Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Comparison of 13 PM sequoia green (with one year patina) vs 14 PM forest green.

The camera cut out is not that much bigger but the 14 PM case is a tight squeeze for the 13 PM and obviously not compatible.
F65B45DC-7C8A-42E2-8E40-C2E55A86A709.jpeg
56E20B8F-2912-45E8-BCFB-801933842C3D.jpeg
6C7F5085-5B8F-49C9-85B6-13BC9544A392.jpeg
 
I ordered the umber cases can you can confirm the case is the same is last year or is it different?
Do you mean the material? Yes it feels and looks the same as last year.

The sequoia green and dark cherry from last year have good patinas. This year's should hopefully behave similarly.
 
Last week I received my new Bullstrap Sienna case (I dropped my phone on the ground and my previous one was damaged so I requested new one and Bullstrap respected the lifetime guarantee). It looks great and the patina process has already began. I am really happy with the case - feels premium.
0EFEF284-8EE8-4141-ACC9-61052DF2F4BE.jpeg
5AB045F5-D22E-447A-89E1-7A9FB05B1A1A.jpeg
C1E92AA0-12CF-41D3-AE3D-3F0692A6D35F.jpeg
380F9AC8-F278-49EE-996A-2DC554DA1386.jpeg
 
Do you mean the material? Yes it feels and looks the same as last year.

The sequoia green and dark cherry from last year have good patinas. This year's should hopefully behave similarly.
Yes the material, I’m pretty excited that since umber looks even darker than saddle brown and especially that nasty golden brown lol it should blend a bit better with the dark corners if worst comes to worst I’ll have to go back to BullStrap. Mine should be arriving tomorrow
 
  • Like
Reactions: Boardiesboi
I see on Bullstrap's website that "Our iPhone cases are eligible for up to two cosmetic replacements per year, subject to Bullstrap’s approval."

So you can just request up to two replacements a year? They just send it for free? Seems too generous...
 
  • Like
Reactions: Daniel Narciso
In my case it just happened like that - I sent them a request, attached a photo of the damaged case and in not more than two hours I received a message that they are sending a new one (without the need to send the old one back to them). Super happy with their service and how they respected the guarantee.
 
In my case it just happened like that - I sent them a request, attached a photo of the damaged case and in not more than two hours I received a message that they are sending a new one (without the need to send the old one back to them). Super happy with their service and how they respected the guarantee.
Thanks for the feedback. I'll give them a try for the 14. Too bad it won't ship until 10/17
 
Bullstrap now has their iPhone 14/Pro/Pro Max cases for pre-order, however as stated above they say they won't ship until October 17th.

As a note, I ordered a leather watch strap from them and it came with a small mark in the leather. Sent them a message as did the poster above, and no questions asked they sent a new one without having the send the old one back.
 
New cases for 14 PM has arrived

Umber seems to be a cross between Arizona and saddle brown.

Forest green seems quite muted and dull and not as vibrant as the one for the 11 PM

Will post some comparison with the 13 PM sequoia green soon.
View attachment 2054198View attachment 2054199
Wow! I think I am more excited by the brown leather case than the phone itself. Can't wait to get mine.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Boardiesboi
It does look nice with gold. I am cautiously optimistic about the patina this year.
Same, just ordered both gold and the apple umber. On another note. I dont think we will see very good patina with the current sharp edges and camera bump of the new phones. I have had the Horween leather platinum base from BB since last years launch. It has decent patina but again its mostly on the corners and metal camera bump. the middle back of the phone really doesn't see enough wear for it to patina evenly like the xs max did with its nice rounded corners and sat flat. That old case is still going strong and the patina is unbelievable at this point in time.
 
Same, just ordered both gold and the apple umber. On another note. I dont think we will see very good patina with the current sharp edges and camera bump of the new phones. I have had the Horween leather platinum base from BB since last years launch. It has decent patina but again its mostly on the corners and metal camera bump. the middle back of the phone really doesn't see enough wear for it to patina evenly like the xs max did with its nice rounded corners and sat flat. That old case is still going strong and the patina is unbelievable at this point in time.
Apple downgraded the leather process so even compared to iPhone 5S leather cases, the 12 and onward Patina horribly by chipping away. It has much more to do with the leather itself than the shape.
 
  • Sad
Reactions: phillytim
Just ordered the 14 Pro. I really want to order the Umbra color but based on past experience I may just do black. I had to move on from leather with my 12 because I couldn't find one I liked. Hopefully that's changed or I'll move on to another Caudabe sheath I guess.
 
Do you mean the material? Yes it feels and looks the same as last year.

The sequoia green and dark cherry from last year have good patinas. This year's should hopefully behave similarly.
Disappointing with the feel. Sounds like will wear the same, like you said. Probably will still order. Like the fit and buttons. They wear really well just not good patina look like before ip12. I would like to see or hear about the cases where people removed the finish. What look like after year or two.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Boardiesboi
How have the black cases aged over the last two years? I love the apple cases but couldn't do that saddle brown woth the 12. I might do black if they hold.up ok.
 
Does Bullstrap have issues with leather wearing thru because thin.
Never heard of that happening. Even if it did they allow cosmetic replacements via their lifetime warranty. The leather is way better than Apples and the edges are slightly more rounded which almost gives it a pre-12 series feel.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Wags
I don’t like the newer Apple leather cases. I had to glue my 12 Pro Max one to the corners of my phone because corners kept popping off in my pocket. Then, after a few months, the case started feeling tacky and gross, even after cleaning. I switched to a Decoded leather MagSafe case and liked it better… corners have never popped off, it never got tacky, and it has held up well for a year and a half. So now that I’m upgrading to the 14 Pro Max, I ordered another Decoded case. Not even going to give the Apple cases another shot.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Forbin1221
I don’t like the newer Apple leather cases. I had to glue my 12 Pro Max one to the corners of my phone because corners kept popping off in my pocket. Then, after a few months, the case started feeling tacky and gross, even after cleaning. I switched to a Decoded leather MagSafe case and liked it better… corners have never popped off, it never got tacky, and it has held up well for a year and a half. So now that I’m upgrading to the 14 Pro Max, I ordered another Decoded case. Not even going to give the Apple cases another shot.
I remember those corners too. I never glued anything down, I just ditched the case.
 
Apple downgraded the leather process so even compared to iPhone 5S leather cases, the 12 and onward Patina horribly by chipping away. It has much more to do with the leather itself than the shape.
Yep I know all about it and That horrible babyshit yellow they had last year as well. That's why I ended up with the horween platinum case which has been great but hard to get a decent patina just due to the shape vs the older rounder devices. It's the shape that makes a big difference.

Here's my old apple xs max leather vs 13 pro max platinum case from BB.
089E5DFE-A79D-40CC-8555-03A9095FDC4E.jpeg
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: JamiLynee
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.