Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
My wife loves her thin q, v35?. The camera is really good, I would say it takes a better pic than my s9+ at times. That said, over all my s9+ beats it at everything else except sound using DAC.
But around here its yada yada yada Apple rules, yada yada yada Android sucks. Except since Marshmallow android no longer is a junk OS.
 
With the state of Android updates not being pushed to many types of phones a year or more old I will not purchase a Android phone. iOS 12 adaption already passed the latest Android update and previous Android update. Not because users do not want the latest Android OS and updates, it is because carriers and manufactures are not supplying them. Their attitude is “you want the updates purchase a new phone”.

At present I am running a four year old iPhone 6S Plus, iOS 12 runs on it. What four year old Android phone gets the latest update? For as long as as my iPhone can take updates or until it quits working I will continue using it not purchasing another phone. My phone is used throughout the day it does not sit unused for long.
 



LG today debuted its next-generation smartphone, the LG V40 ThinQ, equipped with an all glass body and a display notch for housing camera equipment, much like the iPhone XS and XS Max.

We were able to get one of LG's new V40 ThinQ smartphones ahead of their launch, and we've got the first V40 ThinQ vs. iPhone XS Max comparison that highlights the differences between Apple's flagship device and LG's new flagship device.


The LG V40 ThinQ features an all glass body with an aluminum frame, while the iPhone XS Max has an all glass body with a stainless steel frame. Apple has done away with the headphone jack, but the V40 still has one, and instead of a Lightning port, it features a USB-C port.

In the hand, the LG V40 ThinQ feels lighter than the iPhone XS Max, but due to the size, it's still a two-handed device.

lgv40iphonexsmaxbody-800x527.jpg

The V40 measures in at 6.4 inches with a high-quality HDR OLED display that is as sharp and vibrant as the 6.5-inch HDR OLED display of the iPhone XS Max.

iphonexsmaxvslgv40front-800x524.jpg

Both devices have a front-facing notch, and while the V40's notch is somewhat less obtrusive, it's also housing lesser equipment. The V40 ThinQ features two front-facing cameras, one with 8 megapixels and the second with 5 megapixels. The cameras enable a fast and efficient facial recognition feature for unlocking the device, but as with most Android implementations, it's not using 3D facial mapping and is less secure.

lgv40iphonexsmaxnotch-800x510.jpg

Because of the weaker facial recognition implementation, LG's new device continues to offer a fingerprint sensor at the back.

The back of the LG V40 ThinQ is outfitted with three horizontal cameras, while the iPhone XS Max uses a dual camera system. In the V40, there's a 12-megapixel wide-angle lens, a 12-megapixel telephoto lens, and a 16-megapixel wide-angle lens.

The three cameras enable a range of useful features like Triple Shot for three photos at once from different angles, a Cine Shot for creating a photo with one part of the image in motion, and slow motion and portrait features similar to what you'll find in the iPhone XS Max.

lgiphonexsmaxcamera-800x484.jpg

We think the LG V40 is a solid iPhone XS Max competitor with its light weight and its impressive camera equipment, and in a future video, we'll delve further into the triple-lens camera system as rumors have suggested it's something we might see in next year's iPhones.

What do you think of the new LG V40 ThinQ? Does it measure up to the iPhone XS Max? Let us know in the comments.

Article Link: iPhone XS Max vs. LG's Newly Announced V40 ThinQ

How long will the battery last?
 
XS white balance on the display seems much better than other comparable models.
 
This is the nicest LG phone to date. I'm very interested in upgrading from my S8+ to this phone. I'm just ready to try something new and the cameras and nice DAC seem like neat features.
I have an LG V20 as well as an iPhone 6s+. I like both of those phones. The 6s+ gets the edge in battery efficiency and integration with my iMac and iPad; the V20 has the edge with its 4 channel DAC sound system, and even though it has less battery life, it is the last high end phone to have a removable battery, which I still miss with other phones; the V20 also has a fast charging USB-C interface. I like that both of these phones have headphone jacks. The downside of the V40, imo, is that it no longer sports a removable battery, so I hope that its battery is more efficient than its V20 ancestor. I have 3 batteries for my V20 and a separate charger, which makes its battery issues less of a problem (spare batteries run around $20). The V40 retains the phone jack - yea, especially for supporting its superior sound system. As for the face id, which I honestly find to be something of a costly gimmick making the notch necessary and raising the prices, it's even less compelling with the V40 if it is less reliable. They should have just retained the touch id and left face id off of it. If Apple reintroduced the phone jack onto at least one of its models, and perhaps retained touch id as an alternative to face id (that's good for the V40), I'd be more enthusiastic about purchasing one. I'm going to pay closer attention to V40 reviews over the next several months. I'll probably purchase a V20 replacement within a year or so.
 
