Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
I have never had to show ID for any UPS or FEDEX package I signed for at my office or home. Maybe it depends on your location.

I always try and be at home when expensive items are being delivered because couriers will either try and deliver it to any neighbour if you're not home just so they can say it was delivered.

Also in apartment buildings that share a communal door, the delivery guy is usually too lazy to come upstairs and knock on the right door. They usually just hand it over to the first person they see at the communal door and do not ask for ID.

This is terrible for the OP. Why are people such scumbags.
 
The fault lies with whomever made the first mistake that led to the loss of your laptop. That wasn’t you. That wasn’t Fed Ex. That was definitely Apple, whom you made aware of their mistake and still didn’t correct it. Apple should provide you with a brand new laptop and I would imagine that is what the judge will rule too.

Good luck.
 
My predictions (and they are ONLY my "predictions", take it for what you paid for 'em):

FedEx has no culpability and the OP will get no relief from them.
They did what they are supposed to do -- they received a package from Apple and delivered it to the name and address on the label.

Apple is not going to "freely compensate" the OP (that is, give him a replacement). They are stonewalling because the OP "has culpability" -- he knowingly sent the package to Apple WITH THE WRONG RETURN NAME on the label. Apple will say in its defense, "we repaired the MacBook and returned it to the sender" (i.e., the name on the label).

Small claims court is probably the only "avenue of relief" that -might- be possible here. The best the OP can hope for is that Apple doesn't show up to defend itself (after having been given proper notice), and in that case the OP will then "win by default".
BUT... the OP MUST disclose the facts about the wrong name on the label, and that he sent the package out anyway. Failure to do this will constitute perjury, and the owner could find himself in MUCH more trouble if he tries lyin' to the judge and Apple calls him on it.

My take:
The OP should just go and buy another MacBook.
This will probably result in less time, trouble, and expenditures.
A hard lesson learned.

And NEXT TIME -- BE MORE CAREFUL about sending out a package with somebody else's name on the return label !!

Could the OP have corrected the wrong name on the label. I would have done that. Even with a pen, before I sent it back.
 
The fault lies with whomever made the first mistake that led to the loss of your laptop. That wasn’t you. That wasn’t Fed Ex. That was definitely Apple, whom you made aware of their mistake and still didn’t correct it. Apple should provide you with a brand new laptop and I would imagine that is what the judge will rule too.

Good luck.

Pretty sure FedEx are at some fault here. One of the main parts of delivering high value insured items is knowing where you delivered it to and who you gave it to. If you are delivering it somewhere with multiple addresses you can't just give it to anyone and be done with it on the basis they live in the same block.

If they do that then its their fault if the item goes missing and they can't say who or where they delivered it to. That would be akin to getting to a row of houses and going "any one of these will do, it says number 10 on it but I'll just deliver it to anyone on this street and not note who I gave it to or where they lived".

Apple are at fault for not helping him talk to FedEx but FedEx are the main issue here with what they did with the laptop.
 
Good luck! Looking forward to seeing the outcome (which I imagine will come before the court case)
 
Still not seeing anyone blame the thief...

One mistake does not need to lead to catastrophe.

Had it not been for the thief, even with a mistake by Apple, poor judgement by the OP, and the haste of a FedEx delivery driver, the package would be in the OP's hands.

It's very sad, for sure, but I am betting the judge will rule against the OP, on two factors.

-The laptop was technically stolen, to no fault of any company,
-and the OP's main argument is based on a mistake that he himself identified, and took no measure to correct.

All parties made mistakes that still should have ended in a successful delivery. The determining factor, is the thief, who could have successfully stolen it, even without any mistakes.

This leads me to believe that the only possible thing that could have stopped this, was FedEx having a policy to ID the recipient. Such a measure is unesseacary.

The fault is the thief's, and the thief, alone.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Shanghaichica
Still not seeing anyone blame the thief...

Because the world has plenty of ***** people who will steal, hurt and generally abuse other human beings and we have systems in place to try and prevent this. You pay these companies money to deliver a service and that service includes things like signatures and delivering to the correct person/address.

