Black Flag - If you ever have a chance to see Henry Rollins "talk" live, I urge you to go. He gets up and talks non-stop for hours about what he's been up to, and he is completely enthralling. So intense. Doesn't matter what he's talking about, it'll be interesting. One time he talked about taking a trip to the Middle East to just wander around and meet people to understand them better. At a time when it was especially bad to be a single American wandering around the area.
James Brown - too many years ago, a friend had a little hand-held sample-box, that was James Brown embellishments in your hand - "Hit Me!" was one of the four buttons it had. Man I miss that little thing.
The Grateful Dead - saw them a bunch live. Jerry's artistry was transcendent, his guitar work was like filigree work, like Leonardo doing all the little fiddly details on the Sistine Chapel's ceiling. From a distance, it averages out to sound just like the song everyone's playing, but up close, there was so much more detail, he was decorating everything fractal-like along the way.
Jimi Hendrix - Jimi's performance of "Red House" from Live at Winterland, is one of my favorite recordings ever (October 11, 1968, 1st show, 11m32s, and yes, it has to be this particular one). SO blues, much slow wailing.
Lady Gaga - Extremely media-savvy, agreed, but instead of just screaming "look at me", she makes herself worth lookng at and listening to. Tons of talent and following in Bowie's glam/fantasy footsteps.
Madonna - Yes, past her prime, but solid musical talent, and had an excellent ability to reinvent herself.
Nine Inch Nails - Best musician-related quote ever - Tori Amos: "Sometimes I think Trent really just needs a cup of hot chocolate and a blankie."
Parliament - Beavis had it right, "Bootsy's COOL!" The judges would have also accepted Victor Wooten, Tony Levin, Phil Lesh, or Geddy Lee.
Santana - Was really phenomenal live, brought an umpteen-piece percussion section.
In other news, I think I might need to marry you.
That Tori Amos quote is fantastic, I'm filing it away in the back of my brain
Also, with Stevie and Jimi in the same list I should have said something about Voodoo Chile. I love both versions but I think Stevie's just slightly edges out Jimi's. I'm going to track down the version of Red House you mentioned.
There are a few folks that are nominally musicians that I like but prefer their spoken word work. Jello Biafra comes to mind too. All I had known of Henry was his work fronting Black Flag and then I saw one of his "Live at XYZ" specials and it opened up a whole new dimension of the guy for me. I've never had the opportunity to see him live in a show but I'd clear my schedule to make it happen.