Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Am I correct in reading the description as it's going to have a screen protector you have to apply with adhesive? (rather than the defender where it's built into the case itself, no adhesive involved?).

I was really hoping this case was going to be a less insanely massive version of the defender, ie full-body protection without adhesive but without the clip and less bulky overall... but if this is yet another back/sides only case that adds a glue-on screen protector I'm gonna have to keep looking :(

The screen protector is likely a film that is applied before the other parts of the case - at least that's how the Moto Droid's Commuter worked.

Not sure what you're looking for here. If you want a integrated screen protector you're going to get some more bulk - aka Ballistic case or Otterbox Defender.

The commuter is the happy-medium case for those of us that don't work on roof tops, farms, dusty environments, swamps, etc.
 
I couldn't help a quick PS mockup! My ideal OB iP4 Commuter case :D
 

Attachments

  • otterip4green.jpg
    otterip4green.jpg
    59.5 KB · Views: 131
I'd like more of a Dallas Cowboy's Blue on black motif personally. :cool:
 
The screen protector is likely a film that is applied before the other parts of the case - at least that's how the Moto Droid's Commuter worked.

Not sure what you're looking for here. If you want a integrated screen protector you're going to get some more bulk - aka Ballistic case or Otterbox Defender.


Not at all... I had a Griffin Wave for the iphone 3G... non-adhesive screen protector that was held in place by the frame of the case, and it was not bulky at all...

THAT is exactly what I'm looking for...a hard case with a non-adhesive screen protector that isn't bulky.

But nobody seems to make one for the iphone 4 :(
 
Waiting. Defender is too thick. I need something that won't look like a book in my pocket, yet provides adequate drop protection.

I'm waiting on this case, too, for the same reason. I ride horses and do a lot of farm work, so I need something that offers solid drop protection. But I also need something that covers the ports, which is one thing this case offers over many others the same size. It doesn't have to be waterproof, but not having to pick crud out of the ports would be nice. I don't want to have to switch cases every time I do something, and the Defender is too bulky for my tastes. The Commuter case looks like it provides that kind of balance between overkill and protection. The adhesive screen protector doesn't bother me if it's quality. If not, I'll order the powercrystal ones.

Right now I'm using a case-mate Vroom with their crappy screen protector. After many attempts, I finally got the screen protector down well enough that it's not a distraction. The case itself isn't bad, but it doesn't fit very snug and the silicone is a lint-magnet. But overall, it's better than nothing and has made the phone more comfortable. I bought it mainly for drop protection, as I was not experiencing the signal issue.

BTW, the other Otter case (Impact Series) still looks like a render... or someone flipped an image.... or it's a "European" iPhone. lol! All of the images show the volume buttons on the RIGHT side of the phone... but the apps are in the normal/default order.
 
Am I correct in reading the description as it's going to have a screen protector you have to apply with adhesive? (rather than the defender where it's built into the case itself, no adhesive involved?).

I was really hoping this case was going to be a less insanely massive version of the defender, ie full-body protection without adhesive but without the clip and less bulky overall... but if this is yet another back/sides only case that adds a glue-on screen protector I'm gonna have to keep looking :(

No adhesive. Just put the phone in the hard plastic inner shell and then the rubber outer shell fits over. The screen, iphone emblem, and cameras are all covered for protection within the inner shell. It doesn't feel bulky at all.
 
Pre-order is available on on Amazon.com ... says "This item will be released on August 3, 2010."

See:
http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B0...&pf_rd_t=101&pf_rd_p=470938811&pf_rd_i=507846

Or:
http://tinyurl.com/24vjcmo

Cheapest price is $27.47 + Free Shipping from "Beach Camera", which is an Amazon merchant with a 96% rating. But Amazon guarantees purchases from Amazon Marketplace, Auctions, zShops, and Merchant sellers.

OR, you can buy straight from Amazon.com
$32.06 & ships for FREE with Super Saver Shipping

List price on Otterbox.com is $34.95
 
As an Amazon Associate, MacRumors earns a commission from qualifying purchases made through links in this post.
Pre-order is available on on Amazon.com ... says "This item will be released on August 3, 2010."

See:
http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B0...&pf_rd_t=101&pf_rd_p=470938811&pf_rd_i=507846

Or:
http://tinyurl.com/24vjcmo

Cheapest price is $27.47 + Free Shipping from "Beach Camera", which is an Amazon merchant with a 96% rating. But Amazon guarantees purchases from Amazon Marketplace, Auctions, zShops, and Merchant sellers.

OR, you can buy straight from Amazon.com
$32.06 & ships for FREE with Super Saver Shipping

List price on Otterbox.com is $34.95

Thanks for the link!

