Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
I was about to get a cosmetic blemish refurb, but because I couldn't find any info about what "cosmetically blemished" actually entailed, I just went with the normal refurb. It isn't worth the possibility of having a beat up phone to save 20 bucks imo.
 
omg... someone that actually comprehended my simple OP (i thought i made it pretty clear.) thanks for showing me that someone on the board isn't hearing what they wanna hear. :D

I work for AT&T in a management position and the phones they order for us are from this refurbished stock. I can tell you that the descriptions they provide are worst case scenario. You aren't going to get a phone that looks like someone slid it across the parking lot.
 
I work for AT&T in a management position and the phones they order for us are from this refurbished stock. I can tell you that the descriptions they provide are worst case scenario. You aren't going to get a phone that looks like someone slid it across the parking lot.

when you mean refurbished stock you're talking about the cosmetically blemished phones right? i'm hearing that lots of people are getting phones that are good as new... and others that have dings and dents. seems like a dice roll.
 
I was about to get a cosmetic blemish refurb, but because I couldn't find any info about what "cosmetically blemished" actually entailed, I just went with the normal refurb. It isn't worth the possibility of having a beat up phone to save 20 bucks imo.

why would anyone save 20$ for a cosmetically blemished phone?? :eek:

Also I saw one of the previous posts and I hope the OP doesn't get the one that so beaten up like that, thats just ugly, even if it works perfect.
 
why would anyone save 20$ for a cosmetically blemished phone?? :eek:

Also I saw one of the previous posts and I hope the OP doesn't get the one that so beaten up like that, thats just ugly, even if it works perfect.

yeah. i would spend the 20bucks more get a strictly refurbed one, but they didn't have any on the att site. comonnnnn lady luck! i need you right now!
 
when you mean refurbished stock you're talking about the cosmetically blemished phones right? i'm hearing that lots of people are getting phones that are good as new... and others that have dings and dents. seems like a dice roll.

The phones we choose from are refurbs and are broken down by condition. More cosmetically blemished is cheaper. I usually get stuff in the middle grade and it looks new to me. I'd imagine the low grade has minor scratches and stuff, maybe a ding.
 
yippy! just got the phone and theres not a mark on it.

edit: oh, nm. 2 or 3 small... TINY scratches on the back. i'll take pictures when i come home from work.

edit 2: just check the warranty with apple. turns out this phone also has applecare. WIN!
 
Last edited:
What's stopping people from buying cosmetically-blemished refurbs for cheap, then going into an Apple store and claiming that they've been having problems with, say the headphone jack, and getting it replaced with a brand new refurb?
 
What's stopping people from buying cosmetically-blemished refurbs for cheap, then going into an Apple store and claiming that they've been having problems with, say the headphone jack, and getting it replaced with a brand new refurb?

I thought those blemished phones only had a 90 day warranty or something.
 
What's stopping people from buying cosmetically-blemished refurbs for cheap, then going into an Apple store and claiming that they've been having problems with, say the headphone jack, and getting it replaced with a brand new refurb?

i'd think proving that you have an issue is the problem with that idea.
 
What's stopping people from buying cosmetically-blemished refurbs for cheap, then going into an Apple store and claiming that they've been having problems with, say the headphone jack, and getting it replaced with a brand new refurb?

nothing's stopping them.

*waits for the moral police to show up*
 
And THAT would be the reason I would pay a tad more for new. Buying "used" things sans warranty unnerves me, unless I'm getting a SUBSTANTIAL deal on it.

yeah, it's a dice roll for sure. but i got a hellva deal. whoever bought the phone first bought applecare for it. the phone is covered till oct. 2012. winner winner chicken dinner!
 
I wouldn't order refurb from AT&T, but from Apple, I definitely would.


I think the only company that refurbishes iPhones is Apple. So what whould be the difference in buying them from the Apple store vs ATT?
 
I think the only company that refurbishes iPhones is Apple. So what whould be the difference in buying them from the Apple store vs ATT?

Apple refurbish the iphone then use it as replacement phone, they don't sell those refurbished. AT&T just get the used iphone, polish it cosmetically (or not, as in OP's case) and sell it. Thats the different.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.