LG not my cup of tea to be fair but each to their own, however love the comments in here which are predictable about android, however i dont recall google using my phonecalls and email meta data on both ios devices and apple tv to issue each of its users a "Trust Score" of course in the name of "preventing fraud" and as agreed by everyone who installed IOS12, didnt see a mass press release on this "security feature".

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/technol...-users-secret-trust-score-based-calls-emails/
 
The main issues I have with Android phones are:

1. Apps aren't well sandboxed. Malicious apps can and do steal and transmit data from other apps. Maybe this is fixed in current Android versions?

2. It's a crap shoot whether the phone ever get updated, even for glaring security issues.

3. I'm trapped in iMessage hell.
My thoughts on your three points:
1) This tends to be an issue with Android for the same reason security issues plague MS Windows - the system is spread across so many vendors that no seamless security implementation can be easily implemented.

2) Related to point 1, even though Google puts out updates fairly regularly, it's up to individual vendors and carriers to release them where needed. For obvious reasons, this is where the Pixel is superior.

3) Message integration is less of an issue than in the past, with encrypted messaging software available from Signal and WhatsApp across iOS, Android, MacOS, Windows, and Linux platforms.
 
  • Like
Reactions: groadyho
In all seriousness, what useful or fascinating things can I do with Apple's A12 chip that I can't with others? I'm switching to an Android phone (most likely the Pixel). What will I be sacrificing?

I think it's more about what you'll be gaining (and keep in mind I do what i do professionally because of Apple and have been using Apple products since the Apple II):
-Widgets, which for some bizarre reason Apple refuses to copy after a decade.
-Flexibility to customize instead of the "Apple knows better what you need than you do" mentality.
-Probably a cheaper phone.
-A headphone jack, if you're into that sort of thing.
-Choices, choices, choices.

There's a lot more than that but it's a start.

Some things depend on your view ie is power management better on an iPhone or is using the full potential of the processor better? Both have their merits.
 
  • Like
Reactions: kwikdeth
Can makers stop it with the notch.

I'm not touching a phone with one and since every company has to copy one of the worse design elements, most flagship phones are out. (aside from the galaxy line)
As I understand it, current implementation of face id requires the notch for infrared sensors. Perhaps there will eventually be a workaround on that, but I don't find the notch and infrared beams to be worth any gains of face id over touch id. Obviously, others feel differently. The V40 would have been fine without the notch, especially with inferior face id (not sure of the details backing up that, but will find out over time.)
 
  • Like
Reactions: Rhartford
Wait wait wait, androids have notches now but can still manage to show me the battery percentage?! Haha

In fairness, I don't think Apple didn't put the battery percentage indicator on the home screen because they don't know how to do it. They just decided not to ... for some reason.
 
My thoughts on your three points:
1) This tends to be an issue with Android for the same reason security issues plague MS Windows - the system is spread across so many vendors that no seamless security implementation can be easily implemented.

2) Related to point 1, even though Google puts out updates fairly regularly, it's up to individual vendors and carriers to release them where needed. For obvious reasons, this is where the Pixel is superior.

3) Message integration is less of an issue than in the past, with encrypted messaging software available from Signal and WhatsApp across iOS, Android, MacOS, Windows, and Linux platforms.


On point 3, yeah, it would be great everyone I knew used a third party cross platform messaging system. It won't happen in the foreseeable future. Snapchat almost had a chance because everyone had it installed for about a year. Snapchat blew it.
 
I'm not sure why people continue to tout so called iPhone competitors. The truth is there is nothing out there that can complete remotely with any iPhone in the lineup.