Had it not been for the thief, even with a mistake by Apple, poor judgement by the OP, and the haste of a FedEx delivery driver, the package would be in the OP's hands.

The thief didn't exactly hatch a master plan to steal the laptop. To twist your words slightly; Had it not been for the UPS driver handing the package over to a random person at the wrong address, even with a mistake by apple, poor judgement by the OP, the package would be in the OPs hands.

Literally the first and most important consideration of a delivery company is where they are delivering a package. You can deliver it to whoever opens the door as long as its the correct address. I have never had a company deliver anything of value to a neighbour without a name, signature and record of the neighbours address for this very reason.

It's very sad, for sure, but I am betting the judge will rule against the OP, on two factors.

-The laptop was technically stolen, to no fault of any company,
-and the OP's main argument is based on a mistake that he himself identified, and took no measure to correct.

All parties made mistakes that still should have ended in a successful delivery. The determining factor, is the thief, who could have successfully stolen it, even without any mistakes.

I'm genuinely astounded that this is your view on this. The laptop was stolen. Right, so FedEx rock up at your apartment building, drop your £3k laptop on the doorstep and are off on their merry way. Someone steals it. Whos fault is that? I mean without a thief you would just have found it when you get home that night?

Tell you what, leave all your doors and windows open when you go on holiday and see if your insurance will pay out. I mean you didn't take any sensible measures to secure your property but thats not your fault, its the criminal who came in and took all your stuff. You have a responsibility to secure your property for your insurance to pay out and FedEx have a responsibility to take reasonable measures to ensure a parcel is delivered to the correct address and person and if they want to leave it with someone else at a different address they need to at least take some information about it.
 
Maybe the FedEx driver was so lazy that he or she simply left it in front of the door and simply forged the signature.
 
Because the world has plenty of ***** people who will steal, hurt and generally abuse other human beings and we have systems in place to try and prevent this. You pay these companies money to deliver a service and that service includes things like signatures and delivering to the correct person/address.



The thief didn't exactly hatch a master plan to steal the laptop. To twist your words slightly; Had it not been for the UPS driver handing the package over to a random person at the wrong address, even with a mistake by apple, poor judgement by the OP, the package would be in the OPs hands.

Literally the first and most important consideration of a delivery company is where they are delivering a package. You can deliver it to whoever opens the door as long as its the correct address. I have never had a company deliver anything of value to a neighbour without a name, signature and record of the neighbours address for this very reason.



I'm genuinely astounded that this is your view on this. The laptop was stolen. Right, so FedEx rock up at your apartment building, drop your £3k laptop on the doorstep and are off on their merry way. Someone steals it. Whos fault is that? I mean without a thief you would just have found it when you get home that night?

Tell you what, leave all your doors and windows open when you go on holiday and see if your insurance will pay out. I mean you didn't take any sensible measures to secure your property but thats not your fault, its the criminal who came in and took all your stuff. You have a responsibility to secure your property for your insurance to pay out and FedEx have a responsibility to take reasonable measures to ensure a parcel is delivered to the correct address and person and if they want to leave it with someone else at a different address they need to at least take some information about it.

Ohhh, right, we have a system in place, therefore it is not the criminal's fault. Gotcha.

OP said it was the correct address, so there's that...

Next, I think it's the responsibility of the recipient to make sure someone is available to pick up the package. If anyone at that particular address could have picked it up, measures should had been taken to prevent it.

Reading in...

Ah, you're astounded... Yay? My view on this differs from yours. Be astounded then. Doesn't change the fact that had it not been for a dishonest thief, this would had not occurred.

This last lart is kind of funny. You seem to be arguing against me, and yourself...

Asside from the contradictions within the final paragraph, I agree. He DOES have a responsibility to secure his stuff. A correct name on the package -as non determining as that was-, and being available for the pickup, or having someone else available or knowledgable on it's arrival would have been great measures to take.

The fact is, the OP is a victim of theft. Based on information givin, it's hardly anyone's fault, BUT THE THIEF'S.

My argument on this is over.

