Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Terrible timing for me. I was planning to switch to iTunes billing in the next few weeks to start saving. Oh well these things happen
 
Everything has a cost. Literal cost or opportunity cost. We’ll see if Netflix changes their tune once they start losing customers from Apple’s ecosystem. And the streaming market competition really heats up and they have to start fighting for subscribers.

I think Netflix would have to lose 15+% of their iOS subscribers in order to make the outcome net negative. It looks like they already ran it as an experiment, and I assume they determined that it was worth it. That jibes with what my hypothesis would be as well; I don't see 15+% of Apple users ditching Netflix simply due to billing. iOS users should be pretty familiar with this song and dance by now, anyway. Netflix is hardly the only company doing this.
 
Pretty “funny” about the comments on the in-app purchases where as consumers why would we even care about a Netflix and apple agreement when we are not affected?
 
Last edited:
I think Netflix would have to lose 15+% of their iOS subscribers in order to make the outcome net negative. It looks like they already ran it as an experiment, and I assume they determined that it was worth it. That jibes with what my hypothesis would be as well; I don't see 15+% of Apple users ditching Netflix simply due to billing. iOS users should be pretty familiar with this song and dance by now, anyway. Netflix is hardly the only company doing this.
Issue isn’t people leaving. It’s whether as many new people will sign up.

Personally I always choose iTunes billing when available because a lot of these services (not so much Netflix) make cancelling very difficult, and with iTunes billing you never have that issue. Also fewer accounts to get hacked :)
 
  • Like
Reactions: LinusR
This is disappointing. I dumped Netflix. As I only subscribe when certain shows like stranger things and others come out. But I liked the convenience of automatically logging in. And also I would buy iTunes cards at a discount and used that to pay for my Netflix subscription. Now I cannot do either.
 
  • Like
Reactions: LinusR and DIRSGT
it's kind of hard to "miss a point" when you don't really have one.

Apple charges commission for selling apps and content on their App Store platform - it's been that way since the day App Store opened. Their subscription commission model where they charge 30% for the first 12 months, and then drop it to just 15% is quite reasonable by most measures.

What exactly are you proposing? That Apple charge 0% commission for using their app hosting and payment platform? It's not going to happen. Your griping is just a waste of space.

Yes. Clearly you have absolutely no idea what you're talking about.
 
I disagree with you. Netflix wouldn't have the reach if it wasn't for Apple, a fee should be paid to the exposure each of these companies are having. Apple has made Netflix billions with it's over 1 billion activated devices around the globe, this is all about greed and just watch, Netflix will increase their fees in 2019 even though they're saving 10's of millions.
Actually, Netflix wouldn't have had the reach it has if it wasn't for Roku, from almost a decade ago.

iPhone and iPad acccess is nice, but it's really brining streaming to the big tv screen that makes the difference

Music services, I agree, it's all apple and mobile phones
 
  • Like
Reactions: Michael Scrip
We're all familiar with Apple's 30% cut from a purchased app. We know it takes money to run the App Store, process payments, bandwidth, etc. And the industry standard seems to be 30% on other apps stores.

What people are questioning is Apple's continuing cut each and every month from a 3rd-party service.

Even if Apple only takes 15% from a subscription purchased through the App Store... that's still a hell of a lot of money from a $12.99 charge every month.

Should it require $1.95 a month, per account, to allow Netflix on Apple devices? That seems a little high.

On the other hand... some people like the fact that they can let Apple handle all their subscriptions in one place. Whether it's for convenience, or safety/privacy, I see why it's desirable. In that case... I can understand paying an extra $2 for that comfort.

I wonder how many of Netflix's 137 million users are actually subscribed through Apple... and thus will be affected by this?

I've had a Netflix subscription for a long time. I registered through the Netflix website. In fact... I prefer to sign-up and subscribe to services directly with the company. But that's me.
 
Last edited:
Apple needs to charge less. I hope more big content providers do this to send a message

No, it should not charge a penny less. Apple has created a platform for developers to use their skills, create apps and make money. And it is gigantic work of many many years and for years developers have profited from this (with Apple taking it's cut of course)
What Netflix did makes complete sense. Netflix does have the money and ability to put themselves now on any platform out there (including smart TV's, consoles, tablets, and whatnot) and it does not need to rely on Apple. But Netflix is one of the very few who can break free of iTunes 30% cut. I say good for Netflix.
 
No, it should not charge a penny less. Apple has created a platform for developers to use their skills, create apps and make money. And it is gigantic work of many many years and for years developers have profited from this (with Apple taking it's cut of course)
What Netflix did makes complete sense. Netflix does have the money and ability to put themselves now on any platform out there (including smart TV's, consoles, tablets, and whatnot) and it does not need to rely on Apple. But Netflix is one of the very few who can break free of iTunes 30% cut. I say good for Netflix.

