stonyc said:I was talking this one over with my wife, and I like this idea a lot.
Maybe the other camp of survivors (from the tail section) descended into a "Lord of the Flies" situation, where civilized society and behavior became secondary to surivival. Maybe the only the reason the original survivors (Jack, et al) didn't fall into the same sort of situation was because of a strong leader and people with skills available to help keep them alive and more comfortable.
I really like that theory that Walt is being held by the actual Others (who Ethan and blackbeard, etc. came from) and that these captors are actually the other survivors from the crash who developed a more primitive society than our other survivors did.
this is what I was sugesting a few posts up, only not as well described