I wish you the best of luck, OP, but I'd put more energy into investigating the tenants and/or their friends, by simply asking around. I don't see how any just judge could put this on a company, other than the fact that they have seemingly endless profits and may as well just fork over another Mac. For any misunderstanding I may have on this, due to limited information, I apologize. Otherwise, maybe next time, and I hope there is none, take the initiative to correct the name and request other measures are taken, if you can not be available. I truely do feel for you, which is why I've even taken the time to read all posts and intended to add to possible solutions. I just don't see that any party made catastrophic mistakes and that the only thing that could have avoided this, was an ID check. Wish you the best, and hope you get your or A Mac back.
 
Last edited:
I've been following this thread for a while now and have two thoughts.

If you have your serial number of the mac, and you can prove that the machine is the one you purchased (they'll also have a record of you returning this for repair very recently), can they not just see where in the world this laptop is and if anyone is using it? I know Apple are huge on privacy, but in a case like this could they not see if another iCloud account was registered to the device?

Also, if you say the address is correct, how has someone else opened your door and taken delivery? Don't you have a specific address to your actual door?
 
I've been following this thread for a while now and have two thoughts.

If you have your serial number of the mac, and you can prove that the machine is the one you purchased (they'll also have a record of you returning this for repair very recently), can they not just see where in the world this laptop is and if anyone is using it? I know Apple are huge on privacy, but in a case like this could they not see if another iCloud account was registered to the device?

Also, if you say the address is correct, how has someone else opened your door and taken delivery? Don't you have a specific address to your actual door?
It may be possible that the delivery driver was so lazy that he or she just dumped it off somewhere and forged the signature.
 
OP said it was the correct address, so there's that...

OP said it was the correct address but never responded to the question about if there was an apartment number or just the building address to then be distributed within the building...
 
It is too bad that the OP was not provided shipment service through USPS since he as the intended recipient could have reported the package theft to the USPS which they would take seriously since stealing USPS mail which includes packages sent through USPS is a federal offense. Willfully misdirecting mail is also a federal offense.
 
Too many random events would have to intersect for this to have just happened. Fedex in my town doesn't give a package to anyone other than at the address, unless there are delivery instructions to do so. Any signature is normal unless again there are restrictions or instructions. Are there Apt numbers or just the house number? Was the Apt number on the shipping label? If it was then your laptop never made it to your door. If it wasn't most likely you have a funky neighbor. A driver wouldn't know it's a converted house. Who is being served at Apple for your court date? Is it your responsibility to serve them? In my state, in small claims court it is.
 
  • Like
Reactions: eltoslightfoot
It would be best if any replacement laptop were to be picked up from a physical store since FedEx clearly is unable to deliver it.
 
Sorry to hear about your loss. Do you have the tracking number? If so, you should be able to look it up and see the signature. I assume that you've checked with all of your neighbors. Did the package make it inside the building? I think that Apple screwed up by having the wrong name on the label but FedEx is ultimately responsible. Good luck and let us know what happens.
 
If shipping errors like this were occur for newly purchased items then Apple could exposed to the risk of thousands of dollars in charge-backs for every instance. Perhaps Apple needs to crack down in cases like this in order to prevent FedEx thieves from being emboldened to steal Apple deliveries more often.
 
Rocko asked in 94 above:
"any updates?"

I'm guessing there may not be any.
I still believe what I wrote in reply 53 will be what happens.

The OP may or may not go to small claims court.
If he does, his chances of relief there... well, they ain't that great.

So... ultimately... the OP will just have to go buy a new one, and chalk his mistake up to experience...

(I wouldn't mind being proven wrong...)
 
Alright, the small claims court hearing was today. I should receive a judgment within 2 weeks.

Apple sent a very nice store manager from a nearby Apple store to represent them. Clearly she did not have very good legal understanding of the problem, but at least she was a very nice person. I was offered a settlement of $1,000 just before the trial, and I think her authority was capped at that sum since there were no chance to negotiate up by even a penny.

The judgment depends on the point whether or not Apple is at fault due to the wrong name on the label.
 
Wishing good fortunes on you. A trillion dollar company can afford to pony up in this case. If my extremely small percentage of stock ( 0.0000000108 company owner ) had any pull, I'd be writing the man for you.
 
  • Like
Reactions: green86
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.