Lol, its not April the first yet old fella... the galaxy/note series are more than a match on every level.. if you think differently you are just deluding yourself.
 
  • Like
Reactions: groadyho
LG phones are absolutely unusable, at least for me, because they don't provide frequent software updates and their UI is awful.
[doublepost=1538671359][/doublepost]I wonder if anyone looking for an Android device said "no thank you (or no thinq)" to the LG V40 w/ their $900+ USD price point? At that price, you're better off with a Note 9 or iPhone XS/XS Max. Hell, I think the OnePlus 6T will be the more budget friendly flagship (ironic to say budget friendly w/ flagship) and the Pixel 3 will be slightly more affordable.
[doublepost=1538671597][/doublepost]
My wife loves her thin q, v35?. The camera is really good, I would say it takes a better pic than my s9+ at times. That said, over all my s9+ beats it at everything else except sound using DAC.
But around here its yada yada yada Apple rules, yada yada yada Android sucks. Except since Marshmallow android no longer is a junk OS.

As a former S9+ owner, I still think Samsung is gimped experience. The software updates are not frequent enough to give monthly security patches on some carriers. Samsung may give a ton of features, but they also do not optimize their phones enough because you still have their garbage duplicate apps w/ Google Apps. Then you have gimmicky features eating storage (even if disabled). I think they need to make a flat option over the curved displays.

To me, Samsung gives me a junky experience because it feels so damn cluttered. Their phones start to tumble about 8-12 months after first purchased dates too. I have a family member with the Note 8 and it's starting to have plenty of software bugs with text messages and app icons. They did a factory reset and still didn't resolve the issues. No company is perfect, but I chose Apple for peace of mind.

I had problems with touchscreen responsiveness on my old S9+. The device didn't feel as fluid as other Android devices. The OnePlus 6 is the most fluid Android device I have seen myself. Only devices I could recommend are pure Android or minimally skinned ones like the OP or Motorola ones (awful update schedules though). I am rooting for the Blackberry licensed devices and Nokia devices to succeed though.
 
Last edited:
I think it's more about what you'll be gaining (and keep in mind I do what i do professionally because of Apple and have been using Apple products since the Apple II):
-Widgets, which for some bizarre reason Apple refuses to copy after a decade.
-Flexibility to customize instead of the "Apple knows better what you need than you do" mentality.
-Probably a cheaper phone.
-A headphone jack, if you're into that sort of thing.
-Choices, choices, choices.

There's a lot more than that but it's a start.

Some things depend on your view ie is power management better on an iPhone or is using the full potential of the processor better? Both have their merits.

I, too, am someone who uses Apple’s MacOS products professionally and recreationally. I still have a high regard for MacOS.

iOS is another matter. I feel its focus is the antithesis of Apple’s earlier mantras. It is a merchandising tool for Apple—a platform for consumerism. Not that I believe a smartphone shouldn’t be. My dissapointment is that it doesn’t want to be a better tool as well.
 
  • Like
Reactions: kwikdeth and radus
Interesting how the 2017 iPhone X was chastised heavily for having a notch, now the competition is supporting this feature, but less secure than Apples 3D facial mapping.
According to other posts, Apple users originally criticized some older Android phone which had a notch before iPhone X.

In their iPhone marketing pictures, is Apple deliberately using wallpapers which are black at the top in order to make the notch less apparent?
 
It is beyond absurd how they are all copying the notch. The notch is there for a very specific reason on the iPhone. These other companies don't have true Face ID, and could easily fit their front facing cameras in a thin bezel.
 
I’ve had my LG TV for almost 6 years and Best Buy had to service it once and did a great job. I also had an LG refrigerator that I just replaced after 17 years (it still worked, just needed a bigger fridge), and my LG washing machine is going on 5 years now too. I do recommend the extended warranty though on any high-priced products.

see, the thing is with these companies, they are actually essentially conglomerates of companies that all operate under the same umbrella. its like, GE makes railroad engines and light bulbs, but the two businesses really have nothing to do with each other. Same with these big overseas conglomerates like Samsung and LG.

Samsung makes excellent computer electronics. Their phones are top-notch. Their SSDs are the kings of the market. Their RAM and displays are in just about everything.

