Went in today to try again and was met with another "Analyst Review". I asked the Apple rep to only talk to CORe due to the previous troubles. Half way through speaking to CORe the Apple rep was told that I have 26 pending activations. I asked to take the call and see why they keep sharing my account info. It turns out these were not pending activations, they were pending applications. Speaking with CORe I asked for more detail and found out this was not a case of my AOL shenanigans being exposed. Based on the dates and times, these "applications" came from every time I got to the final purchase screen at Apple.com and was met with the "sorry something went wrong" message. Likely due to phone being out of stock. Anyway in the end CORe asked for my permission to delete the pending apps which I approved. Then the Apple rep hit the button again and the new phone was mine. Should be smooth sailing for the next phones.
I had the same problem last week. You'll have same problem until those pending activations get killed. It takes me few days till it clears.
I don't do online orders anymore. Every time you get error or cancellation, you leave more pending application.