Re: Being gay hurts society
Fortunately I don't have to make a drawn out response to your post, because my new friends here aren't buying it, in fact they seem rather opposed to your ideas. I do want to touch on a couple of things tho:
1. How can being gay be bad for the genetic composition of humanity? you pointed out, so eloquently, that we cannot reproduce. The only natural way for a gay man to reproduce is for him to marry a woman who he will not love. That's got to be good for women everywhere, right?
2. The fall of Rome, eh? What about every other nation that embraced homosexuality? Let's look at Florence, Italy, circa late 1400's. Birth of the rennaisance, rebirth of the arts. Almost every stylish man (I'm talking straight here) took on young boy protogés, and raped them constantly. That wasn't even homosexuality, just desperate sodomy, and Italy certainly didn't fall. Greece is a good example as well, as the gays there lived a (somewhat) open life for the last 1000 years. Ever heard of the Isle of Lesbos? And Greece is still a healthy functioning part of the world. The fall of Rome was because of an extreme inbalance in the social structure, to dramatically oversimplify.
3. Gay people are horrible for morality... Okay, lets say I agree. The following people have had a detrimental impact on society:
Leonardo DaVinci. Elanor Roosevelt, Rosie O'Donell, Michalangelo. Sir Ian McKellan, Emily Di¢kenson, Florence Nightingale, Sir Frances Bacon. Susan B. Anthony, Herman Melville, Nathaniel Hawthorne. Willa Cather, Walt Whitman, Greta Garbo. Liberace, Aaron Copeland, Andy Warhol, Amelia Earhart, Elton John, k. d. lang, Lily Tomlin.
Need I continue?
I'm sure God compares these people to theives, cutthroats, and whatever else you likened us to.
Yes, I've known gay people that I wouldn't wish on anyone. I have been in love with, among others, a self-destructor and a sociopath. You know what's sad about the self-destructor, tho? All his suicide attempts, his unhealthy lifestyle (I'm not *just* talking casual sex here)... It's because he had a mother just like you.
I'm not trying to change your mind here. Once a zealot is affirmed, they will never falter. But keep this in mind the next time someone you love comes out, before you destroy all he has worked so hard to accept himself. I hope you never have children to spread this rhetoric to.
pnw
Originally posted by agreenster
I get really tired of this one. Whenever straight people say "I dont mind that people are gay. As long as they dont hurt anyone else, who cares?" -this really bothers me.
Fortunately I don't have to make a drawn out response to your post, because my new friends here aren't buying it, in fact they seem rather opposed to your ideas. I do want to touch on a couple of things tho:
1. How can being gay be bad for the genetic composition of humanity? you pointed out, so eloquently, that we cannot reproduce. The only natural way for a gay man to reproduce is for him to marry a woman who he will not love. That's got to be good for women everywhere, right?
2. The fall of Rome, eh? What about every other nation that embraced homosexuality? Let's look at Florence, Italy, circa late 1400's. Birth of the rennaisance, rebirth of the arts. Almost every stylish man (I'm talking straight here) took on young boy protogés, and raped them constantly. That wasn't even homosexuality, just desperate sodomy, and Italy certainly didn't fall. Greece is a good example as well, as the gays there lived a (somewhat) open life for the last 1000 years. Ever heard of the Isle of Lesbos? And Greece is still a healthy functioning part of the world. The fall of Rome was because of an extreme inbalance in the social structure, to dramatically oversimplify.
3. Gay people are horrible for morality... Okay, lets say I agree. The following people have had a detrimental impact on society:
Leonardo DaVinci. Elanor Roosevelt, Rosie O'Donell, Michalangelo. Sir Ian McKellan, Emily Di¢kenson, Florence Nightingale, Sir Frances Bacon. Susan B. Anthony, Herman Melville, Nathaniel Hawthorne. Willa Cather, Walt Whitman, Greta Garbo. Liberace, Aaron Copeland, Andy Warhol, Amelia Earhart, Elton John, k. d. lang, Lily Tomlin.
Need I continue?
I'm sure God compares these people to theives, cutthroats, and whatever else you likened us to.
Yes, I've known gay people that I wouldn't wish on anyone. I have been in love with, among others, a self-destructor and a sociopath. You know what's sad about the self-destructor, tho? All his suicide attempts, his unhealthy lifestyle (I'm not *just* talking casual sex here)... It's because he had a mother just like you.
I'm not trying to change your mind here. Once a zealot is affirmed, they will never falter. But keep this in mind the next time someone you love comes out, before you destroy all he has worked so hard to accept himself. I hope you never have children to spread this rhetoric to.
pnw