You could not give me a Samsung appliance if it was the newest, most feature-rich, amazing product that was ever made. I wouldnt take one if you paid me to do so. It will be crap junk on the curb in less than three years. Every Samsung appliance ive seen in other people's homes has either been crap or well on the way to becoming crap. I know that personal experience will be different, but what Samsung has taught me over the years is that just because one product is good it doesnt mean their product in another market is as well.

LG phones have not had the best reputation. However, like yourself, my LG appliances have all been exceptional purchases that have never had problems.
 
Bro... You don’t even notice the notch while using the phone! As I’m typing this message all I see is the actual screen. I don’t know why people are so fixated on the notch. It’s allll the way up top.

Apple could’ve probably just made the notch stretch across the entire top so it looks more normal, but who cares. They probably wanted something “distinguishing”.

I think people hate it, just to hate it. Same way you think people copy Apple, just for the sake of copying Apple.
I'm with you when it comes to the notch. People forget that space was pretty much wasted on the screen anyway before the notch appeared.

I believe a certain number of people formed an opinion about the notch that was rooted in their dislike of Apple, and they won't budge from it. I get really tired of people whining about the notch especially given all of the Android phones sporting notches.
 
Yet you did. Just wait, the iPhone XI will have 5 cameras, too. It took Apple a few years to copy the large size of Android phones, so give them some time to copy the extra cameras, too.
Yawn. Next.
[doublepost=1538716117][/doublepost]
The anger of the Apple lovers here is just hilarious. Seriously, who cares what they copy? Everyone copies everyone. Good grief.

Also I can see the writing on the wall now.

2018: 3 rear cameras? No one needs that! That’s absurd! What a gimmick!

2019: (Same people) The iPhone 11 is the BEST PHONE EVER! Those 3 rear cameras are amazing and produce the best photos I’ve ever seen! Apple rules!
It’s because we see so many android OEMs try to throw features to a phone hoping it will stick. Most of them are useless, but make for a good sales commercial or even a diss at Apple. What Apple does is take a said technology and not copy it, but make it better and easier to use in real life. Face ID versus facial scanning. Dual camera setup with optical zoom. Get it?? We all know “android” does it first. That’s cool. You can keep it. Apple does it better.
 
  • Like
Reactions: chuloo
Yawn. Next.
[doublepost=1538716117][/doublepost]
It’s because we see so many android OEMs try to throw features to a phone hoping it will stick. Most of them are useless, but make for a good sales commercial or even a diss at Apple. What Apple does is take a said technology and not copy it, but make it better and easier to use in real life. Face ID versus facial scanning. Dual camera setup with optical zoom. Get it?? We all know “android” does it first. That’s cool. You can keep it. Apple does it better.
Someone named “AppleFan” claims “Apple does it better.” About everything.

You just proved my point almost letter for letter. I for one enjoy getting out of my comfort zone and trying different approaches to things from different manufacturers.

There are plenty of areas, yes even on your precious iPhone, where Android is better and has been for years. Some of them aren’t even close.
 
With the state of Android updates not being pushed to many types of phones a year or more old I will not purchase a Android phone. iOS 12 adaption already passed the latest Android update and previous Android update. Not because users do not want the latest Android OS and updates, it is because carriers and manufactures are not supplying them. Their attitude is “you want the updates purchase a new phone”.

At present I am running a four year old iPhone 6S Plus, iOS 12 runs on it. What four year old Android phone gets the latest update? For as long as as my iPhone can take updates or until it quits working I will continue using it not purchasing another phone. My phone is used throughout the day it does not sit unused for long.
Apple recently announced they are going to allow their devices to be compatible with iOS updates for much longer. I have an iPad Mini 2 that's gone from iOS 7 to iOS 12 already!
 
  • Like
Reactions: AppleFan910
Interesting how the 2017 iPhone X was chastised heavily for having a notch, now the competition is supporting this feature, but less secure than Apples 3D facial mapping.

I have to praise Samsung for avoiding the notch. For once it was a good decision not to copy from Apple :D
Pretty much all the other competitors are building smartphones with the notch, and it is usually uglier.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.