Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
I love it!

Instead of "I don't care enough to not do something stupid with the $500 device I just purchased" its "Apple how dare you not rewrite the laws of physics so I don't have to care for my expensive purchase".


Man consumerism really is warping peoples mind's, "the customer is always right" even if they do something incredibly dumb and obvious.:rolleyes:

I've got my flame shield, so I'm ready for the "well I sit on my phone and nothing happens so therefore that is the intended normal use" posts.

So you drive a new car out of the showroom and get into an accident, you should get a new car as a replacement? Maybe in good service customer is always right.

For the rest of the industries, it's a case by case basis. Apple has good customer service and on forums like these, you don't hear a lot if negativity against apple customer service.
 
Defender case. solid back

Three options as I see it.
1. I broke my phone or bent it doing something stupid and I'm here to drum up noise and pity or something. Lot's of people see physical defects and scream "you broke it". Not always the case.

2. The case had something to do with it. This is a pretty popular case. The case doesn't look warped but I'll measure accurately tomorrow. The case could be counterfeit. I'll look into that option more.

3. Manufactures defect. I'm aware of the properties of aluminum and have worked with it before. This is thin aluminum resting around internals that get pretty toasty while charging. Then add insulation from the case itself. Heat could have nothing to do with it or it could have had an effect. Doesn't particularly matter to me.

This happened in the case.

No way the phone in your case got hot enough for the aluminum to just bend. A friend of mine bent his 5S just by bumping a table with his thigh right where is phone was in his front pocket. He also had an otterbox case and it is bent to the point where the glass will not stay in the casing.

Aluminum is soft and Apple is making the phones thinner and thinner. Bet it bent right at the down volume button which is very common.:rolleyes:
 
So you drive a new car out of the showroom and get into an accident, you should get a new car as a replacement? Maybe in good service customer is always right.

For the rest of the industries, it's a case by case basis. Apple has good customer service and on forums like these, you don't hear a lot if negativity against apple customer service.

That's not what I said.

Driving into a wall doesn't mean it's Toyota's fault that you blame them for not designing a car designed to be driven into a wall.
 
Kind of an odd analogy. Toyota actually does design their cars to be driven into walls.

Anyway, aluminum bends. You bent it. It's not steel, it's aluminum. There is no way heat in the case had anything to do with it. No way at all. A expanding battery would probably pop the screen off before bending the case.
 
I love these posts. I think the underlying trend each time is the same, and it involves a fat butt and sitting down :D
 
I don't know, my i5 basically lives in my back pocket. I'm a male, about 170lbs. I've never bent, broken, cracked, etc. a phone. I sit on mine frequently. I fully understand that it's a "game of Russian roulette" but meh. I normally remember to remove it if I sit on a solid surface, but anything upholstered is a non-issue for me.

Sometimes I read damaged phone threads, and wonder if i get the super-phones or something.
 
No matter how lucky you are today..


Expensive iPhone + Back pocket = Really, really dumb idea....PERIOD !​
 
He smashed his phone and Apple replaced it for free. What is the complaint?
 
For everyone that's purchasing a new iPhone 5S, check and make sure the phone is not bend even slightly. If it looks like it's bend slightly, it's probably not your imagination and it's defective.

So my friend had order an iPhone 5S online and received Wednesday. I helped him setup his new phone and noticed the fingerprint home button doesn't work correctly. I told him to take it to Apple for them to see what's wrong. At the time, I didn't see any warp or damage on the phone. I put on a screen protector and in a case and gave him the phone after setting it up. Since my friend was rushing to go pick up his daughter from dance class, he didn't inspect the phone closely. He did notice the phone seem to be warped a little when he got into his car, barely noticeable, and chalked it up to bad lighting.

On Saturday afternoon, my friend noticed the screen protector was a coming off near the volume button so he took it out of the case and really inspect it. After 3 days of use, no dropping, just in his front pocket when he goes out, the phone had warped right by the volume button. We took it back to Apple to exchange it and was given a hard time about it.