I just placed an order at Amazon with Beach Camera ($27.47 + Free Shipping). I bought stuff from Beach Camera before. They are a legit company, and they have been around for many years.
 
As an Amazon Associate, MacRumors earns a commission from qualifying purchases made through links in this post.
Pre-order is available on on Amazon.com ... says "This item will be released on August 3, 2010."

See:
http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B0...&pf_rd_t=101&pf_rd_p=470938811&pf_rd_i=507846

Or:
http://tinyurl.com/24vjcmo

Cheapest price is $27.47 + Free Shipping from "Beach Camera", which is an Amazon merchant with a 96% rating. But Amazon guarantees purchases from Amazon Marketplace, Auctions, zShops, and Merchant sellers.

OR, you can buy straight from Amazon.com
$32.06 & ships for FREE with Super Saver Shipping

List price on Otterbox.com is $34.95

Much thanks for the heads up. I ordered from Amazon as I am a Prime member so I get free 2 day shipping.
 
As an Amazon Associate, MacRumors earns a commission from qualifying purchases made through links in this post.
Bummer

Well, I put it off too long waiting to hear from a friend, and the $27 Beach Camera deal is no longer posted on Amazon. :(

The Amazon.com $32.06 (+free shipping) is still on the tabled, but I'm thinking with that Otterbox.com coupon code, if it stll works when the commuter is released for sale, is probably a better deal.

Mike
 
Well, I put it off too long waiting to hear from a friend, and the $27 Beach Camera deal is no longer posted on Amazon. :(

The Amazon.com $32.06 (+free shipping) is still on the tabled, but I'm thinking with that Otterbox.com coupon code, if it stll works when the commuter is released for sale, is probably a better deal.

Mike

Just a thought, whatever allotment Amazon is going to get is going to be somewhat limited. Pre-ordering keeps your place in line ....
 
I found a seller on ebay that has a shipment coming in this week (or so they say) so I went ahead and bought one. I don't have my phone yet, so hopefully the case will come in at the same time or shortly after I get my phone.

http://cgi.ebay.com/Otterbox-iPhone-4-Commuter-Case-/170516252979?cmd=ViewItem&pt=PDA_Accessories&hash=item27b38f8933

I'm not sure why negative feedback was left for them already, I received an email shortly after purchasing that they are getting the shipment in and the case would be sent out then. I knew that when I bought it. The seller has responded to both of my questions I had in a decent amount of time.
 
No adhesive. Just put the phone in the hard plastic inner shell and then the rubber outer shell fits over. The screen, iphone emblem, and cameras are all covered for protection within the inner shell. It doesn't feel bulky at all.

FYI this is incorrect... I emailed otterbox and they stated the commuter screen protector is a self-adhesive one
 
Shipping on Amazon just updated to 3-5 weeks. I wonder if its b/c they sold out of their presales allotment or if the case is actually delayed more.

???
 
does anyone on here know from experience or other means if the otterbox commuter will work with an invisible shield?
 
does anyone on here know from experience or other means if the otterbox commuter will work with an invisible shield?

It should work, the commuter case comes with an otterbox screen protector; just don't use their screen protector and keep your invisible shield on.
 
does anyone on here know from experience or other means if the otterbox commuter will work with an invisible shield?

It should work just fine. The Commuter will include its own film - just don't use it and keep what you have.
 
just ordered my commuter on amazon, pre-order from beach camera
they say it releases on august 3rd

if i don't like it, i'll go for the showcase that's coming out
 
just ordered my commuter on amazon, pre-order from beach camera
they say it releases on august 3rd

if i don't like it, i'll go for the showcase that's coming out

Me, too... I still had the link open at home, so I was able to order at the $27 price w/free shipping. The email I got quoted that it would ship between August 5th and 7th. If I don't like it, I'll just use the Speck Pixelskin HD that Apple is giving me. :cool:
 
Got a updated email from my Amazon pre-order. They state delivery between September 1 - 21. :eek:
 
Got a updated email from my Amazon pre-order. They state delivery between September 1 - 21. :eek:

did you order it from amazon or beachcamera?

this is what it says from my beachcamera order

Shipping Soon
Delivery Estimate: August 6, 2010 - August 10, 2010
 
did you order it from amazon or beachcamera?

this is what it says from my beachcamera order

Shipping Soon
Delivery Estimate: August 6, 2010 - August 10, 2010

Ordered thru Amazon. Originally Amazon had the same ship window, but they updated late last night to this.

I wonder if Beach is going to do the same thing?
 
Ordered thru Amazon. Originally Amazon had the same ship window, but they updated late last night to this.

I wonder if Beach is going to do the same thing?

they won't... otterbox can't only release the defender. plus, beach is still expecting the shipment on august 3rd. my guess is that amazon, as weird as it would be, wasn't able to get in on the first shipment
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.