After scanning through everything the only App I think is fairly priced and would have bought is iPhoto. (but I already have iLife 11)
Many of the programs are simply overpriced. Many of the free programs are "lite" or require you to pay one way or another. Of course people need to make money, I just have an issue with things being advertised as free when they are not.
Aperture may also be a good value at $79, but I just got Adobe Elements 9 for $40
Maybe there will be better Apps and prices in the future.
Apple is know for their expertise in keeping things simple. I see these App stores as getting to be overwhelming and out of control.
I don't know how they will do it, but I think at some point, they will have to scale back.
I disagree with everything you typed, right down to your conclusion. The app store prices are reasonable, if not downright cheap (in many cases). Aperture 3 is a far better program than Photoshop Elements 9, and the Mac App Store is going to be HUGELY successful and will continue to grow and flourish.
You must be related to Steve Ballmer, who predicted the iPhone would be an utter failure.
Mark