Per the tech that helped us, this is consider wear and tear/ abuse of the phone. I explain to him that this phone was used for 3 days, there's no marking or scratches on it. We never dropped it. The first time this phone was dropped was when we went in and the Apple employee that checked us in dropped the phone. The tech went on and said this could have happened because my friend sat on his phone. Um... Sorry Apple but a lot of people put their phone in the back pocket. If your phone can't withstand being sit on, you should probably put a disclaimer on your phones. For a small guy who's maybe 140 lbs to sit on the phone and have it bend from that within 3 days? There's a defect on Apple's work, not us abusing the phone.

Needless to say, the tech made it sound like he did us such a huge favor of exchanging the phone. Never had I had such horrible service at Apple. To be accuse of damaging something when it was defective to begin with. I'm ok with the fact that some of the phones might be defective since Apple is trying to make 6 millions of them if not more but don't accuse us of breaking it when it's clearly a problem with Apple not us.

yeah, right.........
 
Aluminum is a poor choice for a phone. It bends, esp the kind that they used if you believe the rumor that they used a softer kind.

And yes, my phone is slightly bent as well, doing the same exact activities as I did with my iphone 4, which never bent at all. Would I ever win a court case, probably not. Did I notice it, independently, before I ever read about it on this forum? Yes. Would I have ever noticed it on an iphone 4? Yes, if it had been present, but it wasn't.

The 5 is much lighter than the 4, but you give up the rigidity of the 4. Overall it's a less sturdy design on Apple's part. Peeps never talked about warping/bending of the iphone 4, and to all of a sudden have this pop up after the 5 and 5s are released suggests to me that there is something to this. There were as many hyperphoniacs when the 4 was released, but the ultra sensitive did not pick up on bending when the 4 was around. There's something going on with the rigidity of the 5 compared to the 4, that's for sure.
 
There were as many hyperphoniacs when the 4 was released, but the ultra sensitive did not pick up on bending when the 4 was around. There's something going on with the rigidity of the 5 compared to the 4, that's for sure.

https://discussions.apple.com/message/24530643#24530643

https://discussions.apple.com/message/15234980#15234980

https://forums.macrumors.com/threads/1226742/

It may not have been as widespread, but it did happen with the 4/4s. But the fact still remains, the phone didn't bend itself. At some point, a force was placed on the phone that caused it to bend.
 
Apple should launch iPants with superprotective iPockets for iPhone. Those would be cool.

It fails as designed. At volume button, where there's very very thin section of soft aluminium. It doesn't require much force to bend. It doesn't require abuse, just that you for a little moment forget to watch over your baby.
It's an ambitious piece of design but impractical.

https://forums.macrumors.com/posts/16579466/
https://forums.macrumors.com/posts/16609693/
 
So the same thing happened to my wife's Lexus over the weekend (hear me out)!

It came without any "bends" from the factory. Point #1

She totally DID NOT hit a curb on the way out of the parking lot. Point #2

It now mysteriously has damage that looks like it hit a curb, but as I mentioned in Point #2, totally DID NOT. Point #3

I am at Lexus right now. I cannot believe the HORRIBLE quality control. The fact that the car curbs itself is INSANE. Please please PLEASE check to make sure your's doesn't have the same "issue" as ours did.

(Now assume I posted this on a Lexus forum... when you get done rolling on the floor laughing, get up, dust yourself off, and TAKE RESPONSIBILITY FOR YOUR OWN ACTIONS!!!).

:p
 
^before laughing and rolling, please take your iPhone from any pocket to a safe place...

Lexus analogy would work better if you one day noticed that the back door wouldn't open because the body is distorted. Only because you drove 35kph over a speed bump, when you should drive only 30kph.
Maybe you did it because you are used to drive recklessly with your Hyundai Pony. Forgot to respect rules and destroyed a fine car by your own actions...
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.