If the phone works with a rubber 'bumper', to me that's a clear admission that they could have (
should have) engineered this to work without forcing people to worry about how they hold the phone.
I have a lot of respect for Steve Jobs, but he's lost me with this one. Okay, other phones lose some signal strength when held I've confirmed this with my 3G. But some people are completely losing an otherwise strong signal just by holding the phone in the normal fashion, because (as is clearly demonstrated in
this YouTube video) there is an issue with the two antennas shorting out due to their proximity and external exposure. It saddens me to say it, but I can't see Apple escaping this one. This is an obvious and easily demonstrated design flaw.
Look, this same external antenna design was something Apple tried to sell as a new design
feature something that differentiates the iPhone 4 from other phones. But now that its weakness is apparent, Apple wants to downplay the difference and say it works just like other phones?!
Some people are saying this isn't a deal breaker. Well sorry guys, but it is for me, and I was as excited about this phone's release as the next guy. I'm now going to wait and hope that the early adopters don't put up with this from Apple, because really, Apple's response is in your hands. If enough people refuse to put up with this issue, what would probably have been the most profitable product launch in Apple's history will be a flop, and Apple will be forced to take notice. Yes, it's gonna hurt their bottom line, and as a long time Apple fan I don't like to see that, but that's something Apple is going to have to deal with for pushing out a product with such a glaring design flaw.
Yes, it's an otherwise brilliant product by all accounts, but that doesn't make it acceptable for what is, after all, still marketed as a 'phone'.