Yup like when I watched Mandela walk out of prison accompanied by a huge crowd including his then wife Winnie.
As for the rest of this thread:
Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Mandela Effect
- Thread starter Project Alice
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
As for the rest of this thread:
Yup like when I watched Mandela walk out of prison accompanied by a huge crowd including his then wife Winnie.
As for the rest of this thread:
should you desire to expand on your narrow mind
one needn't look further than johnemmett.com
I did take a look at ...that which you had linked...(albeit against my better judgment).
By the bleeding nails of Christ......
And the twenty four spherical objects of the twelve apostles.....
Oh, my.
Ouch.
There is a Mandela effect I have come across roughly two years ago involving the song "Amerika" by Rammstein. It could have certainly happened before this, but two years ago was when I distinctly noticed the change. I am hoping that I can find corroboration or evidence to the contrary here.
Between Fall of 2010 and Spring of 2011 I remember vividly discussing the song with a good friend who was in the same college type class. "Amerika" had a notable and very distinct key change during the last chorus where it dropped a whole step down and continued the last chorus in a new, lower key after the bridge with the guitar solo and synth.
To clarify, we were and are, both musical and have a good deal of musical experience.
Two years ago I listened to Amerika again and was perplexed to find that the distinct key change was barely even noticeable. I wasn't in the mood at the time to think too much on it and blew it off at the time.
This week I re listened to the song again and jumped back and forth multiple times between the the first chorus, the last, and each one in between. There was no key change at all, anywhere in the song. Not in the official video, not the official audio, not a live performance, nothing. So far I haven't found anything via a google search.
I messaged my friend this morning whom I remember discussing the song with. He also remembered Amerika having a key change (To clarify, he couldn't remember if it was the middle or last chorus, but he distincntly remembers it having a key change after the bridge).
My roommate remembers the song having a key change as well.
Does anyone else have a similar experience?
Thank you
TLDR
"Amerika" by Rammstein had a key change in the song that is no longer there.
Between Fall of 2010 and Spring of 2011 I remember vividly discussing the song with a good friend who was in the same college type class. "Amerika" had a notable and very distinct key change during the last chorus where it dropped a whole step down and continued the last chorus in a new, lower key after the bridge with the guitar solo and synth.
To clarify, we were and are, both musical and have a good deal of musical experience.
Two years ago I listened to Amerika again and was perplexed to find that the distinct key change was barely even noticeable. I wasn't in the mood at the time to think too much on it and blew it off at the time.
This week I re listened to the song again and jumped back and forth multiple times between the the first chorus, the last, and each one in between. There was no key change at all, anywhere in the song. Not in the official video, not the official audio, not a live performance, nothing. So far I haven't found anything via a google search.
I messaged my friend this morning whom I remember discussing the song with. He also remembered Amerika having a key change (To clarify, he couldn't remember if it was the middle or last chorus, but he distincntly remembers it having a key change after the bridge).
My roommate remembers the song having a key change as well.
Does anyone else have a similar experience?
Thank you
TLDR
"Amerika" by Rammstein had a key change in the song that is no longer there.
Last edited:
I remember the hat size how it was depicted in the clip.
But, I guess some people are remembering it a lot smaller.
Geography is tricky when it comes to memory, especially if it is an area that one isn't too familiar with.
I look at Google Earth frequently…
I saw New Zealand a week before the shift
New Zealand shifted, perhaps I did
I saw New Zealand a week before the shift
New Zealand shifted, perhaps I did
Last edited:
You saying to remember something a certain way is true as long as you aren't lying, but whether or not that actually happened could be false. Just like if I argue about what I heard, I will always say I heard you say ABC, not you said ABC. It's always possible I heard them wrong or they didn't say what they meant.I’m referring to what I have observe. Aren’t memories factual?
And I continue to observe deception daily in American Politics, although this would not be technically part of the Mandella Effect, although the ME could be used as a deception strategy to help convince citizens that Trump really won the popular vote. Hence my comment.
this is not misremembering, this much we know
the evidence is overwhelming
you can check …
the evidence is overwhelming
you can check …
Last edited:
I’m just saying if that is how you remember it, then you’d consider your memories to be true, while acknowleging you might not have an accurate memory about a certain event.
Elizabeth Loftus
Podcast Episode · The Origins Podcast with Lawrence Krauss · 01/13/2020 · 1h 29m
podcasts.apple.com
Elizabeth F. Loftus – UCI School of Social Ecology
UCI School of Social Ecology
memory is reliable, that's what it's for
you rely on memory, everyone relies on it
you rely on memory, everyone relies on it
Last edited:
Absolutely, but also - our brains create false memories all the time...
Memory is NOT reliable
Healthline Mental Well-Being
Your complete guide to better mental well-being. Learn about mindfulness, self-care, parenting, mental health conditions, therapy, and so much more.
www.healthline.com
Photos can be edited and even fabricated from pure fantasy. Just like memories.
Just like the so called mandela effect.
what I find interesting is you can't accept the truth
because it's too far beyond the mundane
because it's too far beyond the mundane
Last edited:
I accept the fact that I can be wrong about many things. While there may be a few exceptional individuals in the world with flawless memory, the fact is that for most people memory is not reliable and even less so as time passes.
What's far more interesting is that you can't seem to accept the fact that you could be wrong.
What's far more interesting is that you can't seem to accept the fact that you could be wrong.