1) iPod Not the first mp3 player.
2) Graphical User Interface - borrowed from Xerox. THEN the next entry on this list was a whole decade later!
3) iMac - Candy-colored cases are an innovation?
4) iTunes - seriously?
5) Mac OS X - it's a Unix front end
6) iPhone - not all that smart for a "smart phone" when it first came out
7) Apple Newton -- nine years after the Mac. Is a nine-year gap acceptable for a LEADER in innovation? If so, then the inclusion of the Apple Watch on this list means you need to wait until at least 2024 before you can credibly claim that Apple innovative days are in the past. Assuming Apple doesn't innovate in the meantime.
8) Apple II -- just four months before the Commodore PET.
9) Keynotes -- Come on! In 1933, we witnessed the unveiling of Kong, the Eighth Wonder of the World!
10) MacBook Air -- Thinner! (I thought we hated thinner.)
11) iPad. It's just a big iPhone, without the phone.
12) Apple Watch. So Apple's days of being a leader in innovation ended a little less than a year ago. You're sure there's nothing in the pipeline?
So I guess according to your logic, a car is just a glorified moped, a moped a bicycle with an engine, a bicycle a unicycle with another wheel, and a unicycle a seat with a wheel underneath?
Well, I think you just invented a new fallacy.
iPhone was definitely an innovation since nobody was doing keyless multitouch phones before it came out.
Just because the underlying architecture is A doesn't mean B(a) isn't an innovation. This is again a logical error on your part.
Something that is better put together should be considered an innovation. I had this debate long ago with colleagues of mine when Steve Jobs passed. Your definition of innovation is probably more akin to that of "invention", which rarely applies in the consumer tech world.
The genius of Steve Jobs is that he can't write programs and that he doesn't know as much about hardware as an engineer but he knows how things "should" fit together. The reasons that you claim iPhone, Mac OS X, iMac and iPad are *not* an innovation are the very reasons that they are - so simply obvious to the point of being so obviously simple (that people should have thought of it before).
I agree with you on Apple Watch and a few other items on the list though, despite the cynic undertone.