I agree. Netflix is an ubiquitous household name. No set top or tv manufacturer today would dare release something without Netflix packaged in it. Apple was the same when they released ATV4. They needed Netflix on it.
 
There is a lot of talk here about getting iTunes gift cards at a discount that can be used to pay for things like Netflix.

But since it costs an extra $3/mo if you subscribe through iTunes instead of Netflix directly... are you really saving money?

I haven't run the numbers... it was just a quick question that popped into my mind.

EDIT: I was wrong about the extra cost subscribing through iTunes! :p
 
Last edited:
There is a lot of talk here about getting iTunes gift cards at a discount that can be used to pay for things like Netflix.

But since it costs an extra $3/mo if you subscribe through iTunes instead of Netflix directly... are you really saving money?

I haven't run the numbers... it was just a quick question that popped into my mind. :p

There is also the time and effort needed to procure and apply the gift cards. Perhaps time is not money to those people :)
 
  • Like
Reactions: Michael Scrip
Who cares what Apple deserves? As a consumer, this was an easy way to save 10-20% on a Netflix subscription by buying discounted iTunes credit.
My subscription is still billed through iTunes. Should Netflix decide to cancel that, they're going to lose me as a customer.

I am glad Netflix decided to do this. This year I wanted to upgrade to a subscription with UHD. Forget it when you're billed via iTunes. You have to cancel, wait for a couple of weeks, then re-subscribe. When you paid via Netflix directly, it's a simple click on their site.

Not sure where all the hate comes from. I have never seen discounted iTunes cards here in the Netherlands.
 
There is a lot of talk here about getting iTunes gift cards at a discount that can be used to pay for things like Netflix.

But since it costs an extra $3/mo if you subscribe through iTunes instead of Netflix directly... are you really saving money?

I haven't run the numbers... it was just a quick question that popped into my mind. :p
I think you are confusing Netflix with spotify. With Netflix, it costs the same whether you subscribe through iTunes or directly to Netflix. Netflix simply eats the loss if you choose to do it through iTunes.

With Spotify, they have to pass the costs on to the consumer because they already pay 70% of revenue to labels. 30% cut to Apple, 70% to labels, it doesn't take a maths genius to see why this wouldn't be sustainable.
 
  • Like
Reactions: FriendlyMackle
Every iOS dev, including Netflix pays apple a yearly developer fee.
Yeah, what is it, $100? Ha.

I’m guessing that goes toward developing dev tools and App Kit, not managing millions of downloads, payments and updates. Could be wrong, that’s just a guess. But $100 is nothing.
[doublepost=1546073334][/doublepost]
I think Netflix would have to lose 15+% of their iOS subscribers in order to make the outcome net negative. It looks like they already ran it as an experiment, and I assume they determined that it was worth it. That jibes with what my hypothesis would be as well; I don't see 15+% of Apple users ditching Netflix simply due to billing. iOS users should be pretty familiar with this song and dance by now, anyway. Netflix is hardly the only company doing this.
The (false) market Netflix has jury-rigged favors them heavily right now. Maybe they’ll pull off a trick like Amazon and wind up turning a profit and maintaining huge market share. Or maybe they won’t and their House of Cards (double entendre untended) will collapse. My guess is that when the competition in the streaming market heats up, they’ll be looking for every customer they can get. It’ll be fascinating to see how it plays out.
[doublepost=1546073828][/doublepost]
You tell em’ Tim.
Please, name another tech or media company that is more innovative, provides more long term value for consumers (TCO), has higher quality ratings and consumer satisfaction, and is as well designed and easy to use. Name one. I’m all ears.
 
Netflix along with many other providers don’t pay 30% to Apple. Apple actively promotes Netflix in the iOS and tvOS App Store and TV app. So why shouldn’t a company like apple that has cultivated such a massive user base, not charge for access to it?

Hey Roku charges Netflix to have their name on a dedicated button their remote. Nothing is free
Like TV smart remotes with Netflix buttons on their remotes, along with Amazon Prime. So how much all these companies get on a monthly basis?
 
I think you are confusing Netflix with spotify. With Netflix, it costs the same whether you subscribe through iTunes or directly to Netflix. Netflix simply eats the loss if you choose to do it through iTunes.

Whoops! Thanks for the correction. :p
 
But what Netflix is doing now is freeloading. Using the resources of AppStore to seemlessly deliver their app and it’s updates to their customers without paying a dime. That ain’t cool.
You mean like the way I can download and update Netflix from the Google Play store, or our LG smart TV, or our PS4. What is it I pay to them for this?
[doublepost=1546075990][/doublepost]
Imagine they pull their app entirely from the App Store. It would probably hurt Apple more than it does Netflix at this point.
And what is your specialist subject on Mastermind? Stating the bleeding obvious? :)
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.