Personally - didn't enjoy Gears - or any MGS games I've played.
I can't say that I enjoyed Gears myself...it was very bland to me but it sure looked good. MGS is a different story..I love the series even if it goes too far out of reach.
I can't believe this is still going on here...MGS4 is an exclusive to PS3....and if it comes out a year later on the 360 who the hell cares...by that time the game will be worn out.
Bless