The hate on this site for pebble and its products is just bizarre. No doubt the same people will be glossing over the Apple Watch's shortcomings when it is released. Don't get me wrong, I'm looking forward to seeing how Cupertino's offering ends up working in day to day use and will likely buy one, but I am under no illusions that battery life will be somehow mystically longer than other smart watches that have gone the high power and touchscreen route.
I have been a pebble backer since the launch edition, then bought a steel, and have now backed the Time too - I think they are great little devices and the importance of the fact that the battery can last days between charges cannot be underestimated. Sure most days I do charge it overnight, but if I go away on a trip or visit friends overnight etc, being safe in the knowledge my watch will keep going till I'm next home is very useful. I won't be surprised if on some longer days the Apple Watch doesn't quite make it all the way through till the end of the night, and that will be a major downside.
Guess it just comes down to what compromises you are willing to make, and I for one am pretty happy with pebble's designs and feature sets.
I tend to agree with you. Individual wants/needs are different, and I think there is a good sized market for a sporty thin budget (less than $100) "smart watch" that tells time (alarms, stopwatch, etc), records steps, and displays basic notifications (email, text, calendar, reminders) with 5 day battery life. I am not sure if this type of product is on market yet, but it should be feasible pretty soon.
Personally and for my needs, I have a hard time justifying $350+ for a smart watch (which will become obsolete in a few years) that requires frequent charging and that requires I carry my iPhone to perform most of the advanced functionality. If I need to carry my phone anyway, I would rather have something inexpensive, simple, lightweight with longer battery life that provides notifications, and then if I need to reply to a message, I'll just remove my phone from my pocket.....which is what I currently do now.
A smart phone was a game changer that significantly altered the way people do things because it provides almost unlimited access to information and opportunities for communication anywhere you can get a cell connection. A smart watch is more of an accessory that adds some convenience, but does not add much functionality if you already own a smart phone. And, you must own a smart phone to utilize most of the important features of a smart watch.
I think one exception to the above would be some of the health monitors (i.e. pulse). There might be folks willing to pay for the convenience of constant monitoring. However, most people (even active athletic people) really don't need this type of data to get a good workout or meet their fitness goals.