPS they will charge you $29 unless you get them to waive the fee.

They were the ones that suggested they would send out a replacement straight away, so I doubt they will charge me for the privilege. It must be different in the UK, because a couple of people I know have received replacements, and they weren't charged either.
 
Just Received my black 64gb replacement today. It was not a new box, it was a replacement and it said "Inspected by Applecare".

The phone looked to be flawless, but there is scratch on the back where the edge meets the backing. What's even funnier is the replacement phone has the + and - volume keys reversed. I think I am just going to keep my original one and forget about it.

You've got to be kidding...
 
Just Received my black 64gb replacement today. It was not a new box, it was a replacement and it said "Inspected by Applecare".

The phone looked to be flawless, but there is scratch on the back where the edge meets the backing. What's even funnier is the replacement phone has the + and - volume keys reversed. I think I am just going to keep my original one and forget about it.

That is just ridiculous...
 
just received my black 64gb replacement today. It was not a new box, it was a replacement and it said "inspected by applecare".

The phone looked to be flawless, but there is scratch on the back where the edge meets the backing. What's even funnier is the replacement phone has the + and - volume keys reversed. I think i am just going to keep my original one and forget about it.

wtf
 

Attachments

  • facepalm_jim.jpg
    facepalm_jim.jpg
    41.1 KB · Views: 104
Wow . . . . how in the world could that pass any stringent QA tests?

I really hope you get something sorted.


I just talked to Applecare. I sent them photos and they will be sending me another replacement after I send the current replacement back. They offered me headphones or a lightning cable for free. I said that I was just going to keep the original, but the representative insisted that I try one more replacement.
 
For those getting replacements in the UK when order online straight from Apple, does your replacement arrive as new in a sealed iPhone box just like you'd bought it new?

I've just got my replacement ordered. Have to say Apple UK were fantastic about it, wasn't on the phone 10 mins and they had approved it. It should be here in 3-5 days and they said to arrange a date for pickup of my old one for after the new one arrives so I won't be without a phone. Ideal!

But after reading some of this forum I was wondering if it'll be like new, sealed in the box with all accessories?

Cheers

I am in the UK and ordered a replacement, Apple said it won't cost me anything, they will send a brand new sealed black model out to me, it will have all the accessories and documentation.

There's no charge for this service, there's NO hold on my debit card in case I don't send the other one back. They are trusting me to uphold my end of the bargain.


3-5 days to deliver, they will send a courier in 7 days so that I can play with both colour models and choose which one I want to keep. If I want a few more days, I can simply tell the courier when I want him to pick the other phone up. Completely up to me.

I asked her if people send their phones back to Apple, she said most do, but there's not much they can do if you don't send it back. I assured her I'd send mine back. Had a very interesting conversation on returns and what people do to make an easy buck and theft. Suffice to say , Mine is going back with everything it came with , unopened , and as mint as possible.

Apple have been amazing, I have never ever come across customer service like this before. Not ever. It's incredible.
 
Just Received my black 64gb replacement today. It was not a new box, it was a replacement and it said "Inspected by Applecare".

The phone looked to be flawless, but there is scratch on the back where the edge meets the backing. What's even funnier is the replacement phone has the + and - volume keys reversed. I think I am just going to keep my original one and forget about it.

holy crap thats horrible!
 
anyone got any ideas how to fix a tiny ding in the metal shamfer. Its not as bad as others on here so I probably wont bother to replace it but I was wondering if it was possible to just touch it up with something like a sharpie?
 
Got my replacement black yesterday, and it's much better than my original one.

There are some faints scuffs (I hesitate to call them that) around the rounded corners on the top-left and bottom-left, but they are so minor they hardly bother me. There is a light scuff on the border of the anodized aluminum that is hardly visible, but again, that doesn't bother me.

I've got an iPhone 5 I feel is good enough to keep. You might think that's compromise, but after going through replacement after replacement on my iPad 2 for backlight bleed, sometimes good enough...is good enough. You could wind up with worse.

I'm not quite ready to call this one flawless, but it's near-flawless, and due to the nature of the mass-market manufacturing process - it's, yes, good enough.
 
Got my replacement black yesterday, and it's much better than my original one.

There are some faints scuffs (I hesitate to call them that) around the rounded corners on the top-left and bottom-left, but they are so minor they hardly bother me. There is a light scuff on the border of the anodized aluminum that is hardly visible, but again, that doesn't bother me.

I've got an iPhone 5 I feel is good enough to keep. You might think that's compromise, but after going through replacement after replacement on my iPad 2 for backlight bleed, sometimes good enough...is good enough. You could wind up with worse.

I'm not quite ready to call this one flawless, but it's near-flawless, and due to the nature of the mass-market manufacturing process - it's, yes, good enough.

How long did it take to arrive?
 
Just Received my black 64gb replacement today. It was not a new box, it was a replacement and it said "Inspected by Applecare".

The phone looked to be flawless, but there is scratch on the back where the edge meets the backing. What's even funnier is the replacement phone has the + and - volume keys reversed. I think I am just going to keep my original one and forget about it.

Haha, inspected by AppleCare. That's horrible!
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.